A、Neutral. B、Cautious. C、Favorable. D、Negative. C

M: We’re having a debate on advertising Thursday evening and I have to take part.
W: That’s interesting. I should like to hear what people think about advertising.
M: [1]What’s there to say? We must have advertising, mustn’t we?
W: Why?
M: Well, [2]we wouldn’t know what there was to buy if we didn’t have advertisements.
W: Yes, that’s true up to a point. Advertisements provide information that we need. If someone has produced a new article, naturally, the seller wants to tell us about it.
M: Yes. And the advertisements tell us which product is the best.
W: Do they? I don’t think so. Every manufacturer says that his product is the best or at least tries to give the impression. [2]Only one can be the best, so the others are misleading, aren’t they?
M: Well, in a way, I suppose. But we don’t have to believe them, do we?
W: Are you saying that advertisements aren’t effective? I don’t think that intelligent businessmen will spend millions of dollars on advertising if nobody believes the advertisements, do you?
M: Perhaps not. But after all, it’s their money that they are spending.
W: Is it? I think not. The cost of advertising is added to the price of the article. [3]You and I and all the other people who buy the article pay for the advertising.
M: Well, I suppose we get something for our money... some information.
W: Yes, [2]but don’t forget it’s often misleading information, and sometimes harmful.
M: Harmful?
W: [4]What about advertisements designed to persuade young people to smoke cigarettes? Wouldn’t you say they are harmful?
M: You’ve given me a lot to think about. I’m quite looking forward to the debate now.
1. What’s the man’s attitude towards advertisements?
2. What do we know about advertisements according to the woman?
3. In the woman’s opinion, who paid the money spent on advertisements?
4. Why does the woman say advertisements are sometimes harmful?