首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
"Finagle" is not a word that most people associate with science. One reason why science is so respected these days is that the i
"Finagle" is not a word that most people associate with science. One reason why science is so respected these days is that the i
admin
2011-01-02
36
问题
"Finagle" is not a word that most people associate with science. One reason why science is so respected these days is that the image of the scientist is of one who dispassionately collects data in an impartial search for truth. In any debate over intelligence, schooling, bias, energy--the phrase "science says" usually squashes the opposition.
But scientists have long acknowledged the existence of a "finagle factor"-a tendency by many scientists to give a helpful nudge to the data to produce desired results. The latest example of the finagle factor in action comes from Stephen Jay Gould, a Harvard biologist, who has examined the important 19th century work of Dr. Samuel George Morton.
Morton was famous in his time not only for amassing a huge collection of skulls but also for anything the cranial capacity, or brain size, of the skulls’ as a measure of intelligence. He concluded that whites had the largest brains, that the brains of Indians and blacks were smaller, and therefore, that whites constitute a superior race.
Gould went back to Morton’s original data and concluded that the results were an example of the finagle at work. "I have reanalyzed Morton’s data," Gould wrote last week in the journal, Science, "and I find that they are a patch work of assumption and finagling, controlled, probably unconsciously, by his conventional prior ranking."
Morton reached his conclusions, Gould found, by leaving out embarrassing data, using incorrect procedures, making simple arithmetical mistakes (always in his favour) and changing his criteria again, always in favour of his argument.
Left alone, that finding would not be particularly disturbing. Morton has been thoroughly discredited by now. Scientists do not believe that brain size reflects intelligence, and Morton’s brand of raw racism is out of style.
But Gould goes on to say that Morton’s story is only "an admittedly egregious example of a common problem in scientific work". Some of the leading figures in science are believed to have used the finagle factor.
One of them is Gregor Mendel, the Bohemian monk whose work is the foundation of modern genetics. The success of Mendel’s work was based on finding a three-to-one ratio in the dominant and recessive characteristics of hybrid plants he was breeding. He found that ratio. But scientists recently have gone back to his data and have found that the results are literally too good to be true. Like Morton, Mendel gave himself the benefit of the doubt.
And so, apparently, did Claudius Ptolemy, the Greek astronomer whose masterwork, The Almagest, summed up the case for a solar system that had the earth at its centre. Recent studies indicate that Ptolemy either faked some key data or resorted heavily to the finagle factor.
All this is important because the finagle factor is still at work. In the saccharin(糖精) controversy, for example, it was remarked that all the studies sponsored by the sugar industry found that the artificial sweeteners were unsafe, while all the studies sponsored by the diet food industry found nothing wrong with saccharin.
No one suggested that the scientists were dishonest; it was just that they quite naturally had a strong tendency to find data that would support their beliefs. The same tendency is observable in almost every Controversial area of science today-the fight over race and intelligence, the argument about nuclear energy, and so on.
It is only occasional that the finagle factor breaks out into pure dishonesty. One example seems to be the research of Cyril Burt, the British scientist whose studies were used to support the belief that intelligence is mostly inherited. It now appears that Burt invented not only a good part of his results but also made up two collaborators whose names appear on his scientific papers.
The moral that Gould draws from his study of Morton is not that scientists are wicked but that they are just human beings, like the rest of us, and so should be subjected to skepticism like the rest of us. "The culprit in this tale is a naive belief that pure objectivity can be attained by human beings rooted in cultural traditions of shared belief--and a consequent failure of self-examination," Gould said.
In other words, listen to what science has to say, but never get far away from a grain of salt.
The example of the sugar industry and the diet food industry is mainly to show that______.
选项
A、the finagle factor exerts its influence not only on scientific research but also on industrial manufacture
B、apart from scientists, manufacturers may also employ finagle factor to their advantage
C、the finagle factor cannot suggest that scientists were dishonest
D、controversy may result from the finagle factor
答案
B
解析
文章前部分讲述欺瞒因素在科研中被某些科学家广泛利用。倒数第五段第一句是该段的主题句,意思是欺瞒因素仍在起作用。随后,该段列举了制糖厂和减肥食品厂有关糖精的不同观点。作者的用意不是说该因素会导致争议,而是说除科研外,该因素也被广泛应用于制造业。因此选B。A不准确,因为它只表示欺瞒因素对科研和制造业都有影响,但是这段例子强调的是制造业有意识地利用欺瞒因素。C和D也没有表述出该段的主要意思。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/RUeO777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
A、byattendingaclassB、fromherparentsC、throughagardeningmagazineD、bylearningformherfriendA从“ThisspringItookas
Scholarandstudentshavealwaysbeengreattravelers.Theofficialcasefor"academicmobility"isnowoftenstatedinimpressi
Whichtwocountriesarelinkedbytunnelunder,theEnglishChannel?
InrecentyearsAmericansocietyhasbecomeincreasinglydependentonitsuniversitiestofindsolutionstoitsmajorproblems.
ThatLouisNevelsonisbelievedbymanycriticstobethegreatesttwentieth-centurysculptorisallthemoreremarkablebecause
Betweenabout1920to1930,newartisticmove-【M1】________.mentsinEuropeanartweremakingthemselvesf
Thethreatfromglobalwarming,hereports,"Isveryreal.Itisonlyamatteroftimebeforethetemperatureofthesurfaceof
A、Anexportsalesmanworkingoverseas.B、Anaccountantworkinginthecompany.C、Aproductionmanagerinabranch.D、Apolicyma
A、Hewasonafieldtrip.B、HewasvacationinginFlorida.C、Hewasstudyingmostofthetime.D、Hewasvacationingathome.C
A、receptionistB、managerC、customerD、cashierC
随机试题
利率风脸
男性,28岁,半小时前被车撞伤,后被送入急诊室。查体:血压60/30mmHg,神志清楚,呼吸困难,面色苍白,四肢发凉,脉搏细速。左胸部压痛,胸壁塌陷,可闻及骨擦音及反常呼吸征,左侧呼吸音消失,右侧呼吸音降低。根据病历摘要在急诊应优先申请哪些辅助检查
维生素D缺乏性手足搐搦症发生惊厥时首选的处理方法为
肺心病、心力衰竭的治疗中最主要的是
下列哪一种情况下,善意第三人不能依据善意取得制度取得相应物权?()
内燃机和机动车制造企业应当按照国家规定的内燃机和机动车(),采用节油技术,减少石油产品消耗量。
在社会主义初级阶段,所有制形式具有多元化的特点,这是因为()。
填入下列横线处的词语,最恰当的一组是()。①你______在这里住一宿,明天再回去。②这场电影______放映了三个小时。③你比他只是______差一点,其实两人不相上下。
汉朝监察京师附近州县和百官的监察机构是()。
•Readthearticleaboutpackagingandlabeling.•ChoosethebestwordtofilleachgapfromA,B,CorDthatfollow.•Forea
最新回复
(
0
)