首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
In politics, in the courts, even on the ubiquitous TV talk show, it is good form to pick an intellectual fight. People attack ea
In politics, in the courts, even on the ubiquitous TV talk show, it is good form to pick an intellectual fight. People attack ea
admin
2016-01-30
57
问题
In politics, in the courts, even on the ubiquitous TV talk show, it is good form to pick an intellectual fight. People attack each other — hurl insults, even — and it counts as logical argument. I cannot understand it. It seems that our society favors a kind of ritualized aggression. Everywhere you look, in newspapers and on television, issues are presented using the terminology of war and conflict. We hear of battles, duels and disputes. We see things in terms of winners and losers, victors and victims. The problem is society’s unquestioning belief in the advantages of the debate as a way of solving disagreements, even proving right from wrong.
Our brainwashing begins early at school, when the brightest pupils are co-opted onto the debating system. They get there because they can think up a good argument to support their case. Once on the debate team, they learn that they earn bonus points for the skill with which they verbally attack, or insult, the opposing team. They win if they can successfully convince the audience that they are right, even if the case they are arguing is clearly consensual. They do this by proving themselves to be stronger, brighter, more outrageous, even. The training in this adversarial approach continues at our tertiary institutions. The standard way to present an academic paper, for instance, is to take up an opposing argument to something expressed by another academic. The paper must set out to prove the other person wrong. This is not at all the same thing as reading the original paper with an open mind and discovering that you disagree with it.
The reverence for the adversarial approach spills over into all areas of life. Instead of answering their critics, politicians learn to sidestep negative comments and turn the point around to an attack on accusers. Defense lawyers argue the case for their clients even when they suspect they may be guilty. And ordinary people use the same tactics — just listen to your teenager next time you pull him up for coming home late. You can be sure a stream of abuse will flow about your own time — keeping, your irritating habits, your history of bad parenting.
Unfortunately, the smarter your kid, the better his or her argument against you will be. You’ll be upset, but you’ll comfort yourself that those teenage monsters of yours will one day turn into mature, though adults who can look after themselves — by which you mean, of course, they will be able to argue their way out of sticky situations.
It’s not that you should never use angry words, or take up a position in opposition to someone or something. There are certainly times when one should take a stand, and in such cases strong words are quite appropriate; if you witness injustice, for instance, or feel passionately about another’s folly. Mockery — so cruel when practiced on the innocent — can be very useful in such situations. There is no better way to bring down a tyrant than to mock him mercilessly.
What I dislike is the automatic assumption most people have when it comes to disagreements: they should attack, abuse, preferably overpower their opponent, at whatever the cost. The approach is to so ingrained that "compromise" has become a dirty word. We feel quality if we are conciliatory rather than confrontational. We have trained ourselves, or been brainwashed into believing, that to be pleasant is a sign of weakness.
But just think how easy it can be to persuade a "difficult" person to be considerate of you or your wished when you are pleasant to them, and unthreatening. Give them a way out of a potentially aggressive situation without losing face, and they will oblige you willingly.
Discuss a subject without taking an adversarial position and you will find the other person happy to explore the possibilities with you. I ’m prepared to bet on it. You’ll get closer to the truth of the matter than you would by going to each other hammer and tongs.
The author’s tone in this passage can be best described as______.
选项
A、objective
B、formal
C、critical
D、ironic
答案
D
解析
作者态度题。本文作者在讨论“辩论”这一普遍的社会现象时,用了很多如favor,advantage,reverence.the smarter…the better…等褒义词,但事实上,他并不欣赏以“辩论”解决问题,由此可见,本文带有很浓的讽刺意味,因此只有选项D最恰当地描述了文章的语气。选项C最具干扰性,因为本文确实在评论“辩论”这一做法,但critical倾向于指“严厉批判”或“挑刺找茬”,这与文章中用词轻快的特点是不相符的,因此选项C不如选项D恰当。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/chGO777K
0
考博英语
相关试题推荐
Inrecentyears,therehasbeenasteadyassaultonsaltfromthedoctors:saltisbadforyouregardlessofyourhealth.Politi
(浙江大学2008年试题)Sincetheearly1930s,Swissbankshadpridedthemselvesontheirsystemofbankingsecrecyandnumberedaccou
Inamaterialisticand______societypeople’sinterestseemstobefocusedsolelyonmonetarypursuit.(中国科学院2008年试题)
(复旦大学2010年试题)Businessandgovernmentleadersconsidertheinflationratetobeanimportantgeneralindicator.Inflationis
AreweatthebeginningofanotherAgeofExploration?Perhapsevenmoreimportant,areweatthebeginningof【C1】______AgeofC
Anumberofresearchershavewrittenabouta"hiddencurriculum"inschools,definedasthesubtleinfluencesonstudentsthatr
Althoughsomeschoolsarepostponingnewprojectsbecauseofthefalteringeconomy,othersareforgingaheadwithplanstoemula
Itisapleasuretoseemenofacertainageworryingabouttheirweight.Listeningtothemisnotsuchapleasure.Becausethe
Mostreadersunderestimatetheamountofrewritingitusuallytakestoproduceaspontaneousreading.Thisisagreatdisadvanta
TheEskimoisperhapsoneofthemosttrustingandconsiderateofallIndiansbutseemstobe_____thewelfareofhisanimals.
随机试题
自我实现人假设是以马斯洛的_______和_______为基础的。
患者大失血后,肌热面赤,烦渴欲饮,舌质淡,脉洪大而虚。治宜选用( )。
A.黄酮B.异黄酮C.二氢黄酮D.二氢黄酮醇E.黄酮醇黄酮类化合物C环氢谱(1H-NMR)的化学位移值(6值)可用于鉴别各类黄酮,指出具如下C环特征吸收为哪种黄酮
护士对患者保密不包括()。
某建设工程项目施工采用了施工总承包方式,其中的幕墙工程、设备安装工程分别进行了专业分包。对幕墙工程施工质量实施监督控制的主体是()等。
当基金管理人认为兑付投资者的赎回申请有困难,或认为兑付投资者的赎回申请进行的资产变现可能使基金份额净值发生较大波动时,基金管理人可以在当日接受赎回比例不低于上一日基金总份额()的前提下,对其余赎回申请延期办理。
2015年8月甲企业以吸收方式合并乙企业,合并业务符合特殊性税务处理条件。合并时乙企业净资产账面价值1100万元,市场公允价值1300万元,弥补期限内的亏损70万元,年末国家发行的最长期限的国债利率为4.5%。2015年由甲企业弥补的乙企业的亏损额为(
某有出口经营权的生产企业(增值税一般纳税人),2016年1月从国内购进生产用的钢材,取得增值税一般纳税人开具的增值税专用发票,注明价款368000元,并通过主管税务机关认证。按规定计算的进料加工贸易进口免税料件的组成计税价格为13200元;当月内销货物取得
________主要包括市场对产品或服务需求的数量、价格、质量、区域分布的历史、现状和发展趋势等相关信息。
河南省是我国重要的苹果和花卉产区,其产品远销国内外。近年来,河南省花卉种植面积逐渐扩大的主要原因是()。
最新回复
(
0
)