首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
A、it is helpful to the burn victims and has other potential uses. B、the usage of the fetal tissue rationalize the practice of ab
A、it is helpful to the burn victims and has other potential uses. B、the usage of the fetal tissue rationalize the practice of ab
admin
2011-01-08
80
问题
W: Good morning, and welcome to today’s broadcast of Seeing Both Sides. Today we have something very interesting for you—a very controversial topic. Is it a moral use of technology to take advantage of fetal tissue for medical experimentation? Owing to the use of human fetal brain tissue in such studies, usually obtained from elective abortions, ethical concerns have been focused on the relationship between abortion and transplantation activities. There is no uniform code on the retrieval and use of human embryonal or fetal material for experimental and clinical research or application. Our guests today is Dr. Kim Benson, head of the Organization of Physicians for Responsible Research. We are going to discuss the moral and medical implications of this new area of research. Good morning, Dr. Benson, let’s begin by hearing the arguments in favor.
M: Well, scientifically speaking, (1) it’s clear that fetal tissue is quite a gold mine. It’s been proven to be extremely successful in grafting new tissue for use with burn victims. Research is being done into other potential uses as well.
W: It is well known that Reverend William Cooper has quite different a voice about this issue. He thinks that it is extremely important to do everything possible in terms of research to alleviate human suffering. But at the same time, (2) he also points out that people can’t ignore the fact that fetal tissue is a product of abortion, which many consider to be an act of murder. He says it is just not right to kill another person to benefit yourself, it is immoral to use the life of a fetus in this way. What do you say to Reverend Cooper’ s opinion?
M: Yes, I suppose some people could say abortion is an act of murder, (3) but it’s really important to clearly separate issues here. You can’ t ignore the fact that abortion is legal in this country at this time. Certainly, while we may recognize that as a grave human tragedy, it is a fact that it happens frequently, thousands of times every day. If this is the case, it makes good medical sense to derive any benefit from it that we can. Isn’t the tragedy perhaps minimized if this tissue can be used to further hmnan life? And, indeed, in terms of using this tissue to create new, healthy, living skin for burn victims, are we not in some small way allowing that life to continue?
W: That’s one way of looking at it. (4) However, people like Reverend Cooper have another way of looking at this issue. They think that the life of that fetus deserves every opportunity to grow and develop as an individual—that using these victims is simply adding insult to injury. Can the health interests of a living child be weighed against a child whose death is an accomplished fact, when the murderer promises to kill no more children, in fact, he promises to use the wealth derived from the murder to keep your child, and thousands like her, alive? And really, Dr. Benson, can you seriously mean to imply that the benefit this tissue provides for skin grafts for burn victims balances the fact that a human life and all its potential has been taken without its consent?
M: Maybe you have a point there, and I’m sure many people would agree with you, (5) but the flip side of the issue is that our greatest moral obligation is to the living. As long as abortion is legal, as long as those fetuses are not developing into full-fledged human life, it seems we must devote our energies to concentrating on and helping in every way possible those who are alive and suffering.
W: What exactly do you mean, Dr. Benson? Are you condoning abortion?
M: It doesn’t matter whether or not I condone it. On one hand, we could spend a great deal of time arguing about abortion. On the other hand, that would be a waste of time since our opinions here don’t change the fact that it is legal. We may as well accept the legality and go from there.
W: And questions have been raised about the morality in the use of tissue from an aborted fetus. The Washington Post published a letter from a policy expert at the Christian Medical Association. He says mistreatment of early human life can easily progress to other groups in society. Dr. Benson also offers his opinion from medical perspective. I’m sure listeners have got a lot of food for thought about this complex and controversial issue. Let’s take a short break now, and when we return we’ll take some calls from our listeners.
选项
A、it is helpful to the burn victims and has other potential uses.
B、the usage of the fetal tissue rationalize the practice of abortion.
C、the usage of fetal tissue brings a new beginning for the organ transplant.
D、the usage of fetal tissue puts an end to the tragedy of abortion.
答案
A
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/NteO777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
OncefoundalmostentirelyinthewesternUnitedStatesandinAsia,dinosaurfossilsatenowbeingdiscoveredonallsevencont
Forwelloveracentury,onestreetinNewYorkCityhasbeenknownastheheartoftheAmericantheater.Thenameofthestreet
Sincethelate1970’s,inthefaceofaseverelossofmarketshareindozensofindustries,manufacturersintheUnitedStates
WhichofthefollowingisNOTconsideredpartofsemanticchange?
1Owingtothewidespreadexpansionofcasinos,thecostofpathologicalandproblemgamblinghassoaredtonearlyhalfthe
1Owingtothewidespreadexpansionofcasinos,thecostofpathologicalandproblemgamblinghassoaredtonearlyhalfthe
A、helpfulB、reasonableC、wrongD、necessaryC
ClassicIntentionMovementInsocialsituations,theclassicIntentionMovementis"thechair-grasp".Hostandguesthaveb
Whichofthefollowingworksbestrepresentthenationalspiritofthe18th-centuryEngland?
随机试题
如果孕妇在孕期暴露于某因素与婴儿畸形的相对危险度是5,意味着
一患者因颏部粉碎性骨折导致舌后坠,引起窒息。最合理的急救方法是
()迫使操纵者应用两只手来操纵控制器,它仅能对操作者提供保护。
某月30d,绞吸挖泥船完成工程量20万m3,该船时间利用率60%,已知该船排泥管径为0.6m,泥浆浓度10%。问题:试述绞吸挖泥船基本原理。
在境外旅游的过程中,全陪应与接待社导游人员密切合作,积极妥善处理各项问题和事故,维护游客的合法权益。()
请为幼儿园大班设计一份“保护环境”的教育主题活动。
将十六进制7E8F转换为十进制数是()。
2012年2月29日,国务院常务会议同意发布新修订的《环境空气质量标准》,新标准增加了细颗粒物(PM2.5)和臭氧(O3)8小时浓度限值监测指标。下列关于PM2.5的说法,错误的是()。
下列叙述中正确的是
计算机之所以能按人们的意图自动进行工作,最直接的原因是因为采用了()。
最新回复
(
0
)