首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Every year, various organizations and magazines publish college rankings issues in their countries. These rankings often get a l
Every year, various organizations and magazines publish college rankings issues in their countries. These rankings often get a l
admin
2021-02-24
29
问题
Every year, various organizations and magazines publish college rankings issues in their countries. These rankings often get a lot of attention from the media, colleges and college-bound students and their parents. But are these rankings actually a good thing? The following excerpts are opinions from two American experts on this issue.
Write an article of NO LESS THAN 300 words, in which you should:
1. summarize both opinions, and then
2. express your opinion towards college rankings.
Excerpt 1
Philip Altbac, Research Professor in the Lynch School of Education at Boston College
College and university rankings are ubiquitous worldwide. Big decisions are made on the basis of rankings. Students and their families use them for deciding where to study, governments sometimes allocate funds on the basis of rankings and the academic community obsesses over its current score.
In today’s world of mass and competitive higher education, rankings are probably and unfortunately inevitable. But what do the rankings measure? Everything and nothing.
They claim to provide in a single score the essence of quality. But quality cannot be measured easily, and some aspects of educational performance cannot be accurately assessed at all. Research performance is most easily assessed; it is possible to count articles, grants, books and to measure the impact of work in the sciences.
Most rankings rely a lot on measures of reputation, such as asking administrators and academics what they think about various universities. These are notoriously inaccurate. No one has wide knowledge of a range of schools, particularly if asked about institutions in other countries, and subjectivity reigns supreme. Other key variables cannot be accurately gauged. Teaching quality and learning outcomes are among the most problematical—and most important.
Further, one size does not fit all in higher education. Harvard University differs immensely from Bunker Hill Community College, just a few miles away. Rankings generally measure the research universities and neglect the rest. Some of the rankings change their criteria from year to year, thus making it difficult to trace trends over time.
Excerpt 2
Paul Glastris, American journalist and political columnist
I like rankings. So do most students and parents. Rankings provide a quick and easy way for normal, busy people to visually grasp the results of assessments that are often quite complex. We rely on rankings—Zagat for restaurants, Angie’s List for contractors, Consumer Reports for just about everything else—to be our arbiters of quality and value because we don’t have the time or ability to reliably figure out all the products and services in the marketplace on our own.
This is especially true of colleges. Higher education is the biggest investment many people will ever make, and often the most fateful. College is also what economists call an "experience good"— that is, a good or service whose quality isn’t readily apparent until after you’ve consumed it It’s almost impossible to buy an experience good intelligently without some reliable third party assessment.
Though certainly not perfect, popular college rankings are a great way to sift through thousands of universities and find college options that are most in tune with an individual’s wants and needs. In the broadest sense, rankings provide a list of top colleges. This allows prospective students to identify and expand the list of potential 4-year or online schools based on quality of degree programs, majors available, career opportunities and more. For example, if a small school is your priority, you can find a list of the top ten small schools. If you’re primarily looking for a social experience, you can check out the top ten party schools.
选项
答案
College Ranking Is a Blessing The college rankings published annually by various organizations and magazines attract a lot of eyeballs. Whether such conduct is good or not? Supporters, like Mr. Glastris, take it as a beneficial information as it can help students to choose colleges that accord with their preferences conveniently, while professor Altbac attacks the rankings on their criteria which aren’t scientific enough, leading to an inaccurate evaluation of colleges. And the criteria of some rankings vary each year, making it very difficult to follow the change of rankings. Moreover, all the current rankings generally give priority to research universities and neglect others. As far as I’m concerned, college ranking is a blessing based on the following three reasons. Firstly, college rankings give people a direct and fast way of distinguishing thousands of universities around the world. As going to college is a major investment for most families, college rankings published in major media will make more data available to people who are intended to make sensible and efficient choices. Secondly, in response to the attack on the validity of the rankings, i.e. the criteria chosen, I believe that different rankings must have considered different criteria which will provide a relatively comprehensive picture on the strengths and weakness of universities. For example, there are also specialized rankings on universities such as rankings based on a specific major, employment and student satisfaction rate. As most rankings have already published their measuring criteria, people can choose which ranking to believe based on what they consider the most important factor. Thirdly, rankings at universities around the world also reveal a distribution of quality education resources around the globe. Taking a closer look at these data is crucial and helpful when the public is considering to improve global issues such as education equality and north-south gap. Armed with the three reasons above, I believe universities ranking is a blessing regardless of the uncertain criteria the rankings are conducted by. It’s advantageous to both individuals who are faced with the choice of college and the interest of the public.
解析
材料围绕“大学排名是否是好事”进行了探讨,两个选段正好是相反的观点。
选段一是反对的观点,指出这些大学排名的评估方式并不准确。首先,一所学校的教学质量并不能简单评估出来(quality cannot be measured easily);其次,这些排名大多依赖学校的声誉做判断,众所周知这是不可靠的(notoriously inaccurate)。而且这些排名多关注研究型大学而忽略其他学校,标准(criteria)也每年都不同,这些都说明排名不可靠。
选段二则是支持的观点,指出排名能够让人们迅速便捷地了解信息,而大学可以被看作是“体验式商品”,没有可靠第三方的评估(reliable third party assessment),人们很难作出选择。这些排名还能让学生根据自己的需要选择合适的大学。
开篇:概括材料,总结正反双方对大学排名的不同意见。
主体:提出自己观点——大学排名是好事,并从三方面阐述理由:
1.大学排名能让人们直观、快速的区分世界上的众多大学。
2.不同的排名有不同的参考标准,这有助于客观全面地体现大学的优缺点。
3.大学排名可以显示全球教育资源的分配情况。
结尾:总结全文,重申大学排名不仅对面临择校的个人,而且对于公众而言都是有益的。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/QBIK777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
TypesofLanguageTestingI.Placement—sortnewstudentsinto【T1】______【T1】______—testthestudent’s【T2】______ratherthansp
Whatdoyouneedtodoinordertounderstandthelecture?NowtherearefourthingsthatI’mgoingtotalkabout.Thefirstthi
沙漠里真有魔鬼吗?在那时人们的知识水平看起来,确像是有魔鬼在作怪。但是人们掌握了自然规律以后,便可把这种光怪陆离的现象说清楚。这种现象在大戈壁夏天中午是常见的。当人们旅行得渴不可耐的时候,忽然看见一个很大的湖,里面蓄着碧蓝的清水,看来并不很远。当人们欢天喜
A、Roadrage.B、Roadaccidents.C、Modernmotorists.D、Growthofhighways.A主持人在访谈开始部分就提到参加节目的嘉宾Neff会谈及roadrage的概况,而随后的访谈内容也是紧紧围绕
……合中国旧历的三伏,一年最热的时候。
我自然知道,大山有坎坷,大海有浪涛,大漠有风沙,森林有猛兽。即便这样,我依然喜欢。打破生活的平静便是另一番景致,一种属于年轻的景致。真庆幸,我还没有老。即便真老了又怎么样,不是有句话叫老当益壮吗?于是,我还想从大山那里学习深刻,我还想从大海
而后,她放下右手,仔细地把右手摊在桌子上,左手拿起一把切饼的刀,对准右手的无名指来回一锯,又来回一锯。她做得干净利落,完全不像十岁的孩子。我傻了,忘了去夺她的刀。“哦,天啊!”这是旁边的人发出的惊叹,不是我。我猛地烦躁起来,这一切太出乎
当我在小学毕了业的时候,亲友一致的愿意我去学手艺,好帮助母亲。我晓得我应当去找饭吃,以减轻母亲的勤劳困苦。可是,我也愿意升学。我偷偷地考入了师范学校——制服,饭食,书籍,宿处,都由学校供给。只有这样,我才敢对母亲提升学的话。入学,要交十元的保证会。这是一笔
最令人怵目惊心的一件事,是看着钟表上的秒针一下一下的移动,每移动一下就是表示我们的寿命已经缩短了一部分。再看看墙上挂着的可以一张张撕下的日历,每天撕下一张就是表示我们寿命又缩短了一天,因为时间即生命,没有人不爱惜他的生命,但很少人珍视他时间。如果想在有生之
何谓幸福?每个人自有不同的衡量标准,虽然幸福的结局是那样的皆大欢喜。幸福可以漾在脸上,幸福也可以写在心里,当幸福在阳光下熠熠生辉时,幸福是灼人的。为什么幸福是灼人的?因为幸福是一种力量,是千锤百炼之后提升出来的一种力量。一种踏遍阴森荆棘的勇气,一种翻越陡峭
随机试题
Thekidslayfacedownonthebeach,theirbacks()tothesun.
患者,男性,20岁,2个月前因进食冷热食物感左上后牙疼痛来医院就诊,不进食时无不适感,检查近中邻面深龋,探诊酸痛,及大量软化牙本质,无叩痛,无松动,冷测一过性疼痛。数日前,患者出现左侧头面部自发性疼痛,间歇发作,呈放射性,下列疾病中可能出现类似疼痛症状
最先考虑诊断下列治疗哪项不正确
下列哪种药涂擦后会使牙面变黑不能用于恒前牙
爪形手不会出现在( )
为及时了解全国城市商品零售价格的变动趋势,按照商品零售额排序对前35个大中型城市的商品零售价格变化情况进行调查,这种调查方法属于()。
下列属于资产类科目的是()。
对建立良好的程序设计风格,下面描述正确的是______。
以下程序运行后的输出结果是______。fun(intx){if(x/2>0)fun(x/2);printf("%d",x);}main(){fun(6);}
Whatdoesthemanimply?
最新回复
(
0
)