首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Game Theory: Climate Talks Destined to Fail A modestly successful outcome from the latest round of international climate cha
Game Theory: Climate Talks Destined to Fail A modestly successful outcome from the latest round of international climate cha
admin
2012-07-11
19
问题
Game Theory: Climate Talks Destined to Fail
A modestly successful outcome from the latest round of international climate change negotiations in Cancun,Mexico,has supporters breathing a huge sigh of relief.
After last year’s session in Copenhagen, Denmark, most governments and activists were put on the defensive to prove that multilateral action on global warming was even possible. They now feel justified.
But even as optimism strengthens ahead of the next year’s major conference in South Africa,one famous predictor says it’s still more likely that we’ll see a repeat of Copenhagen’s performance toward the end of 2011.
Last year, Bruce Bueno de Mesquita, a New York University professor and partner in a Manhattan consultancy, famously predicted the flat outcome at Copenhagen in an article he penned for Foreign Policy magazine,one month before that conference began.
Confidence in the computer model he designed that led to that conclusion informs his views on where the talks are headed next;Namely,multilateral negotiations will not fix the climate change problem, regardless of what U. N. officials and others claim.
"It’s depressing, it is what it is,but unfortunately it was right," Bueno de Mesquita said in an interview. " We got nothing out of Copenhagen. "
Bueno de Mesquita makes a living by calculating the likely outcomes to various scenarios under the lens of game theory,a mathematical tool political scientists use to better understand how power relationships inform various strategies in negotiations. By applying numerical values to the influence and attitudes of actors, he has used his private software to accurately predict the outcome of elections, foreign aid spending decisions and the Copenhagen talks.
" Universal treaties have one of two qualities," Bueno de Mesquita said in explaining the modeling. "They don’t ask people to change what they’re doing,and so they’re happy to sign on...or it asks for fundamental changes in behavior and it lacks monitoring and punishing provisions that are credible. "
His main argument: Governments probably won’t conclude a major international treaty to reduce atmospheric concentrations of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases, ever. And even if they do, any such treaty won’t actually work.
Thus the essence of the Kyoto Protocol (京都议定书) ,now scheduled to expire at the end of 2012, he said. That agreement was achieved because developing countries don’t have to do anything to comply, and thus happily signed on,while developed countries were satisfied that they faced no actual punishment for not meeting their emissions reduction targets. And even then, the United States felt compelled to later leave the treaty, a further indication of the difficulty of the climate change problem, said Bueno de Mesquita.
Industrial nations act individually,but public support weakens
In other words Just because climate change is a serious problem doesn’t mean politicians will come together to actually do something about it,he said. First and foremost,leaders will,by and large,act on what keeps them in power or helps them to get re-elected, and promising their constituents light economic pain now for vaguely understood benefits years into the future isn’t a winning formula.
" People have a tendency to slide too easily from the facts of a matter to the political response as if the facts simply dictate what politicians do because politicians are going to do what is good for society," said Bueno de Mesquita. "It’s a nice thought;unfortunately,it’s not how it happens. Politicians are out for politicians. "
The modeling he led his students through last year,using the same methodology that has made his New York firm, Mesquita & Roundell LLC, a success, predicts that over the next 30 to 40 years, developed nations will gradually adopt emissions standards more strict than those called for under Kyoto Protocol in fits and starts.
At the same time,real public support for these moves will gradually weaken. That’s because emissions rates will continue to increase in Brazil,India and other rapidly developing nations,more than offsetting any cuts achieved in the richer world.
Although negotiators are aiming for steep cuts in emissions by 2050, the computer model predicts that by this time, the world will come to realize that multilateral efforts simply aren’t working. And by the end of the century," political will for tougher regulations will have dried up almost completely," Bueno de Mesquita writes in his Foreign Policy piece.
The reasoning behind the model is spelled out in Bueno de Mesquita’s 2009 book The Predictioneer’s Game: Using the Logic of Brazen Self-interest to See and Shape the Future. A Central Intelligence Agency assessment says his methodology is 90 percent accurate.
Peter Wood, a mathematician and fellow at the Australian National University who studies how game theory applies in climate negotiations,sees an inherent prisoners’ dilemma at work here. "Climate negotiations themselves are not a prisoners’ dilemma,but addressing greenhouse gas emissions in the absence of international coordination is very similar to a prisoners’ dilemma,leading to a sub-optimal outcome ," Wood explained. "This is because (almost) every country wants global emission reductions,but would prefer that someone else take on the burden. "
So then why did the Montreal Protocol work?
Wood isn’t as fatalistic as Bueno de Mesquita’s model. He believes a new global treaty can be achieved by December 2011, or at the very least a set of individual agreements along the lines spelled out at Cancun—money for adaptation in the developing world, an anti-deforestation strategy, and other steps. The key is to overcome the free-rider problem by incorporating the appropriate incentives that will get nations to cooperate.
" One way that this could work is to link cooperation on climate change with cooperation on other issues ,such as trade," said Wood. " If a country introduces a carbon price, it may also want to introduce a ’ border tax adjustment’ on emissions-intensive imported goods. "
The NYU professor agrees that mankind can eventually solve the problem,just not along the lines governments are currently attempting to.
"The nature...of international,global treaties is that they almost always fail to do anything," he said. " People get so caught up in the flowery words they don’t focus, from my point of view, on where they might have a political shot at being successful. "
There’s no logical basis in the famous saying that " global problems require global solutions," he says, contending that a series of localized, grass-roots or unilateral initiatives can add up to a solution if pursued appropriately.
Bueno de Mesquita would even like to apply his game theory modeling again,to see if it can provide clues as to why some multilateral agreements, like the Montreal Protocol, do work. Unfortunately, no government or institution seems interested, he says, perhaps fearful of the conclusions that would be reached.
"Actually,I,with colleagues in Germany and Netherlands,put in several grant proposals to do that,and not just to do that but also to identify strategies for improving outcomes," he said. "We never get funded. "
What do governments and activists think of multilateral action on global warming?
选项
A、They think it is possible.
B、They defend against it.
C、They think it may achieve a successful outcome.
D、They think nations should sigh for it.
答案
A
解析
本题考查政府和活动家们是如何看待针对全球变暖的多方行动的。定位句指出,在去年的哥本哈根会议以后,大多数政府和活动家都要去证明此多方行动是可行的。A)是对原文的同义转述,故为本题答案。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/oYE7777K
0
大学英语六级
相关试题推荐
A、Hecan’trememberpeoplebysight.B、Hecan’trememberpeoplebyname.C、Hehasaterriblememoryforfootball.D、Hehasahar
PartⅡReadingComprehension(SkimmingandScanning)Directions:Inthispart,youwillhave15minutestogooverthepassageq
It’ssaidveryfewchildrensurvivedcancerbeforethe1970s.【B1】______treatmentsnowshowhopsoflong-termsurvivalforalmos
Accordingtoamuch-reportedsurveycarriedoutin2002,Britainthenhad4.3millionclosed-circuittelevisioncameras(CCTV)--
Thehumanbraincontains10thousandmillioncellsandeachofthesemayhaveathousandconnec-tions.Suchenormousnumbersus
Autism(儿童自闭症)isaseriousmentalillness,especiallyofchildren,inwhichonebecomesunabletocommunicateorformrelation
Autism(儿童自闭症)isaseriousmentalillness,especiallyofchildren,inwhichonebecomesunabletocommunicateorformrelation
Peoplehavewonderedforalongtimehowtheirpersonalitiesandbehaviorsareformed.Itisnoteasytoexplainwhyoneperson
Thecomplaintwouldbemore______ifhecouldremembermorespecificdetails.
Wehadexperiencedaperiodof______economicboomanddepression.
随机试题
患者男性,65岁,发现下睑硬结1个月余。体检发现硬结在睑缘皮肤黏膜移行处,边界不规则,边缘质硬隆起。完善相关检查,肿瘤仅有局部侵犯,没有淋巴结及远处转移,取细胞学眼睑鳞状细胞癌。正确的治疗原则是
男性,52岁。因咳嗽、痰血伴体重减轻2个月就诊,检查发现右肺上叶空洞性病变,洞壁光整,疑为结核。结核病空洞的特征应是
A.组织接种单位销毁B.立即停止销售C.对该疫苗依法查封、扣押D.采取应急处置措施依照《疫苗流通和预防接种管理条例》的规定接到质量可疑疫苗报告的药品监督管理部门应()
生产经营单位对重大危险源应当登记建档,进行定期检测、评估、监控,并制定应急预案,告知从业人员和相关人员在紧急情况下应当()。
某企业年赊销收入为360元,信用条件为“2/10,n/30”时,预计有20%的客户选择现金折扣优惠,其余客户在信用期付款,变动成本率为60%,资金成本率为8%,则应收账款占用资金的应计利息为()元。(1年按360天计算)
2017年3月11日,甲公司签发一张商业汇票,收款人为乙公司,到期日为2018年9月11日,甲公司的开户银行P银行为该汇票承兑。2018年6月30日,乙公司从丙公司采购一批货物,将该汇票背书转让给丙公司,丙公司9月30日持该汇票到其开户银行Q银行办理委托收
政府制定或调整重大劳动关系标准应当贯彻“三方原则”,其中“三方”指的是()。
全国人大代表,在全国人大闭会期间非经()的许可,不受逮捕或刑事审判。
关于假释,下列选项正确的是
在考生文件夹下,打开文档WORD1.docx,按照要求完成下列操作并以该文件名(WORD1.docx)保存文档。【文档开始】认识AGF8X要想深入认识AGP8X,让我们先来说说AGP总线这个话题吧。我们知道最初的
最新回复
(
0
)