首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
Many philosophers have argued that people make decisions about what’s right and wrong based on moral principles and rational tho
Many philosophers have argued that people make decisions about what’s right and wrong based on moral principles and rational tho
admin
2015-09-30
21
问题
Many philosophers have argued that people make decisions about what’s right and wrong based on moral principles and rational thought. But other philosophers—and more recently, some psychologists and neuroscientists—have argued that there’s more to the story. When faced with a moral dilemma, these scholars say, we rely on emotional reactions as well as our powers of reasoning. In a study of brain damage, published today, neuroscientists report evidence that emotions indeed exert a powerful influence on moral judgments.
In the new study, Antonio Damasio of the University of Southern California in Los Angeles and colleagues examined moral reasoning in six people who had damage to the ventromedial prefrontal cortex(VMPC), a brain region that regulates emotions. The researchers presented the patients with moral dilemmas that forced them to decide whether it was acceptable to sacrifice one person’s life to save several others. For example, participants had to decide whether to flip a switch that diverts a runaway trolley from a track leading to five workers to a track leading to just one worker. The researchers also gauged the decisions of 12 people without brain damage and 12 patients with damage to brain regions unconnected to emotions.
In the trolley scenario, most people in all three groups said it was okay to flip the switch. However, the VMPC patients’ decisions diverged when the scenario required inflicting direct personal harm on one person to save several others—such as shoving a large person off a bridge to slow a trolley headed for five people. From a strictly rational point of view, it’s better to save five people instead of one, but the thought of pushing an innocent person to his death is emotionally wrenching. That may explain why only about 20% of people in the control groups said they’d push. The VMPC patients, on the other hand, made the utilitarian choice about twice as often, the researchers report online today in Nature.
The findings fit nicely with other evidence that moral judgments often involve a conflict between emotion and reason and that those two competing influences rely on different networks of brain regions, says Joshua Greene, a philosopher and cognitive neuroscientist at Harvard University. But Jordan Grafman, a cognitive neuroscientist at the National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke in Bethesda, Maryland, isn’t convinced that extreme moral dilemmas like the trolley problem evoke the same cognitive processes—and involve the same brain regions as moral judgments in the real world involve. Even so, he says, the study "emphasizes that disciplines other than philosophy can contribute to issues related to moral behavior. "
The trolley problem is presented to illustrate that______.
选项
A、VMPC is a brain region that regulates emotions
B、moral judgments may be influenced by emotions
C、even patients with brain damage can deal with moral dilemmas
D、it’s a tragedy to sacrifice an innocent person to save several others
答案
B
解析
本文第二、三段所引用的“trolley problem”用来说明第一段最后一句“In a study of braindamage,published today,neuroscientists report evidence that emotions indeed exert a powerfulinfluence on moral judgments”所提出的观点。所以,B应为答案。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/QWzZ777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
Ithasbeennecessarytoreferrepeatedlytotheeffectsofthetwoworldwarsinpromotingallkindofinnovation.Itshouldbe
Intheireverydaylife,mostAmericansseemtoagreewithHenryFordwhooncesaid,"Historyismoreorlessabsurdity.Wewant
Intheireverydaylife,mostAmericansseemtoagreewithHenryFordwhooncesaid,"Historyismoreorlessabsurdity.Wewant
[A]EachNewYear’sDaylotsofpeoplemakeplanstodomoreexerciseorgiveupsmoking.ButbyJanuary2ndmanyofthemhaven
Whatmaybetheattitudeofmanypublic-serviceworkerstowardsthestrategyofBlair’sgovernment?Whenmentioning"thesometh
Gingrichianpoliticiansreluctanttoaddresstheproblembecause______.Thecomputermodelsfailedtopicturerealitybecause__
Itvanishedin2002,aresultofabadfall.Asmyneurosurgeonexplained,whenmyheadhittheground,mybrainsloshedaround,
Whenadiseaseofepidemicproportionsthreatensthepublic,scientistsimmediatelygettowork,tryingtolocatethesourceof
Agreatmanycreatureshavewhatarecalledwarningcolours,thatistosay,thecolourationwarnseverycreaturethattheanima
Forthefirsttime,GeorgeBushhasacknowledgedtheexistenceofsecretCIAprisonsaroundtheworld,wherekeyterroristsuspe
随机试题
下列作品,属于悼念性散文的有
健康教育处方是以下列哪种形式提供的健康教育材料
A、肾小球毛细血管血压降低B、囊内压升高C、血浆胶体渗透压降低D、血浆晶体渗透压降低E、肾小管内溶质浓度增加静脉注射甘露醇引起尿量增加的主要机制是
A.中央前回B.颞叶C.黑质纹状体D.枕叶E.小脑帕金森病病损于
房地产开发企业销售商品房不得采取的方式是:
下列关于城市轨道交通地下工程风险管理的说法中,正确的是()。
波斯纳提出了一个教师成长的公式来概括教师成长的过程中的主要关系,即:教师成长=经验+反思。()
20世纪60年代末,国外有人把学校课程领域予以扩大,把课程分为()两大类,杰克逊和瓦兰斯就是这一观点的代表人物。
法人的概念和法律特征。
办公信息系统的基本功能包括四方面,下面哪条描述不太确切?
最新回复
(
0
)