A child who has once been pleased with a tale likes, as a rule, to have it retold in identically the same words, but this should

admin2011-02-28  40

问题    A child who has once been pleased with a tale likes, as a rule, to have it retold in identically the same words, but this should not lead parents to treat printed fairy stories as sacred texts. It is always much better to tell a story than read it out of a book, and, if a parent can produce what, in the actual circumstances of the time and the individual child, is an improvement on the printed text, so much the better.
   A charge made against fairy tales is that they harm the child by frightening him or arousing his sadistic impulses. To prove the latter, one would have to show in a controlled experiment that children who have read fairy stories were more often guilty of cruelty than those who had not. Aggressive, destructive, sadistic impulses every child has and, on the whole, their symbolic verbal discharge seems to be rather a safety valve than an incitement to overt action. As to fears, there are, I think, well-authenticated cases of children being dangerously terrified by some fairy stories. Often, however, this arises from the child having heard the story once. Familiarity with the story by repetition turns the pain of fear into the pleasure of a fear faced and mastered.
   There are also people who object to fairy stories on the grounds that they are not objectively true, that giants, witches, two-headed dragons, magic carpets, etc. do not exist; and that, instead of indulging his fantasies in fairy tales, the child should be taught how to adapt to reality by studying history and mechanics. I find such people, must confess, so unsympathetic and peculiar that I do not know how to argue with them. If their case were sound, the world should be full of madmen attempting to fly from New York to Philadelphia on a broomstick or covering a telephone with kisses in the belief that it was their enchanted girl friend.
   Not fairy story ever claimed to be a description of the external world and no sane child had ever believed that it was.
According to the passage, which of the following statement is NOT true about fairy stories?

选项 A、If children indulged his fantasies in fairy tales instead of being taught how to adapt to reality by studying history and mechanics, the world should be full of madmen.
B、Children can often be greatly terrified when the fairy story is heard for the first time.
C、Fairy tales may beneficially direct children’s aggressive, destructive and sadistic impulses.
D、Fairy tales are no more than stories about imaginary figures with magical powers which has nothing to do with external world.

答案A

解析 A项的内容不是作者的观点,而是作者在末段要批判的观点。而且作者对童话是持肯定态度的,A项内容显然是一种否定态度,因而是错误的。故选A。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/zPtd777K
0

最新回复(0)