首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Linguists have understood for decades that language and thought are closely related. Humans construct reality using thought and
Linguists have understood for decades that language and thought are closely related. Humans construct reality using thought and
admin
2011-05-29
92
问题
Linguists have understood for decades that language and thought are closely related. Humans construct reality using thought and express these thoughts through the use of language. Edward Sapir and his student Benjamin Whorl are credited with developing the most relevant explanation outlining the relationship between thought and language, the Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis. The hypothesis consists of two parts, linguistic relativity and linguistic determinism. Supporters of linguistic relativity assume that culture is shaped by language. Terwilliger defines linguistic determinism as the process by which "the functions of one’s mind are determined by the nature of the language which one speaks." In simpler terms, the thoughts that we construct are based upon the language that we speak and the words that we use. In its strongest sense, linguistic determinism can be interpreted as meaning that language determines thought. In its weakest sense, language partially influences thought. Whorl was careful to avoid authoritative statements which would permanently commit him to particular position.
Because of the broad nature of his statements, it is difficult to distinguish exactly to what extent Whorf believes that language determines thought. Heated debate among modern linguists demonstrates that disagreement exists about the accuracy and correctness of Whorf’s studies and of the actual level of influence of language on thought processes.
The Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis essentially consists of two distinct statements connecting the relation of thought and language. Whorf believes that humans may be able to think only about objects, processes, and conditions that have language associated with them. The Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis also explains the relationship between different languages (French, English, German, Chinese, and so on) and thought. Whorl demonstrated that culture is largely determined by language. Different cultures perceive the world in different ways. Culturally essential objects, conditions and processes usually are defined by a plethora of words, while things that cultures perceive as unimportant are usually assigned one or two words. Whorf developed this theory while studying the Hopi Indian tribe. Whorl was amazed that the Hopi language has no words for past, present, and future. The Hopi have only one word for flying objects. A dragonfly, an airplane, and a pilot are defined using the same word. Whorl questioned whether or not the Hopi view the world differently than western peoples. After further interpretation and analysis he concluded that the Hopi have a sense for the continuum of time despite having no words to specifically describe past, present, and future.
It is commonly believed that the Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis possesses some truth, but the extent to which it is applicable to all situations is questioned. Linguists generally sup port a "strong" or a "weak" interpretation. Linguists who study the hypothesis tend to cite examples that support their beliefs but are unable or unwilling to refute the opposing arguments. Examples exist that strengthen the arguments of everyone who studies the hypothesis. Nobody has gained significant ground in proving or refuting the hypothesis because the definitions of Sapir and Whorl are very vague and incomplete, leaving room for a significant amount of interpretation.
Which of the following criticisms is often made of the Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis?
选项
A、It has no empirical evidence in its favor.
B、It is formulated on the basis of only one case study.
C、Its applicability has been greatly exaggerated.
D、No convincing examples can be found to support its claim.
答案
C
解析
本题的依据句是第四段第一句的“It is commonly believed that... all situations is questioned.”从中可知,人们普遍认为Sapir-Whorf假设具有,定的真实性,但对该学说能否适用于所有情况提出了质疑,后半句实际上暗指有人对该假设的用途过分夸大提出了批评。因此正确答案为C。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/qh6O777K
0
考博英语
相关试题推荐
•Readtheannualreportaboutacompany.•Choosethebestwordtofillineachgap,fromA,BorC.•Foreachquestion(29-40
Lookatthegraphsbelow.Theyshowunemploymentineightdifferentregionscomparedtothenationalaverage.Whichregiond
Thevegetativeformsofmostbacteriaarekilledbydryinginair,althoughthedifferentspeciesexhibitpronounceddifferences
Computersmayonedayturnnightintoday—withgoodold,naturalsunlight.Giantcomputer-controlledmirrors,thousandsoff
Becausealcoholisasolvent,itisacomponentofmanyliquidmedicines.
Urbancongestionwouldbegreatlyrelievedifonlythe______chargedonpublictransportweremorereasonable.
A theincidenceofmesotheliomaisextremelylowB whichmayextendfrom25to30yearafterinitialexposureC whereasthel
Youmust______yourself,ortheywillcontinuetobullyyou,soyouwillgoonlivingindisgrace.
Althoughoftenextremelycriticalofthemedicalprofessionasawhole,peoplearerarelywillingtotreattheirpersonaldoctor
Thinkaboutwhatwouldmakeyoureally,reallyhappy.Moremoney?Wrong.Smiling,well-adjustedkids?Wrongagain.Thefactisw
随机试题
小明、小亮和小兰三个人的信息是:他们来自甲、乙、丙三个不同的地方,他们学的专业各不相同,分别是经济、行政管理和英语中一个。另外,小明的专业不是经济,小亮的不是英语,学经济的不是来自乙地,学英语的来自甲地,小亮不是来自丙地。由此可知道,小明的专业是
罗马法由习惯法向成文法发展的重要里程碑是()
A.浓缩丸B.滴丸C.蜡丸D.大蜜丸E.水丸溶散时限在2h内的丸剂是
某工程项目设计人员根据业主的使用要求,提出了A、B、C共3个设计方案。有关专家决定从5个方面(分别以F1~F5表示)对不同方案的功能进行评价,并对各功能的重要性分析如下:F3相对于F4很重要,F3相对于F1较重要,F2和F5同样重要,F4和F5同样重要。
【2015交通银行】Makesurethetableissecurelyanchored.
核冬天是用于描述大量核武器爆炸时可能对大气带来灾难性影响的名词。核爆炸时产生大火,释放的热量可能会引起强大的推动力,将灰黑色的燃烧产物带到同温层区域,这将导致全球几年内温度都很低,甚至在夏天也较低。从这段话可知()。
制约反应指当两事物经常同时出现时,大脑对其中一事物的记忆会附带另外一事物。根据上述定义,下列不涉及制约反应的是()。
结合材料回答问题:材料1二十年实践,二十年探索。“一国两制”事业前无古人,需要在实践中不断探索完善。二十年来,在不断应对和处理各种新情况新问题的过程中,中央政府和香港特别行政区深刻地认识到:继续推进“一国两制”事业,必须全面准确理解和贯
阅读下列说明,回答问题1至问题6,将解答填入答题纸的对应栏内。【说明】某大学搭建了一套视频直播系统,用于在全校范围内通过校园网直播学校的一些会议、晚会和示范课程。直播过程中产生的相关音视频被保存在大容量存储设备中,用于日后供学校师生下载观看。
Itisnaturalforyoungpeopletobecriticaloftheirparentsattimesandtoblamethemformostofthemisunderstandingsbetw
最新回复
(
0
)