首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
"Physics Class" According to the discussion, what reason does the man give for rejecting string theory?
"Physics Class" According to the discussion, what reason does the man give for rejecting string theory?
admin
2012-01-14
35
问题
"Physics Class"
According to the discussion, what reason does the man give for rejecting string theory?
Narrator: Listen to part of a discussion in a physics class.
Professor Blake:
Okay, you’ll remember that when Einstein was doing his research, uh, the strong and weak forces-they hadn’t been identified yet, but still, he had some questions about the two forces that were generally
accepted at the time-electromagnetism and gravity. You see, Einstein thought that nature, or rather a
theory of nature, a good theory of nature had to be much simpler and, to use his term, more "elegant."
So he spent the next thirty years in an effort to arrive at a... a unified field theory that he assumed...
that.., that would demonstrate how these two forces were really defined by one underlying principle.
So, today, and that would be about sixty years later; a group of physicists believe that they are close Q46
to finding that principle in something called the theory of everything.
[Laughter]
That’s okay. A lot of other equally distinguished physicists are also laughing at this idea. But, anyway,
for the first time in the history of our field, we have, uh, at least, uh, a structure, a framework, with
the potential to explain every fundamental characteristic of the universe. You see, until fairly recently,
we’ve been conceptualizing the particles, that is, the protons, neutrons, electrons, quarks, and everything
else.., we’ve been viewing them as points-very tiny points. But string theory assumes that if we
could really take a look at the particles, and uh, that would have to be with technology that we haven’t
yet discovered, but if we could, then we’d see that the particles aren’t points at all but.., but strings and
these strings are looped back into themselves. Look, think of the strings like a very thin rubber band. Q47
Oh, and.., and these strings vibrate
Jim:
So everything in the universe is made up of the same thing then? It’s all a combination of... of strings?
Professor Blake:
According to the theory, yes. But of course.., we see differences, and those differences, uh, they’re
accounted for because the vibrations of the strings are different.
Jim: So in physics, you buy into the theory of everything or... or what? Professor Blake:
Well, Jim, the choice isn’t that clear. Um, not at all. There are a lot of scientists in between, and by that
I mean that they see the theory of everything in a more limited way. They think that string theory, and
understand that string theory is incorporated into the theory of everything.., um, that string theory can
explain all of the properties of the forces that cause the particles to interact and influence each other.
Yes, Ellen. Did you have a comment?
Ellen:
Well, a question, really. Wouldn’t it be true that if you understand everything about the... I think you
called it the fundamental characteristics of the universe.., so if you understand that, don’t you understand everything?
Jim:
Wait a minute. So that would mean that we know it all now and there isn’t anything else to discover,
right? Because, uh, everything is physics.., everything is just a reaction between vibrating strings.
Ellen:
I see your point, but you could.., you might look at it as a... as a... starting place to, uh, to build our
knowledge. Dr. Blake, you said that it’d be a structure, didn’t you? So we’d have to fill in a lot of information
but.., we’d have a structure to start with. In my math class we were talking about string theory
because some of the recent advances in mathematics have been possible because of string theory.
Professor Blake:
True enough. And, string theory isn’t finished by any means. It’s evolved from the beginning when we
first started to think about it and, uh, the early models that included both open strings and the closed
strings that I just described to you-the ones that look like a thin rubber band. And there’s a lot of
discussion about vibration or rather various types of vibration. Then there’s the possibility of branes-
b-r-a-n-e-s-which are kind of like closed strings with a membrane over them.
Jim:
But all of this is theoretical, right? Because we don’t have the technology to observe strings-closed or
open-and we certainly can’t verify that there are branes out there.
Ellen:
Sure. But there are some very complex and.., and.., persuasive, uh, mathematical formulas, and
they’re presented in support of the theories. It isn’t like someone’s just dreaming this up without calculations.
Jim:
But I don’t see why we should accept calculations when some of those calculations require us to think
beyond what we can observe.
Professor Blake:
And many physicists would agree with you, Jim. String theory’s unverified. Richard Feynman wrote a
very interesting book, The Character of Physical Law, and to Feynman, to him, the test of any scientific
theory has to be whether the consequences agree with the measurements we take in experiments. Of
course, that assumes that the experiment was performed correctly and, uh, that the calculations were
done without error, but anyway, I think you see the point. Ellen: So you’re saying that string theory requires further developments? Q48
Professor Blake: What do you think?
Jim:
Well, I tend to be an empirical scientist. I’m a biology major, and I just Want to take something into the Q49
lab and dissect it,
Professor Blake: Fair enough.
Ellen:
But I’m a physics major and...the idea of a theory of everything appeals to me. I know that we can’t Q50
observe strings.., yet.., but maybe that’s just a problem with the technology and.., and eventually,
we may be able to observe strings in the laboratory or... or we could find a way to observe strings in a
natural setting and...
Jim: Come on. It’s just conjecture.
Professor Blake:
Well, in fairness, any new theory has to begin as conjecture, but the real question is, can string theory
pass through the developmental stages to a point where it can be verified or rejected. And, uh, these
developments could be in the area of technology like Ellen suggests or perhaps they could be new
methods of performing calculations and, uh, deriving the mathematical predictions. What I’m going to
suggest is that we take a look at the web site that supplements your textbook. There are videos as well
as animations and it includes a really good history of string theory, uh, but that’s not why I want you to
see it. I think the site demonstrates where we need to go from here if we’re going to pursue an ultimate
theory, a... a theory of everything, if you will. And it’s fairly objective so it should provide us with some Q51
interesting data for both sides of the debate.
选项
A、There may have been errors in the mathematical calculations.
B、Strings have not been observed in a laboratory.
C、String theory does not prove the theory of everything.
D、The experiments were not performed correctly.
答案
B
解析
Strings have not been observed in a laboratory.
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/mHyO777K
0
托福(TOEFL)
相关试题推荐
Choosethecorrectletter,A,B,CorD.Writethecorrectletterinboxes9-13onyouranswersheet.Accordingtothetext,wh
Choosethecorrectletter,A,B,CorD.Writethecorrectletterinboxesonyouranswersheet.Accordingtothepassage,iti
AccordingtoMrSingh,onwhichthingdomanypeoplemakesuperficialobservations?MrSinghbelievesthatWesternmethodsplus
WhichpiechartshowstheagesoftheAsianstudentssurveyed?WhichpiechartshowsthemainreasonsAsianstudentswantedto
Theprofessorsaysthatsuperhighways______.【30】
Theprofessorsaysthatsuperhighways______.【27】
Theprofessorsaysthatsuperhighways______.【26】
TheprofessoralreadyknowssomethingaboutClarefromher______.
TheprofessoralreadyknowssomethingaboutClarefromher______.
随机试题
1)______theGrammar-TranslationMethod2)______theDirectMethod3)______theAudiolingualMethod4)______
舌癌的远处转移最多见于
八正散的功用五苓散的功用()
妊娠末期肺内功能残气量减少
资产组的认定,应当以能否独立生产产品为依据,如果几项资产的组合能独立生产产品,则应当将这些资产的组合认定为资产组。()
关于对纳税人、扣缴义务人未缴少缴税款的追征制度,下列说法正确的是()。
生:老师,书上例2中,y=x2+1与y=x2-1的图象会相交吗?师:这个问题不是很简单吗?后面的图象是前面图象往上平移2个单位长度,怎么可能相交呢?怎么看书的!问题:你认为学生问的问题可能是因为学生在哪一方面不清楚?教师的回答是否妥当?
法律规定当事人不服行政机关的具体行政行为.可以向人民法院起诉,也.-]r2申请复议并由复议机关作最终裁决的,如果当事人既提起诉讼又申请复议.且法院和复议机关同时收到有关材料的,下列关于确定管辖权的说法中,正确的是()。
继发性龋形成的原因如下,除外()。
产品/服务资源的生命周期有四个阶段,分别是需求、获取、经营和管理、回收或分配。其中决定需要多少产品和资源,获取它们的计划,以及执行计划要求的度量和控制的阶段是
最新回复
(
0
)