首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
For more than 2,000 years, a liberal education has been the ideal of the West—for the brightest, if not for all, students. The t
For more than 2,000 years, a liberal education has been the ideal of the West—for the brightest, if not for all, students. The t
admin
2016-08-19
34
问题
For more than 2,000 years, a liberal education has been the ideal of the West—for the brightest, if not for all, students. The tradition goes back to Plato, who argued in The Republic that "leadership should be entrusted to the philosopher". More recently, in a World War II-era treatise, a Harvard University committee concluded that a liberal education best prepared an individual to become "an expert in the general art of the free man and the citizen. "The report, which led to the introduction of Harvard’s general education curriculum, concluded,"The fruit of education is intelligence in action. The aim is mastery of life. "
In recent years, the fruit has spoiled and such high-sounding rhetoric has been increasingly challenged. Critics have charged that liberal arts education is elitist education, based on undefined and empty shibboleths. Caroline Bird, social critic and author, argues in The Case Against College that the liberal arts are a religion, "the established religion of the ruling class. "Bird writes, "The exalted language, the universalistic setting, the ultimate value, the inability to define, the appeal to personal witness...these are all the familiar modes of religious discourse. "
Students in the 1960s charged that such traditional liberal arts courses as "Western Thought and Institutions" and" Contemporary Civilization" were ethnocentric and imperialistic. Other students found little stimulation in a curriculum that emphasized learning to both formulate ideas and engage in rational discourse. They preferred, instead, to express themselves in experience and action: they favored feeling over thought, the nonverbal over the verbal, the concrete over the abstract. In the inflationary, job-scarce economy of the 1970s,many students argue that the liberal arts curriculum is "irrelevant" because it neither prepares them for careers nor teaches them marketable skills. In its present form, moreover, liberal arts education is expensive education.
Partly in response to these charge and, more immediately to faculty discontent, Harvard recently approved a redesigning of the liberal arts program. Faculty had complained that the growing numbers and varieties of courses had "eroded the purpose of the existing general education program. "Students, they felt, could use any number of courses to satisfy the university’s minimal requirements, making those requirements meaningless. The new core curriculum will require students to take eight courses carefully distributed among five basic areas of knowledge. The Harvard plan proposed to give students " a critical appreciation of the ways in which we gain knowledge and understanding of ourselves. "Plausible as this credo may be, it rests on rhetoric and not solid research evidence— like curriculum innovations of the 1960s.
In an era of educational accounting and educational accountability, it would be helpful to have a way of determining what the essential and most valuable" core" of a university education is and what is peripheral and mere tradition. What are the actual effects of a liberal education, this most persistent of Western ideals? It is sobering to realize that we have little firm evidence.
Against this background, we recently designed and carried out a new study to get some of the evidence. Our findings suggest that liberal arts education does, in fact, change students more or less as Plato envisioned, so that the durability of this educational ideal in western civilization may not be undeserved. In our research, liberal education appears to promote increases in conceptual and social-emotional sophistication. Thus, according to a number of new tests we developed, students trained in the liberal arts are better able to formulate valid concepts, analyze arguments, define themselves, and orient themselves maturely to their world. The liberal arts education in at least one college also seems to increase the leadership motivation pattern—a desire for power, tempered by self-control.
We started our study from two fundamental premises: first, that the evidence to date was probably more a reflection of the testing procedures used than of the efficacy of higher education: and, second, that new tests should be modeled on what university students actually do rather than on what researchers can easily score. If liberal education teaches articulate formation of complex concepts, then student research subjects should be asked to form concepts from complex material and then scored on how well they articulate them, rather than being asked to choose the "best"of five concepts by putting a check mark in one of the boxes. Any study of the effects of higher education has the difficult task of distinguishing educational effects from simply maturational effects. In order to have some control over the effects of maturation, therefore, we tested students who were receiving three different kinds of higher education: A traditional four-year liberal arts education at a prestigious Eastern US institution: A four-year undergraduate program for training teachers and other professionals: A two-year community college that offers career programs in data processing, electronics, nursing secreta-rial skills, and business administration.
At all three institutions, last-year students scored higher than first-year students, but seniors at the liberal arts college far outdistanced their counterparts at the teachers’ and community colleges.
What did the author think of the Harvard’s efforts in redesigning liberal arts program?
选项
A、It was carefully designed and therefore should prove effective.
B、It spoiled the purpose of the present general education program.
C、It enabled students to appreciate the ways they gained knowledge.
D、It was not any better than their earlier attempts in effect.
答案
D
解析
推断题。第四段最后两句指出,哈佛建议教给学生“批判性地评价获取知识、理解自身的方法”。这个想法可能看似有理,但实际上是夸夸其谈,因为它缺乏有说服力的研究证据,这很像20世纪60年代的课程改革。由此可知,作者对哈佛改革不以为然,故[D]为答案。作者对改革持否定态度,[A]和[C]是正面肯定,故排除;文中没有提到改革破坏现在一般教育项目的教学目标,因此排除[B]。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/uP7O777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
Theincreaseininternationalbusinessandinforeigninvestmenthascreatedaneedforexecutiveswithknowledgeofforeignl
Theincreaseininternationalbusinessandinforeigninvestmenthascreatedaneedforexecutiveswithknowledgeofforeignl
ItisthroughtheTreatyofWaitangiin______thattheUnitedKingdomestablishedBritishsovereigntyinNewZealand.
AndrewCarnegie,knownastheKingofSteel,builtthesteelindustryintheUnitedStates,and,intheprocess,becameoneof
Manypeopledreamofhavingasmarterbrain.PrincetonneurobiologistJosephZ.Tsienfoundthekey.InSeptemberheannounced
Asthe20thcenturybegan,theimportanceofformaleducationintheUSincreasedThefrontierhadmostlydisappearedandin191
Theterm"leadership"isoneofthemostdifficultinan【M1】______educationaladministration.Tosome,aleaderissimpleonew
记忆是人类有别于禽兽的标志之一。对心灵,它有时是沉重的负担,有时又是无法估价的财富。人们时而巴不得没有它,时而又十分稀罕。它能冲破时空局限,使生活从平面变为多棱多角。一个人可以游遍天下山山水水,然而梦境里出现的,往往不是什么名川佳境,而是幼年走过
最令人怵目惊心的一件事,是看着钟表上的秒针一下一下地移动,每移动一下就是表示我们的寿命已经缩短了一部分。再看看墙上挂着的可以一张张撕下的日历,每天撕下一张就是表示我们的寿命又缩短了一天。因为时间即生命。没有人不爱惜他的生命,但很少有人珍视他的时间。如果想在
学问要有根底,根底要打得平正坚实,以后永远受用。初学阶段的科目之最重要的莫过于语文与数学。语文是阅读达意的工具,国文不通便很难表达自己,外国文不通便很难吸取外来的新知。数学是思想条理之最好的训练。其他科目也各有各的用处,其重要性很难强分轩轾,例如体育,从一
随机试题
跨国公司采取快速的组织吞并手段来改变竞争地位的战略是()
治疗疱疹性口炎的常用药物是
类风湿性关节炎的关节特点为
心绞痛疼痛发作时典型心电图表现是
下面五个选项中,正确的有()。
【2001年第157题,2010年第122题】砂土地基上的一般建筑,对其在施工期间能完成的沉降量的估计,可以认为:
阅读以下文字,完成以下问题。“微创”外科一词顾名思义,要比“腔镜”“小切口”“小径路”“内镜”外科更为广泛,它是要达到造成最小的创伤(局部及全身)的外科,而不是限于哪一种方式或哪一种工具。可以说,微创外科是指在任何外科创伤应急情况下,达到最佳的内环
A、3B、4C、5D、6C
我国《刑法》第170条规定:“伪造货币的,处三年以上十年以下有期徒刑,并处罚金;有下列情形之一的,处十年以上有期徒刑或者无期徒刑,并处罚金或者没收财产:(一)伪造货币集团的首要分子;(二)伪造货币数额特别巨大的;(三)有其他特别严重情节的。”甲是伪造货币集
下列关于计算机病毒的叙述中,错误的是()。
最新回复
(
0
)