首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
Scientists have long argued over the relative contributions of practice and native talent to the development of elite performanc
Scientists have long argued over the relative contributions of practice and native talent to the development of elite performanc
admin
2016-01-30
52
问题
Scientists have long argued over the relative contributions of practice and native talent to the development of elite performance. This debate swings back and forth every century, it seems, but a paper in the current issue of the journal Psychological Science illustrates where the discussion now stands and hints—more tantalizingly, for people who just want to do their best—at where the research will go next.
The value-of-practice debate has reached a stalemate. In a landmark 1993 study of musicians, a research team led by K. Anders Ericsson found that practice time explained almost all the difference(about 80 percent)between elite performers and committed amateurs. The finding rippled quickly through the popular culture, perhaps most visibly as the apparent inspiration for the "10,000-hour rule" in Malcolm Gladwell’s best-selling "Outliers" —a rough average of the amount of practice time required for expert performance.
The new paper, the most comprehensive review of relevant research to date, comes to a different conclusion. Compiling results from 88 studies across a wide range of skills, it estimates that practice time explains about 20 percent to 25 percent of the difference in performance in music, sports and games like chess. In academics, the number is much lower—4 percent—in part because it’s hard to assess the effect of previous knowledge, the authors wrote.
One of those people, Dr. Ericsson, had by last week already written his critique of the new review. He points out that the paper uses a definition of practice that includes a variety of related activities, including playing music or sports for fun or playing in a group. But his own studies focused on what he calls deliberate practice: one-on-one lessons in which an instructor pushes a student continually, gives immediate feedback and focuses on weak spots. "If you throw all these kinds of practice into one big soup, of course you are going to reduce the effect of deliberate practice," he said in a telephone interview.
Zach Hambrick, a co-author of the paper of the journal Psychological Science, said that using Dr. Ericsson’ s definition of practice would not change the results much, if at all, and partisans on both sides have staked out positions. Like most branches of the nature-nurture debate, this one has produced multiple camps, whose estimates of the effects of practice vary by as much as 50 percentage points.
What is the author’ s attitude towards the practice-nature debate?
选项
A、Disinterested.
B、Objective.
C、Critical.
D、Unconcerned.
答案
B
解析
本题问作者对关于天赋和练习争论的态度。文章第一段引出话题,第二段介绍了认为练习更重要的研究者的观点:第三段介绍了新论文与以往截然不同的结论。第四段阐述了认为练习更重要的学者对新论文观点的评价。最后一段介绍了两个阵营研究结果差异之大。由此看出,作者对此争论的态度是客观的,故B项“客观的”为正确答案。A项“不感兴趣的”,C项“批评的”,D项“不关心的”,均不符合题意,故排除。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/icsZ777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
Astheoilindustrygearsupfortheongoingoffshore-oilboom,scientistswhostudytheseafloorsaycompetitionforscarcedr
Oneofthemoststartlingthingsaboutthepost-crisislandscapeishowtone-deafthewealthiestAmericansremaintooutrageove
Oneofthemoststartlingthingsaboutthepost-crisislandscapeishowtone-deafthewealthiestAmericansremaintooutrageove
DoesWallStreetowethepeopleofAmericaanapology?ThatwasSenatorSherrodBrown’ssuggestiontoBenBernankeandHankPaul
Doctors’sloppyhandwritingkillsmorethan7,000peopleannually.It’sashockingstatistic,and,accordingtoaJuly2006repo
【F1】Formorethanacentury,afewscientistshaveoccasionallydaydreamedoftransformingmuchoftheSaharadesertgreen,with
ModernizationandMoralCultivation现代化与道德修养Writeanessayof160-200wordsbasedonthedrawing.Inyouressay,youshould1)d
Itmaynotbeobvious,buthearingtwolanguagesregularlyduringpregnancyputsinfantsontheroadtobilingualismbybirth.A
Humanlanguageisthesubjectofendlessscientificinvestigation,butthegesturesthataccompanyspeechareasurprisinglyneg
随机试题
“行到水穷处,坐看云起时”属借对。()
下列选项中,不属于真虚假实所致腹胀满症特点的是()(2011年第22题)
A.分水B.通关C.血堂D.三江E.太阳治疗马肝热传眼、肝经风热、中暑、脑黄宜选
雌激素的生理作用是
对于易水解的药物制剂生产中原料的水分一般控制在()。
人对时间的估计可以根据()。
海洋表层的运动主要受海平面风的牵制。信风的存在使得大量暖水被吹送到赤道西太平洋地区,而赤道东太平洋地区暖水被刮走后,主要靠海面以下的冷水进行补充,因此,赤道东太平洋海温比西太平洋海温明显偏低。当信风加强时,赤道东太平洋深层海水涌升上翻现象更加剧烈,导致海表
协议制决策:指具有同等权限的单位或部门就共同面临的问题,通过协商作出决定的决策方法。下列属于协议制决策的是:
阅读下面短文,回答下列五道题。文化,尤其是对一个民族的特点和历史走向产生过明显影响的有形文化或“雅文化”,是一种有机的活体,有她或她们的历史生命和灵魂。说一个这种意义上的文化还存在刁;存在,主要看她是否还活在某个民族或社团的现实生活中。具体的标志就是要看
A、Springandfall.B、Summerandspring.C、Winterandsummer.D、Fallandwinter.A细节辨别题谈到四个季节时,Huntington得出的结论是春秋两季最有利于人们的创造性思维。
最新回复
(
0
)