首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
Many philosophers have argued that people make decisions about what’s right and wrong based on moral principles and rational tho
Many philosophers have argued that people make decisions about what’s right and wrong based on moral principles and rational tho
admin
2015-09-30
61
问题
Many philosophers have argued that people make decisions about what’s right and wrong based on moral principles and rational thought. But other philosophers—and more recently, some psychologists and neuroscientists—have argued that there’s more to the story. When faced with a moral dilemma, these scholars say, we rely on emotional reactions as well as our powers of reasoning. In a study of brain damage, published today, neuroscientists report evidence that emotions indeed exert a powerful influence on moral judgments.
In the new study, Antonio Damasio of the University of Southern California in Los Angeles and colleagues examined moral reasoning in six people who had damage to the ventromedial prefrontal cortex(VMPC), a brain region that regulates emotions. The researchers presented the patients with moral dilemmas that forced them to decide whether it was acceptable to sacrifice one person’s life to save several others. For example, participants had to decide whether to flip a switch that diverts a runaway trolley from a track leading to five workers to a track leading to just one worker. The researchers also gauged the decisions of 12 people without brain damage and 12 patients with damage to brain regions unconnected to emotions.
In the trolley scenario, most people in all three groups said it was okay to flip the switch. However, the VMPC patients’ decisions diverged when the scenario required inflicting direct personal harm on one person to save several others—such as shoving a large person off a bridge to slow a trolley headed for five people. From a strictly rational point of view, it’s better to save five people instead of one, but the thought of pushing an innocent person to his death is emotionally wrenching. That may explain why only about 20% of people in the control groups said they’d push. The VMPC patients, on the other hand, made the utilitarian choice about twice as often, the researchers report online today in Nature.
The findings fit nicely with other evidence that moral judgments often involve a conflict between emotion and reason and that those two competing influences rely on different networks of brain regions, says Joshua Greene, a philosopher and cognitive neuroscientist at Harvard University. But Jordan Grafman, a cognitive neuroscientist at the National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke in Bethesda, Maryland, isn’t convinced that extreme moral dilemmas like the trolley problem evoke the same cognitive processes—and involve the same brain regions as moral judgments in the real world involve. Even so, he says, the study "emphasizes that disciplines other than philosophy can contribute to issues related to moral behavior. "
The trolley problem is presented to illustrate that______.
选项
A、VMPC is a brain region that regulates emotions
B、moral judgments may be influenced by emotions
C、even patients with brain damage can deal with moral dilemmas
D、it’s a tragedy to sacrifice an innocent person to save several others
答案
B
解析
本文第二、三段所引用的“trolley problem”用来说明第一段最后一句“In a study of braindamage,published today,neuroscientists report evidence that emotions indeed exert a powerfulinfluence on moral judgments”所提出的观点。所以,B应为答案。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/QWzZ777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
Intheireverydaylife,mostAmericansseemtoagreewithHenryFordwhooncesaid,"Historyismoreorlessabsurdity.Wewant
Economics,asweknowit,isthesocialscienceconcernedwiththeproduction,distribution,exchange,andconsumptionofgoods
Advancesincomputersanddatanetworksinspirevisionsofafuture"informationeconomy"inwhicheveryonewillhave(1)_____t
Whatimpactcanmobilephoneshaveontheirusers’health?Manypeopleworryaboutthesupposedilleffectscausedbyradiation
ReduceWaste-FoodExpertsinthefoodindustryarethinkingalotabouttrashthesedays.Restaurants,colleges,hospitalsa
ReduceWaste-FoodExpertsinthefoodindustryarethinkingalotabouttrashthesedays.Restaurants,colleges,hospitalsa
Whenadiseaseofepidemicproportionsthreatensthepublic,scientistsimmediatelygettowork,tryingtolocatethesourceof
Forthefirsttime,GeorgeBushhasacknowledgedtheexistenceofsecretCIAprisonsaroundtheworld,wherekeyterroristsuspe
Lookaroundtheworldandtheforcesaremassing.OnonesideareCalifornianprisonguards,Britishpolicemen,Frenchrailworke
ThefirsttimeItriedshark-finsoupwasatTimeWarner’sannualdinnerinHongKong.Shark-finsoupisaluxuryitem($100bowl
随机试题
中国政府倡议,共建“一带一路”恪守联合国宪章的宗旨和原则,坚持开放合作、和谐包容、市场运作、互利共赢。“一带一路”秉持的理念是()
200年10月17日,周某为其子陈某投保了生死两全保险,保险期限5年,保险费于当日一次缴清。2009年12月1日,陈某因盗窃罪被判处三年有期徒刑。2009年12月20日,陈某越狱,触电网身亡。关于本事例,保险人应
酗酒可引起活性明显升高的血清酶是
一男婴,8个月。已发热惊厥3天,诊断为“化脓性脑膜炎”。下述哪项处理不当
在甲公司的破产案件中,若人民法院裁定(),当事人可以向上一级人民法院提起上诉。
根据《建设工程工程量清单计价规范》的规定,金属门窗套、石材门窗套等,按设计图示尺寸以()计算。
一个与其他领土之间的大部分贸易保持着单独税率或其他单独贸易规章的地区为“单独关税区”。()
上海黄浦江和苏州河的长度分别为()。
()是中国的第一部纪传体通史,后世学者以之为史传文学之典范。
下图表示下丘脑神经细胞、垂体细胞、甲状腺细胞及它们分泌的激素之间的关系,研究表明物质乙是一种糖蛋白。请回答下列问题。 如果用物质丙饲喂正常动物,则物质甲、乙的分泌量的变化分别是______;如果用物质乙饲喂正常动物,则物质丙的分泌量______,原因
最新回复
(
0
)