首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
For more than 2,000 years, a liberal education has been the ideal of the West—for the brightest, if not for all, students. The t
For more than 2,000 years, a liberal education has been the ideal of the West—for the brightest, if not for all, students. The t
admin
2016-08-19
60
问题
For more than 2,000 years, a liberal education has been the ideal of the West—for the brightest, if not for all, students. The tradition goes back to Plato, who argued in The Republic that "leadership should be entrusted to the philosopher". More recently, in a World War II-era treatise, a Harvard University committee concluded that a liberal education best prepared an individual to become "an expert in the general art of the free man and the citizen. "The report, which led to the introduction of Harvard’s general education curriculum, concluded,"The fruit of education is intelligence in action. The aim is mastery of life. "
In recent years, the fruit has spoiled and such high-sounding rhetoric has been increasingly challenged. Critics have charged that liberal arts education is elitist education, based on undefined and empty shibboleths. Caroline Bird, social critic and author, argues in The Case Against College that the liberal arts are a religion, "the established religion of the ruling class. "Bird writes, "The exalted language, the universalistic setting, the ultimate value, the inability to define, the appeal to personal witness...these are all the familiar modes of religious discourse. "
Students in the 1960s charged that such traditional liberal arts courses as "Western Thought and Institutions" and" Contemporary Civilization" were ethnocentric and imperialistic. Other students found little stimulation in a curriculum that emphasized learning to both formulate ideas and engage in rational discourse. They preferred, instead, to express themselves in experience and action: they favored feeling over thought, the nonverbal over the verbal, the concrete over the abstract. In the inflationary, job-scarce economy of the 1970s,many students argue that the liberal arts curriculum is "irrelevant" because it neither prepares them for careers nor teaches them marketable skills. In its present form, moreover, liberal arts education is expensive education.
Partly in response to these charge and, more immediately to faculty discontent, Harvard recently approved a redesigning of the liberal arts program. Faculty had complained that the growing numbers and varieties of courses had "eroded the purpose of the existing general education program. "Students, they felt, could use any number of courses to satisfy the university’s minimal requirements, making those requirements meaningless. The new core curriculum will require students to take eight courses carefully distributed among five basic areas of knowledge. The Harvard plan proposed to give students " a critical appreciation of the ways in which we gain knowledge and understanding of ourselves. "Plausible as this credo may be, it rests on rhetoric and not solid research evidence— like curriculum innovations of the 1960s.
In an era of educational accounting and educational accountability, it would be helpful to have a way of determining what the essential and most valuable" core" of a university education is and what is peripheral and mere tradition. What are the actual effects of a liberal education, this most persistent of Western ideals? It is sobering to realize that we have little firm evidence.
Against this background, we recently designed and carried out a new study to get some of the evidence. Our findings suggest that liberal arts education does, in fact, change students more or less as Plato envisioned, so that the durability of this educational ideal in western civilization may not be undeserved. In our research, liberal education appears to promote increases in conceptual and social-emotional sophistication. Thus, according to a number of new tests we developed, students trained in the liberal arts are better able to formulate valid concepts, analyze arguments, define themselves, and orient themselves maturely to their world. The liberal arts education in at least one college also seems to increase the leadership motivation pattern—a desire for power, tempered by self-control.
We started our study from two fundamental premises: first, that the evidence to date was probably more a reflection of the testing procedures used than of the efficacy of higher education: and, second, that new tests should be modeled on what university students actually do rather than on what researchers can easily score. If liberal education teaches articulate formation of complex concepts, then student research subjects should be asked to form concepts from complex material and then scored on how well they articulate them, rather than being asked to choose the "best"of five concepts by putting a check mark in one of the boxes. Any study of the effects of higher education has the difficult task of distinguishing educational effects from simply maturational effects. In order to have some control over the effects of maturation, therefore, we tested students who were receiving three different kinds of higher education: A traditional four-year liberal arts education at a prestigious Eastern US institution: A four-year undergraduate program for training teachers and other professionals: A two-year community college that offers career programs in data processing, electronics, nursing secreta-rial skills, and business administration.
At all three institutions, last-year students scored higher than first-year students, but seniors at the liberal arts college far outdistanced their counterparts at the teachers’ and community colleges.
We may infer from the author’s designing of the study that natural maturation with age might______.
选项
A、affect the accuracy of the scoring of the tests
B、lower the score of the tests
C、be a factor to be ignored in the testing
D、be the dominant variable in the tests
答案
A
解析
推断题。倒数第二段第三句指出,所有针对高等教育效果的研究所面对的一个难题是将教育成效与成熟因素区分开来。然后作者指明自己的设计思路:为了对成熟因素有所控制,我们测试了三类接受不同层次高等教育的学生。从这里可以判断出作者在设计时尽量控制了成熟因素,但是并没有说是否能够完全避免,因此还是有可能影响测试结果,故[A]为答案,同时排除[C]。这里只涉及测试结果的精确性,不涉及成绩高低,故排除[B];文中也没有提到成熟因素是决定性因素,故排除[D]。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/5P7O777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
"LostGeneration"isatermcoinedbytheauthorandpoetGertrudeStein,referringtoauthorsandpoetsincludingthefollowing
Theincreaseininternationalbusinessandinforeigninvestmenthascreatedaneedforexecutiveswithknowledgeofforeignl
AndrewCarnegie,knownastheKingofSteel,builtthesteelindustryintheUnitedStates,and,intheprocess,becameoneof
WhichofthefollowingdoesNOTbelongtotheIndo-Europeanfamily?
InBritain,primaryeducationisfreeandcompulsoryfromage______to
Asthe20thcenturybegan,theimportanceofformaleducationintheUSincreasedThefrontierhadmostlydisappearedandin191
Asthe20thcenturybegan,theimportanceofformaleducationintheUSincreasedThefrontierhadmostlydisappearedandin191
这世上有些东西,最好别看透,留几分神秘,留一点朦胧,留一丝悬念,可能会更有意思些。魔术,如果让观众看透了手法,知道了诀窍,这门艺术也就寿终正寝了;变脸,正因为迄今为止大伙都没有看透其技术真相,才能屡演屡新,大受欢迎,成为国粹。交朋友,各有目的:或
流逝,表现了南国人对时间最早的感觉。“子在川上曰:逝者如斯夫。”他们发现无论是潺潺小溪,还是浩荡大河,都一去不复返,流逝之际青年变成了老翁而绿草转眼就枯黄,很自然有错阴的紧迫感。流逝也许是缓慢的,但无论如何缓慢,对流逝的恐惧使人们必须用“流逝”这个词来时时
中国人素有“家园”“故乡”的文化传统,表达了一方人与一方水土的关系。一个城市的人居环境往往成为一方人物、土地、生活、历史、理想、未来的复杂聚合体,成为家园意识最好的物质载体。古代先贤在规划建设城市的时候,早已把自己的内心世界全都放在物质空间里了,他们的规划
随机试题
竞争性抑制作用的特点是
目前已发现的内源性阿片样肽类有()
对经营品种比较单一,经营地点、时间和商品来源不固定的纳税人进行的税款征收方式是( )。
A公司2015年财务报告批准报出日为2016年4月30日。A公司2016年1月6日向乙公司销售一批商品并确认收入。2016年2月20日,乙公司因产品质量原因将上述商品退回。A公司对此项退货业务正确的处理方法是()。
引证法的形式有()
财务分析中的效率指标,是某项财务活动中所费与所得之间的比率,反映投入与产出的关系。()
安全通道为建筑物消防安全必须拥有,用于应急逃生和消防救助的快速通道。下列表示安全通道标志的图标的是()。
商品的价值是()
“http://www.rkb.gov.cn”中的“gov”代表的是______。
结构化设计方法所设计的模块具有诸多特点,下列不属于结构化设计方法中所设计的模块的特点的是
最新回复
(
0
)