首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Being Objective on Climate Change [A]Last week, Craig Rucker, a climate-change skeptic and the executive director of a nonprofit
Being Objective on Climate Change [A]Last week, Craig Rucker, a climate-change skeptic and the executive director of a nonprofit
admin
2018-07-24
25
问题
Being Objective on Climate Change
[A]Last week, Craig Rucker, a climate-change skeptic and the executive director of a nonprofit organization called the Committee for a Constructive Tomorrow(CFACT), tweeted a quotation supposedly taken from a 1922 edition of the Washington Post: "Within a few years it is predicted due to ice melt the sea will rise & make most coastal cities uninhabitable. " The intent, of course, was to poke fun at current headlines about climate change.
[B]Rucker’ s organization is a member of the Cooler Heads Coalition, an umbrella organization operated by the Competitive Enterprise Institute, a nonprofit organization that prides itself on its opposition to environmentalists. Rucker himself is part of a network of bloggers, op-ed writers, and policy executives who argue that climate change is either a hoax or an example of left-wing hysteria. Surfacing old newspaper clips is one of their favorite games. They also make substantive arguments about climate policy, but the sniping may be more effective. There is no stronger rhetorical tool than ridicule.
[C]In this case, Rucker’ s ridicule seems misplaced. After spending a few minutes poking around online, I was able to find both the Washington Post article and the longer source material that it came from a weather report issued by the U. S. consul in Bergen, Norway, and sent to the State Department on October 10, 1922. The report didn’ t say anything about coasts being inundated(淹没). This isn’ t surprising. Scientists were smart back then, too, and they knew that melting sea ice wouldn’ t appreciably raise sea levels any more than a melting ice cube raises the level of water in a glass.
[D]Rucker ultimately corrected his tweet once commenters pointed out the misquote. Through Twitter, he informed me that he had taken the line from a Washington Times op-ed by Richard Rahn, a senior fellow at the Cato Institute. When I contacted Rahn’s office, a press representative acknowledged that Rahn had copied the quote from other bloggers and columnists: the fabricated sentence appears in articles at reason. com and texasgopvote. com. The fabricated line seems to have been inserted around 2011, but the original article has been circulating online since 2007.
[E]The statement about rising sea levels aside, 1922 really was a strange period in the Svalbard archipelago(群岛), the area described by the weather report. The islands lie halfway between Norway and the North Pole, at a latitude that puts them several hundred miles farther north than Barrow, Alaska. "The Arctic seems to be warming up," the report read. In August of that year, a geologist near the island of Spitsbergen sailed as far north as eighty-one degrees, twenty-nine minutes in ice-free water. This was highly unusual. The previous several summers had likewise been warm. Seal populations had moved farther north, and formerly unseen stretches of coast were now accessible.
[F]What are we to take from this historical evidence? A central tenet for Rucker and his colleagues may be today’ s sea-ice retreat, warming surface temperatures, and similar observations are short-lived anomalies of a kind that often happened in the past—and that overzealous scientists and gullible(易受骗的)media are quick to drum up crises where none exist. Favorite examples include numerous newspaper articles from the nineteen seventies that predicted the advent of a new ice age. In fact, it’ s possible to find articles from nearly every decade of the past century that seem to imply information about the climate that turned out to be premature or wrong.
[G]The 1922 article has been quoted repeatedly by Rucker’ s comrades-in-arms since its 2007 rebirth in the Washington Times. For nearly that long, scientists have been objecting. Gavin Schmidt, a climate modeler and the deputy director of the NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies, points out that what was an anomaly in 1922 is now the norm: the waters near Spitsbergen are clear of ice at the end of every summer. More important, long-term temperature and sea-ice records indicate that the dramatic sea-ice retreat in the early nineteen-twenties was short-lived. It also occurred locally around Svalbard—the unusual conditions didn’t even encompass the whole Norwegian Sea, let alone the rest of the Arctic.
[H]Over the weekend, after retracting his previous tweet, Rucker posted a link to a blog item about a different article, this one a 1932 New York Times story. The eighty-year-old headline reads, "The Next Great Deluge Forecast By Science: Melting Polar Ice Caps to Raise the Level of the Seas and Flood the Continents. " That one sounded juicy, and, indeed, this time the text was correct: that really is what the headline said. Ironically, the quotation researcher cited in the piece was a German scientist named Alfred Wegener, who has sometimes been considered a hero of climate-change deniers for a completely different reason. Wegener is known for proposing the phenomenon of continental drift starting around the First World War. The idea was ridiculed before gaining acceptance in the nineteen-sixties, once ample evidence had been amassed. Wegener’s life story, then, is used to support the idea that the small number of researchers in the field who downplay the risk of anthropogenic climate change will one day prevail.
[I]In reality, the potential for anthropogenic global warming was being discussed earlier than continental drift, and took even longer to gain wide acceptance. The versatile Professor Wegener was a geophysicist and polar researcher who spent much of his career studying meteorology in Greenland, and trying to unlock the secrets of the Earth’ s past. His elevated place in the current climate-change debate is abstracted from history.
[J]In any case, it’ s not clear that the bloggers linking to the 1932 article read much beyond the headline. The article does discuss a collapse of the ice sheets that would raise sea levels by more than a hundred feet—but it says that event lies thirty to forty thousand years in the future. There’ s nothing wrong with examining old newspaper articles for clues about climate conditions in the past. Legitimate climate researchers look at historical documents of all kinds. However, a good-faith effort to arrive at the truth would not rely on cherry-picking catchy headlines. It would require considering the context and looking at all the evidence. At the very least, it wouldn’ t allow for deliberate distortions. A prediction that the ice caps might melt by the year 42000 is hardly all example of climate alarmism.
The dramatic sea-ice retreat in the early nineteen-twenties didn’t last for a long time.
选项
答案
G
解析
题干大意:20世纪20年代早期发生的剧烈海冰撤退现象没有持续很长时间。由题干中的“dramatic sea-ice retreat in the early nineteen-twenties”可以定位到文中G段第四句话。第四句提到“长期的温度和海冰记录都表明20世纪20年代早期发生的剧烈海冰撤退是短期的,而且只发生在斯瓦尔巴群岛周围”,与题干相吻合。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/rD47777K
0
大学英语四级
相关试题推荐
A、Theygenerallyholdbadfeelingstowardstheirbirthparents.B、Theydonotwanttohurtthefeelingsoftheiradoptiveparent
A、Heenjoysitverymuch.B、Hefeelsitstressfulbuthewillcontinue.C、Heisconsideringtochangehisjob.D、Heisnotsatis
ShocktreatmentA)TheobjectiveofAmerica’sAffordableCareActof2010—commonlyknownasObamacare—wastoensurethatthe40m-
ShocktreatmentA)TheobjectiveofAmerica’sAffordableCareActof2010—commonlyknownasObamacare—wastoensurethatthe40m-
Banksareembarkingonaradicaloverhaul(改革)ofthewaytheypaytheirseniorexecutivesbyconsideringhowtheycanlinktheir
A、Certificatesofdeposit.B、Savingsaccount.C、Moneymarketfunds.D、Creditunions.C短文最后说:“然而,货币市场基金可能不像其他存款一样受联邦政府的保证。”与此相符的是
A、Theyhavetroubleinmoving.B、Theyhavetroubleinspeaking.C、Theyhavetroubleinsleeping.D、Theyhavetroubleinbreathin
Themorewomenandminoritiesmaketheirwayintotheranksofmanagement,themoretheyseemtowanttotalkaboutthingsforme
随机试题
为保护焊工眼睛不受弧光伤害,焊接时必须使用镶有特制防护镜片的面罩,并按照()不同来选用不同型号的滤光镜片。
患者突然昏仆,不省人事,牙关紧闭,口噤不开,两手握固,面赤身热,气粗口臭,躁扰不宁,舌苔黄腻,脉弦滑而数。问题l:其诊断是
患者,男,28岁。于2年前曾患慢性肾炎,近1年来常有颜面及眼睑水肿、贫血。经医院尿检:有蜡样管型及尿蛋白(+++),内生肌酐清除率为30ml/min。查体:心肺(—),皮肤瘙痒。血压1.50/98mmHg(20/13kPa)。提示病情危急的症状是
下列关于房地产抵押的表述中,正确的有()。
船舶吨税由地方税务局负责征收管理。()
幼儿情绪的一般特点是易冲动、易变化、易受感染和易外露。()
根据下列文字资料回答问题。根据联合国艾滋病规划署公布的最新统计数字,截至2005年底,全球估计共有3860万名艾滋病病毒感染者,其中女性达1750万,15岁以下的儿童230万。统计还发现,2005年全球新增艾滋病病毒感染者410万,另有280万人
如果将信号检测论的模型与传统的阈限测量相比较,就会发现传统的阈限测量实际上假设()
科学发展观的实质是( )
以太网(Ethernet)是一种计算机局域网技术,由美国Xerox等公司研发并推广。以太网协议定义了一系列软件和硬件标准,从而将不同的计算机设备连接在一起。以太网技术规范是一个工业标准,下列选项中不属于其技术规范的是()。
最新回复
(
0
)