首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
How’s this for a cynical view of science? (46)"A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making th
How’s this for a cynical view of science? (46)"A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making th
admin
2012-07-06
86
问题
How’s this for a cynical view of science? (46)
"A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it. "
Scientific truth, according to this view, is established less by the noble use of reason than by the stubborn exertion of will. One hopes that the Nobel Prize-winning physicist Max Planck, the author of the quotation above, was writing in an unusually dark moment.
(47)
And yet a large body of psychological data supports Planck’s view; we humans quickly develop an irrational loyalty to our beliefs, and work hard to find evidence that supports those opinions and to discredit, discount or avoid information that does not.
In the laboratory, this is labeled confirmation bias; observed in the real world, it’s known as pigheadedness. Scientists are not immune. In an experiment, psychologists were asked to review a paper submitted for journal publication in their field. They rated the paper’s methodology, data presentation and scientific contribution significantly more favorably when the paper happened to offer results consistent with their own theoretical stance. Identical research methods prompted a very different response in those whose scientific opinion was challenged.
This is a worry. Doesn’t the ideal of scientific reasoning call for pure, dispassionate curiosity? Doesn’t it positively shun the ego-driven desire to prevail over our critics and the prejudicial urge to support our social values? Perhaps not. (48)
Some academics have recently suggested that a scientist’s pigheadedness and social prejudices can peacefully coexist with — and may even facilitate — the pursuit of scientific knowledge.
Let’s take pigheadedness first. (49)
In a much discussed article this year in Behavioral and Brain Sciences, the cognitive scientists Hugo Mercier and Dan Sperber argue that our reasoning skills are really not as dismal as they seem.
They don’t deny that irrationalities like the confirmation bias are common. Instead, they suggest that we stop thinking of the primary function of reasoning as being to improve knowledge and make better decisions. Reasoning, they claim, is for winning arguments. And an irrational tendency like pigheadedness can be quite an asset in an argumentative context.
And what about scientists’ prejudices? Clearly, social values should never count as evidence for or against a particular hypothesis. However, the philosopher of science Heather Douglas has argued that social values can safely play an indirect role in scientific reasoning. Consider: The greater we judge the social costs of a potential scientific error, the higher the standard of evidence we will demand. Deciding which are the "better" criteria or the "better" background assumptions is not, Ms. Douglas argues, solely a scientific issue. It also depends on the social values you bring to bear on the research.
For all its imperfections, science continues to be a stunning success. (50)
Yet maybe progress would be even faster and smoother if scientists would admit, and even embrace, their humanity.
[487 words]
选项
答案
在《行为和脑科学》今年发表的一一篇颇受争议的文章里,认知科学家雨果·梅尔西埃和丹·斯比贝指出,人类的推理能力其实并不像其表现的那样差劲。
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/YMp4777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
BycitingexamplesofwomenemploymentinSweden,theauthorintendstoshowthatThestate-fundedchildcareandmaternitypol
BycitingexamplesofwomenemploymentinSweden,theauthorintendstoshowthatBysaying"noparadiseiswithoutitsparadox
WirelesstechnologyisintroducedasFromtheauthor’spointofview,theWi-Fitechnology
WhatdoNationalSemiconductor,MaxwellHouseCoffee,DeloitteTouche,andHearstMagazineshaveincommon?Alltheseorganizati
WhatdoNationalSemiconductor,MaxwellHouseCoffee,DeloitteTouche,andHearstMagazineshaveincommon?Alltheseorganizati
WhatdoNationalSemiconductor,MaxwellHouseCoffee,DeloitteTouche,andHearstMagazineshaveincommon?Alltheseorganizati
The20thcenturymayhavebeentheageofscientificadvancementbut,asthenewmillenniumbegins,(1)_____worldhealththepr
The20thcenturymayhavebeentheageofscientificadvancementbut,asthenewmillenniumbegins,(1)_____worldhealththepr
The20thcenturymayhavebeentheageofscientificadvancementbut,asthenewmillenniumbegins,(1)_____worldhealththepr
随机试题
执法人员当场作出的行政处罚决定,必须报所属行政机关备案。()
A.医疗用毒性药品B.药品类易制毒化学品C.非处方药D.处方药零售药店不得经营的药品是
【背景资料】某5000t级混凝土方块码头,结构断面如图3所示。基槽的底质为风化岩。底层方块平行码头前沿线方向长度为4980mm。码头基床采用常规的潜水员人工整平方法,基床顶面在方块前趾处预留500mm沉降量,并预留0.6%倒坡。施工中,项目部严格
会计数据是指在会计工作中从不同渠道取得的,记录在各种“单”、“证”、“账”、“表”上的原始资料。()
当咖啡价格急剧下降时,在其他条件不变的情况下,对茶叶的需求将()。
甲公司成立于2012年5月18日,法定代表人为李某。6月5日,甲公司财务人员张某持有关资料到Q银行开立基本存款账户。8月6日,甲公司从乙公司购进一批价值260万元的货物,果用支票方式付款。9月12日,甲公司向P银行申请贷款,P银行审查符合贷款条件后向其发放
下列关于研究与开发战略意义表述错误的有()。
著名的遗忘曲线最先由()提出。
[2007年MPA真题]如果王教授是历史学家,又深入研究过夏商周三代历史,则他一定是中国的历史学家。这个断定是根据以下哪项作出的?
在考生文件夹下,打开文档WORD1.DOCX,按照要求完成下列操作并以该文件名(WORD1.DOCX)保存文档。【文档开始】高校科技实力排名由教委授权,uniranks.edu.cn网站(一个纯公益性网站)6月7日独家公布了1999年
最新回复
(
0
)