首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
According to the professor, why does Sartre reject most Western approaches to ethics?
According to the professor, why does Sartre reject most Western approaches to ethics?
admin
2018-08-16
124
问题
According to the professor, why does Sartre reject most Western approaches to ethics?
Listen to part of a lecture in a philosophy class.
Professor So what is ethics? Well, ethics is the study of what is right and wrong, good and bad. The great ethical thinkers have concentrated on what makes an act right, what makes it wrong and what are our duties, what are our obligations. These are the typical questions that you encounter in the study of ethics.
Let’s introduce Jean Paul Sartre—the French philosopher. It is pretty clear that Sartre rejects most of the approaches to ethics in the history of Western philosophy, approaches to ethics that try to ascertain the fundamental principles of morality. For example, the English philosopher Joan Stuart Mill in the 19th Century did exactly that. He said what is the most basic and fundamental principle of right and wrong, and he came up with his theory of utilitarianism. Utilitarianism claims that an act is right if it promotes the greatest happiness for the greatest number of people, so if the way a person chooses to act benefits as many people as possible, if no other action could benefit more people, then the person has acted rightly. Mill’s theory and other major teachings in Western ethics seek to provide principles, rules that we ought to follow, basic guidelines for human action.
And Sartre rejects this emphasis on rules. To explain why, he gives an example that has become very famous: a young Frenchman during the Second World War is trying to figure out what to do. This young man lives alone with his mother, and his mother relies on him, so he feels an obligation to take care of her. But on the other hand, France is at war, so the man also feels an obligation to help protect his country. What should he do? If he stays home the benefit is pretty certain, he could continue to help his mother, but she is only one person if he joins the French resistance and helps defend his country, he could probably help more than one person, but then again, he might die in the first moment of battle and in effect, help no one at all. Possibly he could help a lot of people by joining the resistance, but not definitely. So Mill would tell this young man: do what will promote the greatest happiness of the greatest number. But which of these two actions—staying home or joining the resistance—would promote the greatest happiness of the greatest number? There is simply no way to answer the question.
You could say, well, maybe there is some other rule or principle that would work here; what if I am simply out for my own game? I am going to do what is in my best interest. Would that tell our young Frenchman what to do? So, what is in his own best interest? To help his mother, or to help is country? Again, there is no way to answer the question based on principles alone. Sartre actually tried to answer this question, using many different ethical principles. Well, the result in each case was that there are no ethical principles that will settle the issue for the young man. Finally, the man just has to decide and he must take responsibility for his decision. That is the tough reality of it.
Ethical philosophers from the beginning of Western thought have offered us principles, but these principles don’t give us real decision making procedures. And they don’t address the idea of taking responsibility for our actions and the consequences of our actions. Taking personal responsibility, being held accountable for what we do. This is a core concept in Sartre’s philosophy.
Student: But can we interpret Mill’s ethical theory to mean that there are multiple choices that are all equally good?
Professor: Well, certainly you might claim that. In some cases, it’s ethically or morally indifferent what you do. Neither choice is preferable; each one is permissible. But still, "What do I do?" Knowing that an act is permissible is not telling me to do it. I still have to choose, I have to pick one option over another. Of course the case of the young Frenchman is not an everyday experience, but it certainly drives home Sartre’s point. All of us are in a predicament of making decisions every day, and most of us probably think there is a right and a wrong, that there is some ethical principle out there that will tell us what to do, but that sort of principle in itself doesn’t give us much practical guidance. Sartre would argue that this is true in all cases.
选项
A、They are too complex to be understood by average citizens.
B、They do not provide people with a practical way to make decisions.
C、They do not take into account personal preferences.
D、They have not met the needs of society since the Second World War.
答案
B
解析
细节题。萨特尝试使用不同标准来解决问题,但仍旧无法指导进行如何选择,由此指出传统西方哲学道德准则的问题:Ethical philosophers from the beginning of Western thought have offered us principles,but these principles don’t give us real decision making procedures.即道德准则并没有给出人们如何做选择的程序或步骤,因此B选项是正确答案。该部分未提到西方哲学道德准则过于复杂而不能被普通人理解的缺点,讲座中也未陈述该方法未考虑到个人偏好,因此A和C选项不正确。教授并未陈述道德标准无法满足二战后的社会需求,因此D选项不正确。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/YNfO777K
0
托福(TOEFL)
相关试题推荐
Completethesentencesbelow.WriteNOMORETHANTHREEWORDSforeachanswer.ThedataJuliefoundonpastexperimentsisin___
Whatisthedesiredoutcometoeachofthefollowingcourseofaction?ChooseFIVEanswersfromtheboxandwritethecorrectle
Completethesentencesbelow.WriteONEWORDONLYforeachanswer.Graphicwritingsystemsareofgreatimportanceinthesubje
Choosethecorrectletter,A,BorC.Dogsarechosenaccordingto
ChooseTHREEletters,A-ETheinventionofdifferentgearsonabicycleaffectedwhichTHREEofthefollowing?AWheelsizeBBa
Whichadvantageismentionedforeachofthefollowingrestaurants?ChooseSIXanswersfromtheboxandwritethecorrectletter
Completethenotesbelow.WriteONEWORDforeachanswer.PotterynotesEarthenwareadvantages:-po
Whatproblemsdothespeakersidentifyforthisproject?ChooseSEVENanswersfromtheboxandwritetheletters,A-H,nexttoq
Whatadvantagedoesthespeakermentionforeachofthefollowingphysicalactivities?ChooseSIXanswersfromtheboxandwrite
WhatinformationdoesAnniegiveaboutskiingoneachofthefollowingmountaintrails?ChooseFOURanswersfromtheboxandwri
随机试题
配菜的重要性在于_______。
教育调查研究,按照调查目的来划分,可分为()
急性化脓性阑尾炎术后,7天拆线,切口无红肿、无渗液、无压痛,记录为
在图5-47所示xy坐标系下,单元体的最大主应力σ1大致指向()。
A公司的2015年度财务报表主要数据如下:该公司适用的所得税税率为25%,股利支付率为60%,假设债务资本均为5年期、每年付息一次的平价债券。该公司股票2015年12月31日的市盈率为20倍,股利的固定增长率为3.73%。要求:计算该公司2015
下列各项中,属于会计基本职能的有()。
实施培训课程的管理,应当包括()。
注:①费用均值按当年价计算;②次均门诊费用指门诊病人次均医药费用。人均住院费用指出院病人住院期间人均医药费用,日均住院费用指出院病人住院期间日均医药费用。2014—2015年全国医院次均门诊费用,“按当年价格上涨”不同于“按可比价格上涨”的幅度,主要影
目前,多数商业银行考核体系中的核心指标是()。
世界上有很多种野生动物面临着绝种的危险。印度尼西亚生活在保护区内的天堂鸟,70年代末还有500来只,现在只剩下55只;海豹正从北海消失;非洲野狗面临灭绝的威胁,估计南非现在仅残存350只;上个世纪非洲共有1000万头大象,而现在幸存下来的野象可能只有40万
最新回复
(
0
)