首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Too Much Healthcare A) For people who had been awaiting the rollout of the Affordable Care Act in order to obtain health ins
Too Much Healthcare A) For people who had been awaiting the rollout of the Affordable Care Act in order to obtain health ins
admin
2022-07-18
72
问题
Too Much Healthcare
A) For people who had been awaiting the rollout of the Affordable Care Act in order to obtain health insurance for the first time, the major problem associated with American healthcare has been a lack of access to it. But for a surprising number of Americans, the greater problem may be exactly the opposite: They are receiving too much healthcare. And that’s not good news for either their wallets or their physical well-being.
B) The most recent estimate from the Institute of Medicine is that about 30 percent of total healthcare expenditures in America go toward unneeded care. Doctors, too, have acknowledged the problem: In a 2011 survey published in the Archives of Internal Medicine, 42 percent of American primary care physicians said that patients in their own practice were getting more care than necessary.
C) Excessive care typically takes the form of overabundant referrals (转诊病人) to specialists, more diagnostic tests than would be medically necessary, or too many prescriptions—but in some cases, it can extend to actual treatments or surgeries that are not clinically indicated. Richard Baron, president of the American Board of Internal Medicine, is candid (直言不讳的) about the problem. "There were and are lots of things being done in healthcare that don’t reliably benefit patients," he says.
D) From a patient perspective, it can be hard to see at first glance how too much care could be a problem. But unneeded healthcare can be physically damaging. "Anything we do in medicine and healthcare has expected benefits and harms," says Brenda Sirovich, a research associate at the VA Medical Center in White River Junction, Vermont. "Any time you have an intervention for a patient, no matter how small there is also the chance that it’s going to do some harm."
E) Even for initial screening tests that pose no risk in themselves, there’s the problem of the "downstream effect"; if the first test produces an ambiguous result or a false positive, it can lead to more invasive testing that does carry substantial risk. "As you intervene on patients who have less and less reason to intervene and less and less chance of benefiting, you still retain that probability of harming them," says Sirovich. "In a word, that is the biggest problem with doing too much—the risk of harm."
F) In some cases, the roots of the excess care are noble: Doctors just want to provide the best possible care for their patients. The operating assumption for many both inside and outside the medical field tends to be that if a little care does a little good, a lot of care will do a lot of good. Given the time constraints that many physicians are under, it can seem safest to default to over-ordering.
G) But there are several other major drivers of overutilization (过度医疗) , as well. Experts debate exactly how much the threat of lawsuits influences physicians in their practice of medicine, but physicians themselves say that fear of legal challenges is a substantial factor in motivating them to provide too much care.
H) Skeptics challenge that physicians might not be in the best position to know exactly what motivates their own behavior. But a study published in Health Affairs this summer suggests that the malpractice effect is real. According to the report, doctors who acknowledge having a strong fear of malpractice are more likely to show a pattern of ordering aggressive diagnostic tests, and they’re also more likely to refer patients to the ER (急诊室) for treatment. This makes intuitive sense: Doctors are rarely asked if they did too much, but they are constantly questioned as to whether or not they did enough—and they know they can wind up in legal trouble if patients don’t think their care was sufficient.
I) Perhaps more troubling than medical liability issues are the financial incentives inherent in the American healthcare system. Most American healthcare currently operates on a fee-for-service model, where physicians receive payment for every service performed, regardless of whether that service actually benefits the patient or not. In some cases, especially where physicians self-refer their patients for expensive diagnostic tests and treatments, there can be substantial financial incentives for ordering interventions that might not be medically necessary.
J) Several recent studies have explored whether financial incentives influence how physicians practice, and the answer, unsurprisingly, is that they do. In October, for example, a report in the New England Journal of Medicine examined the "self-referral effect" among urologists (泌尿科医生) treating patients fox prostate cancer (前列腺癌). The study found that doctors are substantially more likely to order radiation therapy for their prostate cancer patients if those doctors have ownership interests in the radiation services they are offering. Over the five-year period from 2005 to 2010, the use of radiation therapy by self-referring urologists in private practice jumped 19.2 percentage points, whereas the rate among their non self-referring peers barely budged, going up just 1.3 percentage points.
K) Jean Mitchell, a professor of public policy at Georgetown University and the author of the report, acknowledges that her study can’t ultimately speak to the motivations of the physicians involved. But she sees reason to be concerned. "There’s been this dramatic trend toward aggressive treatment of prostate cancer, even though basically the clinical data suggest that we should move away from that," she says. "The issue is that it seems like being steered toward the treatment that is going to have the most financial benefit for the urologist."
L) The self-referral effect isn’t unique to radiology. Earlier this summer, a report of the United States Government Accountability Office examined rates of referrals for biopsies (活组织检查) and found that between 2004 and 2010, referrals for biopsies more than doubled among self-referring physicians, even while they increased only 38 percent among those who referred outside their own practices.
M) As physicians, researchers, and policy experts have grown to recognize the problem of excessive care, there have been a number of attempts to combat the problem. One of the most talked-about provisions of Obama’s Affordable Care Act, for example, is the provision for Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs). Under this provision, a network of doctors and hospitals that agrees to act as an ACO receives financial incentives to figure out how to maximize quality while simultaneously reducing costs and eliminating waste in the system. The idea is to encourage healthcare networks to take more collective responsibility for population health and reward better care, rather than simply more care.
N) Physician groups are also stepping up to solve the problem. One widely publicized effort is the Choosing Wisely campaign which is set out to promote conversations between doctors and patients about utilizing the most effective tests and treatments while avoiding unnecessary care. To this end, organizers began calling on physician societies to compile lists of the top five tests and procedures in their respective specialties that were most susceptible to overuse. To date, more than 50 physician societies have joined the campaign, each contributing their own "top 5" list.
O) For Sirovich, these initiatives offer signs of hope. Fifteen years ago, she says, conversations about the harms of medical care or excessive spending weren’t likely to come up, but today, she hears more patients—and fellow physicians—talking about the harms of overuse.
P) But despite hints of change, the problem of overutilization is likely to persist for some time. After all, it took more than a century to construct the current healthcare system, and change does not come easily.
According to a 2011 study, nearly half of American primary care physicians agreed that patients may get more care than necessary.
选项
答案
B
解析
题干意为,根据一项2011年的调查研究,将近一半的美国初级护理医师承认病人们可能接受了不必要的医疗护理。根据题干中的关键词a 2011 study可定位到B段。该段第二句提到,一项2011年刊登在《内科学文献》杂志上的调查研究显示,有42%的初级护理医师表示,在他们的实际工作中,有许多患者都在接受不必要的医疗护理。由此可知,题干是对原文的同义转述,故选B。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/KMx7777K
0
大学英语六级
相关试题推荐
西柏坡原是一个普通的小山村,坐落在河北省平山县。在抗日战争时期,这里就是老革命根据地之一。自1948年5月至次年3月间,这里成为中共中央和中国人民解放军领导中国革命的中心。从这里,中国共产党走出深山,走向全国胜利,创建了中华人民共和国。西柏坡纪念馆占地
我国地域辽阔、人口众多,要解决大规模人口流动问题,最安全可靠、最快速便捷、最经济环保的交通方式就是高速铁路(high-speedrail)。高铁的诞生满足了现代社会人们生活、工作、出行节奏快的需求。自2007年修建第一条高速铁路“京津”高铁开始,几十
A、Theyareinterestedinthemarket.B、Theyareinterestedinnaturelifeandsports.C、Theycanchangethestrategyquickly.D、
A、Organisingprotests.B、Recruitingmembers.C、Actingasitsspokesman.D、Savingendangeredanimals.A根据选项,可以预测本题询问某人的工作内容。男士说他在
A、Participationinsportsisrelevanttopositiveeffects.B、Participationinsportsincreasesfemalecollegeattendance.C、Part
A、Safety.B、Comfort.C、Size.D、Cost.D选项均为名词,是关于什么事物的。对话中女士说她租车主要根据价格选择,由此可知正确答案是D)。
A、Inastudio.B、Inaclothingstore.C、Atabeachresort.D、Atafashionshow.A对话开头男士说:“欢迎你来到我们的节目。”可见对话发生在节目演播室,故答案为A。长对话开始处的
A、Operatingsystemswillcrash.B、Computernetworkswillbeattacked.C、Applicationswillbedamaged.D、Sensitiveinformationwi
A、Agenerationofwomenwillbepromotedintheirpositions.B、Anumberofexcellentwomenwillfindtheircareeropportunities.
A、Therearetoomanypeoplelivingthere.B、Thecostoflivingthereisrelativelyhigh.C、Ithasfrequentnaturaldisasters.D、
随机试题
以下哪种药物是PCOS患者促排卵治疗的首选药物
关注社会经济技术变化趋势对组织影响的人力资源管理模式称为【】
听觉中枢位于()
下列五种感染过程最常见的是
患者张某,在输液过程中突然感到胸部异常不适,随后出现呼吸困难,严重发绀,其最大可能及首要处理是()。
投资利息与会计上的财务费用不同,它包括()的利息,无论它们的来源是借贷资金还是自有资金,都应计算利息。
一般仓库主要由()和管理生活区、辅助设施等组成。
社会工作者小兰经常参与医院内有关活动的策划,按照要求,她策划的精神病患者的训练活动要()。
甲乘坐地铁,在西单下地铁时,被几个下车的小伙子挤倒摔了个跟头。甲很生气,给地铁热线打电话声称要炸地铁。接到电话后,各级领导高度重视,北京市公安局公交总队刑侦支队因此出动千人在地铁各站巡控。甲的行为构成()
在PowerPoint2003中,幻灯片放映模式为我们提供了放映时的指针效果,其中不属于“指针选项”的是()。
最新回复
(
0
)