首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
In a paper just published in Science, Peter Gordon of Columbia University uses his study of the Piraha and their counting system
In a paper just published in Science, Peter Gordon of Columbia University uses his study of the Piraha and their counting system
admin
2010-05-05
74
问题
In a paper just published in Science, Peter Gordon of Columbia University uses his study of the Piraha and their counting system to try to answer a tricky linguistic question. The Piraha, a group of hunter-gatherers who live along the banks of the Maici River in Brazil, use a system of counting called "one-two-many". In this, the word for "one" translates to "roughly one" (similar to "one or two" in English), the word for "two" means "a slightly larger amount than one" (similar to "a few" in English), and the word for "many" means "a much larger amount".
This question was posed by Benjamin Lee Whorl in the 1930s. Whorl studied Hopi, an Amerindian language very different from the Eurasian languages that had hitherto been the subject of academic linguistics. His work led him to suggest that language not only influences thought but, more strongly, that it determines thought.
While there is no dispute that language influences what people think about, evidence suggesting it determines thought is inconclusive. For example, in 1972, Eleanor Rosch and Karl Heider investigated the colour-naming abilities of the Dani people of Indonesia. The Dani have words for only two colours: black and white. But Dr. Rosch and Dr. Heider found that, even so, Dani could distinguish and comprehend other colours. That does not support the deterministic version of the Whorf hypothesis.
While recognising that there are such things as colours for which you have no name is certainly a cognitive leap, it may not be a good test of Whorf’s ideas. Colours, after all, are out there everywhere. Numbers, by contrast, are abstract, so may be a better test. Dr. Gordon therefore spent a month with the Piraha and elicited the help of seven of them to see how far their grasp of numbers extended.
The tests began simply, with a row of, say, seven evenly spaced batteries. Gradually, they got more complicated. The more complicated tests included tasks such as matching numbers of unevenly spaced objects, replicating the number of objects from memory, and copying a number of straight lines from a drawing.
In the tests that involved matching the number and layout of objects they could see, participants were pretty good when faced with two or three items, but found it harder to cope as the number of items rose. Things were worse when the participants had to remember the number of objects in a layout and replicate it "blind", rather than matching a layout they could see. In this case the success rate dropped to zero when the number of items became, in terms of their language, "many".
And line drawing produced the worst results of all—though that could have had as much to do with the fact that drawing is not part of Piraha culture as it did with the difficulties of numerical abstraction. Indeed, Dr. Gordon described the task of reproducing straight lines as being accomplished only with "heavy sighs and groans".
选项
A、Gordon’s purpose in his study of the Piraha was to solve a language problem.
B、The Piraha would use the word "many" to describe the number "twenty".
C、Linguists had studied other languages before they switched to Hopi.
D、Whorl claimed that language did more than influence people’s thought.
答案
C
解析
这是一道是非判断题。依据段二句二,是Whorl而非其他语言学家研究Hopi语言,所以答案选项不符合文章内容。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/lD44777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
Nowadays,amateurphotographyhasbecomeatroublingissue.Citizensofrichcountrieshavegotusedtobeingwatchedbyclosed-
Couldyoursmartphonepreventacarfromhittingyou?GeneralMotorsandotherresearchersthinkthat’sapossibility【C1】_______
Britain’sprivateschoolsareoneofitsmostsuccessfulexports.Thechildrenofthewealthy【C1】________tothem,whetherfromC
Bypersistentandsustainedpractice,anyoneandeveryonecanmaketheyogajourneyandreachthegoalofenlightenmentandfree
Bypersistentandsustainedpractice,anyoneandeveryonecanmaketheyogajourneyandreachthegoalofenlightenmentandfree
Peoplehavebeenholdingheateddiscussionsrecentlyaboutwomen’sexperienceintheworkplace.LastmonthSherylSandberg,chie
Rememberbooks?Theywerethosepiecesofpaperwithwordsprintedonthem【C1】________inbetweentwo,sometimes,【C2】________cove
Writeanessaybasedonthefollowingpiechart.Inyourwriting,youshould1)interpretthechart,and2)giveyourcomments.
WhenIaskexperiencedcollegeteachersandadministratorstodescribehowcollegestudentshavechangedovertheyears,Ioften
Itisgenerallybelievedthatambitionmaybewellregardedif______.Fromthelastparagraphtheconclusioncanbedrawnthat
随机试题
简述孔子教育思想的历史影响。
中国历史上第一部具有资产阶级共和国宪法性质的法典是()。
要不是有他帮忙,我们不可能取得成功。
某患者,右下6缺失,行双端固定桥修复。固定桥试戴时,用力戴入后,基牙出现胀痛不适。最可能的原因是
龙胆泻肝汤的组成药物不包括
甲因故意杀死乙被某市中级人民法院一审判处死刑缓期二年执行,下列表述不正确的有()
三相异步电动机的旋转方向决定于()。
某会计人员在履行会计职责时,发现甲领导报销的单据不符合国家统一的会计制度的规定,考虑到甲领导是自己的领导,给予受理。该会计人员的行为违背了()的会计职业道德要求。
集体应当选择在两两对决中以简单多数胜出的议案,这种形式的选举规则被称为()。
秦朝的诉讼程序中,官府不予受理的有()。
最新回复
(
0
)