首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Kathryn Harrison is a wonderful writer. It seems important to get that on the table right away, since for most readers, her name
Kathryn Harrison is a wonderful writer. It seems important to get that on the table right away, since for most readers, her name
admin
2013-10-08
25
问题
Kathryn Harrison is a wonderful writer. It seems important to get that on the table right away, since for most readers, her name will elicit one fact: Kathryn Harrison wrote a memoir about having slept with her father. Back in 1997, that notoriously hyper publicized book, "The Kiss"—in which she recounted an affair she had in her 20’s with the father she had not seen since she was a child—set critics scratching furiously at the welts it raised in the culture, largely neglecting the book in the process for its lurid cover story. Skip to next paragraph
In the hubbub, few pointed out that "The Kiss" is a pretty terrific memoir. Poetic and compressed, it is not a pointed finger, or an artless blurt, but a grimly hypnotic horror story, making human what might in other hands seem merely grotesque. That’s Harrison’s particular gift as a writer; and while her output, from memoirs and essays and novels, has been of varying quality, she has continually circled around her central, obsessive themes: narcissism, family violation, sexual taboo and physical suffering. For better or worse, this is a writer who veers toward what others find distasteful; in her novels, she has found parallel torments everywhere in history, from foot-binding in China ("The Binding Chair") to the Inquisition ("Poison").
The setting of "Envy" is less exotic. Will Moreland, a New York psychoanalyst, thinks at once too much and too little. His son has died. His twin brother—a world-famous swimmer—is estranged. His wife is distant. In fact, everything in this grief-stained but otherwise normal existence feels a little distant, and Will himself appears, if not precisely unreliable, then slightly clueless. In his struggle to wriggle out from his own anxieties, his remarks can seem like witty meta-comments on the narrative itself: "Yes, he’s obsessed with sex. How else could he escape the inside of his head, where every thought refuses to be fleeting and instead waits its turn to be hyperarticulated, edited, revised and then annotated like some nightmare hybrid of Talmudic commentary and Freudian case study?"
In the spellbinding opening chapters, Will attends his college reunion and confronts an old girlfriend who may or may not have gotten pregnant by him years back. The ex is a grade-A wench, and their run-in is a startling rat-a-tat of mutual accusation. "Ironic that she’d become a dermatologist," Will thinks. "She’d always had a personality like a rash, itchy, chafing, the kind of woman who just won’t let you get comfortable." She ends the scene (and it does feel like a scene—the best elements of "Envy" are its most theatrical) with the fair-enough remark, "You are an excellent example of why it is that people think shrinks are nuts."
The pages that follow ignore this electric showdown, or at least repress it. There’s a lot going on here, perhaps too much: a married couple drifting apart in grief, tension between Will and his philandering father, identical twins with non identical faces, a patient whose seductive behavior spills insistently over the edges of her shrink’s couch. And despite Will’s agitated attempts to interrogate the meaning of his life, he is surrounded by people who would prefer that he stop his inquiries immediately. As much detective as psychoanalyst, he’s too blinded by over thinking to give in to his own intuition.
Then abruptly, with one traumatic sexual sequence, these disparate story lines cohere to reveal a new pattern: a Rorschach plot, in essence. The book’s muted family problems become elements in a Greekish tragedy, one filled with the tropes of sexual violation for which Harrison is best known. It’s like one of those souvenir 1950’s pens that tilt upside down to strip an innocent cheesecake model to her pornographic double, and Harrison’s witty, lucid, poetic sentences do carry us quite a long way through passages rife with the kind of ickiness bound to alienate some readers and rivet others.
Unfortunately, her consistently skillful descriptions aren’t quite enough to make the novel pay off in the end. As heightened as this hidden plot turns out to be, it is frustratingly formulaic at its deepest level. It’s a dream horror that finally feels all too dreamlike, too embeddedly symbolic to have the pang of real life. And when the villain of the book is unmasked—and there is a villain, as blackhearted as a medieval troll—it’s disappointing to find a sociopath standing behind that particular door. So rank an antagonist renders the whole question of analytical motivation moot: the human flaws of the other characters pale by contrast; their struggles seem weightless next to such grave crimes.
Still. there are standout moments here, mainly in the most chaotic and unmediated confrontations: the sequences, especially, in which a waifish, tattooed, sardonic, compulsively sexual graduate student is transformed into the world’s most disturbing therapy patient. What finally marks the book is Harrison’s abandonment of the tragic mode. After a series of lurid turns that would leave most families in seizures of distress, her characters do not collapse, or brutalize one another. Instead, they fulfill Will’s deepest psychoanalytic desires, and confess—reeling out monologues far less con vincing than the showdowns that came before. We are left with the loving attempts of well-meaning people to heal their wounds. In real life, that would be a beautiful ending; but in a novel soaked so deeply in horror, it feels too much like wishful thinking.
Which one is not true?
选项
A、Kathryn Harrison’s novels are not accepted
B、Kathryn Harrison shocked people with her personal experiences
C、Kathryn Harrison didn’t adhere to tragedy
D、Will Moreland’ family has some troubles
答案
A
解析
虽然他的小说没有为他带来许多现实利益,但并不是说哈里森的作品不被人们所接受。故选A。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/nQZO777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
SomeAspectsoftheResearchNeedtoBalanceI.TheproblemA.Whatkindofproblem:bothinterestingand(1)______B.Howtof
Whichisthemostpossiblereasonforsuchadisaster?
InDecember1653,byanInstrumentofGovernment,OliverCromwellbecame______oftheCommonwealthofEngland.
Anumberofcollegesanduniversitieshaveannouncedsteeptuitionincreasesfornextyear—moresteeperthanthecurrent,very(
Moststudiessuggestthatwhenwomenandmenshoulddothe(1)______samejobandhavetheexperience,payratestendtobesimi
Manyofthehomeelectricgoodswhichareadvertisedasliberatingthemodernwomentendtohavetheoppositeeffect,sotheys
不管是好习惯还是坏习惯,都是逐渐养成的。当一个人重复做某件事时,一种看不见的力量驱使他去重复做同一件事,这样就养成了习惯。习惯一旦形成,要改掉它是网难的,有时是不可能的。所以,我们在形成习惯的时候要小心谨慎,这一点是非常重要的。小孩子常常会养成坏习惯。这些
记忆是人类有别于禽兽的标志之一。对心灵,它有时是沉重的负担,有时又是无法估价的财富。人们时而巴不得没有它,时而又十分稀罕。它能冲破时空局限,使生活从平面变为多棱多角。一个人可以游遍天下山山水水,然而梦境里出现的,往往不是什么名川佳境,而是幼年走过
DorothyThompsonandRebeccaWestwerecareerwomenlongbeforethetermhadbeeninvented.Inthe1930s,whenThompsonandWest
InAmericanliterature,the18thcenturywastheageoftheEnlightenment.______wasthedominantspirit.
随机试题
病为黄疸,症见黄色晦暗,食少纳呆,脘闷腹胀,神疲畏寒,大便不实,舌淡苔白腻,脉濡缓。其最佳方剂为:
患者,女,53岁,已婚。带下量多,色黄,阴道灼热干涩,腰膝酸软,妇科检查:阴道潮红,萎缩变薄。治疗首选药物是
甲市乙区卫生局在一次餐馆卫生检查中,发现ABC三家餐馆不符合卫生标准,此后分别对这三家进行了行政处罚,据此回答下列两个问题:餐馆B向法院提起行政诉讼,被告向法院提交了鉴定结论、现场笔录和该餐馆帮工丙的证言等证据。下列哪些说法正确?()
美国房地产经纪人出现()现象与行为要暂停或吊销牌照。
关于以人为本的含义,下列叙述不正确的是()。
工程项目的质量终检存在一定的局限性,因此施工质量控制应重视()。
在经济学中,关于充分就业的含义是指()。
幼儿教育是______的重要组成部分,是我国学校教育和______的奠基阶段。
下列词语中,没有错别字的一项是:
SpeakerA:What’stherateforsendingapackageofbookssurfacemailtoJapan?SpeakerB:______
最新回复
(
0
)