首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Rarely does it get much more ironic. Marc Hauser,a professor of psychology at Harvard who made his name probing the evolutionary
Rarely does it get much more ironic. Marc Hauser,a professor of psychology at Harvard who made his name probing the evolutionary
admin
2013-08-05
27
问题
Rarely does it get much more ironic. Marc Hauser,a professor of psychology at Harvard who made his name probing the evolutionary origins of morality, is suspected of having committed the closest thing academia has to a deadly sin: cheating. It is not the first time the scientific world has been rocked by scandal. But the present furore,involving as it does a prestigious university and one of its star professors, will echo through common rooms and quadrangles far and wide.
The story broke when the Boston Globe revealed that Dr. Hauser had been under investigation since 2007 for alleged misconduct at Harvard’s Cognitive Evolution Laboratory, which he heads. This investigation has resulted in the retraction of an oft-cited study published in 2002 in Cognition, the publication last month of a correction to a paper from 2007 in the Proceedings of the Royal Society, and doubts about the validity of findings published in Science, also in 2007. Dr. Hauser was the only author common to all three papers.
An article in the Chronicle of Higher Education added further spice. It offered unsettling accounts by anonymous graduate students and research assistants depicting Dr. Hauser as brusquely dismissive of their attempts to discuss possible improprieties in data collection and interpretation.
This prompted Michael Smith,the hitherto taciturn dean of Harvard’s Faculty of Arts and Sciences, to react. In an open letter to the faculty,he confirmed that an internal investigation had found Dr. Hauser "solely responsible" for eight instances of scientific misconduct, involving the three published papers and five other pieces of research. On the same day,Dr. Hauser, who is on leave and refusing to be interviewed, issued a single contrite statement apologising for having made some "significant mistakes".
These would not be his first. So far, none of this constitutes conclusive evidence of fraud. Slapdash lab work is not the same as fabricating data and Harvard has kept mum about the precise nature of the charges, citing concerns about privacy. Many researchers, however, fear that this silence itself makes things worse and not just for Dr. Hauser and Harvard. The uncertainty about which of his results(for he has been a prolific researcher)are up to snuff means others in the field are finding it hard to decide what to rely on in their own work. And despite Dr. Hauser’s professed sole responsibility,a sizeable number of his present and former wards may unfairly be tainted by association.
At the least, then, Dr. Hauser stands accused of setting the study of animal cognition back many years. Trying to discern an animal’s thought processes on the basis of its behaviour is notoriously tricky and subjective at the best of times. Now,his critics fear,no one will take it seriously. As Greg Laden,one of Dr. Hauser’s former colleagues, laments in a blog,"the hubris and selfishness of one person can do more in the form of damage than an entire productive career can do in the way of building of our collective credibility. "
Others are less depressed, warning against conflating scientific misconduct with difficult science. One corner-cutting researcher does not impugn a whole field. Clive Wynne, editor of Behavioural Processes, which published an "obsessively" immaculate paper by Dr. Hauser three days before the Globe’s revelations,says he is struck by how meticulous recent research in his discipline has been.
In general,scientists see themselves better placed than most to weed out cheats. The more startling a paper’s claims, the more likely it is that others will try to replicate it and, if the claims were plausible, fail. Moreover,scientists want their work to be replicated; it is the only way it will stand the test of time, observes Robert Seyfarth,a primatologist and Dr. Mauser’s former mentor.
Many researchers cite Harvard’s probe as further proof of science’s self-correcting mechanisms, and praise students for doughtily standing up to an authority figure of Dr. Hauser’s distinction. Gerry Altmann, editor of Cognition, agrees, adding: "Although at the time it might appear that each transgression is major,its eventual impact on science is minor. "
Which of the following statements is INCORRECT?
选项
A、Dr. Hauser claimed to take all the blame for cheating.
B、Dr. Hauser was criticized for his study many years ago.
C、Dr. Hauser’s critics fear his misconduct will be ignored.
D、Dr. Hauser’s misconduct may not affect his field of research.
答案
C
解析
细节题。第二段第三句中的it是指首句中提到的the study of animal cognition,不是Dr.Hauser的学术不端行为,[C]是对此句的曲解,故为答案。第五段末句明确指出“Hause博士公开表明自己负全责”,[A]符合文意;[B]符合第六段首句文意;第七段第二句表明了多数人的看法“One corner—cutting researcher doesnot impugn a whole field”,[D]是对“一个行为不端的研究人员不能抹黑整个领域”含义的解释。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/yi4O777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
IwasborninFeb.12,1809,inHardinCounty,Kentucky.MyparentswerebothborninVirginia,ofundistinguishedfamilies--secon
SlanginEnglishTodaywe’lldiscussacommonlinguisticphenomenoninEnglish—slang.Thefeaturesofslangarelistedasfo
SlanginEnglishTodaywe’lldiscussacommonlinguisticphenomenoninEnglish—slang.Thefeaturesofslangarelistedasfo
Whichofthefollowingisatotallyarbitraryone?
WhichofthefollowingdoesnotbelongtotheIslandofGreatBritain?
TheDeathofaSpouseFormuchoftheworld,thedeathofRichardNixonwastheendofacomplexpubliclife.Butresearcher
Inmanyclassroomsaroundthecountry,teachersareemphasizing,andperiodicallytesting,students’readingfluency,thecurrent
EveryEnglishmanisbornwithacertainmiraculouspowerthatmakeshimthemasteroftheworld.(1)______Whenhewantsa
那还是几年前的一个早晨,在太阳刚刚升起来的时候,踏着熹微的晨光,到一个离开旅馆不远的菜市场去。到了邻近菜市场的地方,市场的气氛就逐渐浓了起来。熙熙攘攘的人群,摩肩擦背,来来往往。许多老大娘的菜篮子里装满了蔬菜海味鸡鸭鱼肉。有的篮子里活鱼在摇摆着尾巴,肥鸡在
Incognitivepsychology,studiesoflearningstrategieswithfirstlanguagelearnershaveconcentratedondeterminingtheeffec
随机试题
A、Hisworksheetsareterriblymessy.B、Hefindstheworkloadtooheavy.C、Hisstudyfolderisbadlydisorganized.D、Hehasdiffi
具有润肠通便功效的药物是
下行上给式热水管道系统的最高点宜设:(2009,57)
银行公司信贷产品市场定位的步骤中,首先是()。
甲公司于2015年1月1日购入乙公司80%股权,能够对乙公司的财务和经营政策实施控制。除乙公司外,甲公司无其他子公司。2015年度,乙公司按照购买日可辨认净资产公允价值为基础计算实现的净利润为2000万元,无其他所有者权益变动。2015年年末,甲公司合并财
唉声:叹气:憋闷
假设某计算机具有1 MB的内存(目前使用的计算机往往具有128 MB以上的内存),并按字节编址,为了能存取该内存各地址的内容,其地址寄存器至少需要二进制(42)位。为了使4字节组成的字能从存储器中一次读出,要求存放在存储器中的字边界对齐,1字节的地址码应(
J.Martin指出,以下因素:Ⅰ.程序的适应性差Ⅱ.数据格式的不一致导致数据的共享性差Ⅲ.系统开发方法选择不当Ⅳ.开发工具选择不当哪个(些)是造成数据处理生产效率低的主要原因?
有以下程序#includeintfun(intx){intp;if(x==0||x==1)return(3);p=x-fun(x-2);return(p);}main(){printf("%d\n",fun(9));}程序运行后的输出结
Followingayearoffastdevelopment,bythefirstquarterofthisyear,Chinahashadabout1,100e-commercewebsites.
最新回复
(
0
)