首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
The Great Lyme Debate There’s a debate raging over Lyme disease, although you’d never know it unless you’ve been paying clos
The Great Lyme Debate There’s a debate raging over Lyme disease, although you’d never know it unless you’ve been paying clos
admin
2011-06-24
58
问题
The Great Lyme Debate
There’s a debate raging over Lyme disease, although you’d never know it unless you’ve been paying close attention—because on the surface it sounds like the dullest argument imaginable. Last year, the Infectious Diseases Society of America issued new guidelines saying physicians should treat Lyme with antibiotics for no longer than 30 days. Some docs think that’s wrong. It’s a seemingly straightforward difference of opinion. So why has the debate dissolved into animosity, with one side suggesting that its opponents have no credibility and the other slinging deeply personal insults on the Web? And why has it now spilled out of medical journals and onto the office of a state attorney general? Clearly, something other than ticks is bugging a lot of doctors.
Lyme disease—the most common insect-borne ailment in America, with roughly 20,000 cases diagnosed each year and more undetected—is transmitted mostly by a well-known pest, the deer tick. But the real culprit is something even nastier, a bacterium called Borrelia burgdorferi that lives in the tick’s gut. When Borrelia infiltrates the human body, it can cause a suite of distinctive symptoms, most notably a flulike feeling and a red rash like a bull’s-eye. Sometimes, though, it causes no symptoms at all, and that’s more dangerous, because the early signs are the only warnings doctors have. If Lyme is left undiagnosed and untreated, its consequences can be serious, including arthritis, meningitis, heart problems and inflammation of the brain. "The real secret," says Dr. Michael Zimring, director of the Center for Wilderness and Travel Medicine at Mercy Medical Center in Baltimore, "is to be able to recognize the disease early enough."
Zimring would know. Several years ago his wife felt fluish and came down with an oval-shaped rash. Zimring wasn’t sure what she had, but "knowing our backyard is loaded with ticks was enough," he says. He started his wife right away on one of the classic, effective antibiotics used to treat Lyme. When her medical tests came back, they proved him right. "I treated her for three weeks," he says, "and that was it. No problem."
Unfortunately, not all Lyme patients recover so easily. And that’s what’s at the heart of the debate—some docs think patients who are treated inadequately can develop a chronic form of the disease, while others deny that it’s possible. Dr. Rafael Stricter, president of the International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society, believes in "chronic Lyme disease," and he says that in his clinical experience about 70 percent of patients with it get better if they’re treated long term with the same drugs used to treat early infection. But the doctors who made the new IDSA guidelines on treatment say there’s no such thing as chronic Lyme, because in most patients who complain of it, Borrelia isn’t detectable in the body. Dr. Gary Wormser, who chaired the IDSA panel, prefers the term "post-Lyme syndrome." "Treating that syndrome with high-dose antibiotics for months—as some physicians did before the new guidelines—can only hurt patients," he says. "It can give them gallstones and infections and lead to antibiotic resistance while not curing anything. The majority of patients treated for ’chronic Lyme’ do not have post-Lyme," he says, "and in fact never, ever had Lyme disease at all."
This does not sit well with thousands of patients who believe they do have chronic Lyme and badly want antibiotic treatment for it. "The IDSA is basically saying to them, ’We’re right, you’re wrong, we don’t want to listen to you, just take some antidepressants and go away’," says Stricker. The IDSA is a highly respected group of doctors. But it’s facing formidable opposition, not just from Stricker’s group (and angry patients who’ve taken to Internet message boards) but also from the attorney general’s office in Connecticut, the state with the country’s highest incidence of Lyme disease. A.G. Richard Blumenthal has launched an investigation of the IDSA panel, looking into whether it ignored any research that would support long-term antibiotic treatment (the guidelines cite more than 400 studies). "Our question basically is whether the guidelines were formulated through a process that was proper, without self-interest or conflicts of interest," Blumenthal says, noting that some of the panel members have financial interests in treatments and vaccines. Blumenthal also worries that the new guidelines might be used by insurance companies looking to avoid paying for Lyme drugs. "The investigation is at an important juncture," he says. Meanwhile, Wormser is baffled. "How could the interests of the patient be served by treating with unnecessary and potentially dangerous therapies?" he says. "The guidelines represent the best that medical science has to offer." The question, then, is whether that’s good enough.
According to the passage, who is not opposed to the guidelines issued by the IDSA?
选项
A、Dr. Rafael Stricker.
B、Dr. Gary Wormser.C.A.
C、A.G. Richard Blumenthal.
D、Patients who think they have chronic Lyme.
答案
B
解析
Stricker博士是国际Lyme病及相关疾病协会的总裁,他认为Lyme病可转为慢性病,因此反对IDSA颁布的指导方针(A),Wormser作为IDSA小组的负责人自然不会反对该组织颁布的指导方针,Blumenthal作为美国Lyme病高发地的康涅狄格州的总检察长已经开始了对IDSA的调查,说明他反对该组织颁布的指导方针(C),那些认为患有Lyme病的人需要抗生素的治疗,因此也反对新的指导方针(D)。故B为正确答案。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/6yYO777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
Althoughitisnowpossibletobringmosthighbloodpressureundercontrol,themusesofessentialhypertensionremainelusive.
Ascientistwhodoesresearchineconomicpsychologyandwhowantstopredictthewayinwhichconsumerswillspendtheirmoney
ResearchfindingsfromNorwegianandDanishscientistsreleasedinlate1997indicatethattheworld’sreindeerare"hot"—radi
Therearetwomainmethodsoforganizinggovernments—theunitarysystemandthefederalsystem.Theunitarystateplacesmost
TheAmericanTaxSystemGovernmentsraiserevenuesthroughtaxation.Ataxisa【1】______paymenttogovernment.IntheUnit
TheschoolsystemofreachingforAsunderliesthiscountry’sculture,whichemphasisesthechaseforeconomicexcellencewhere
TheMiddleAgesisnotnotedforitsscientificknowledgeandachievement.Foronething,medievalphilosophysufferedfromthe
A、Aftertheyhadbeenonhungerstrike.B、Aftertheylodgedstrongprotest.C、Afterthecourtfailedtogetenoughevidence.D、A
ReligioninAmericanLifeDiversityisthechieffeatureofreligionintheUnitedStates.AlthoughChristianityhasalways
Airpollutionexistsnotonlyoutdoor,butalsoindoor.Ithasgreateffectsonpeople,andtherearemanymeasurestakentocor
随机试题
A.偏头痛B.脑出血C.颅内动脉瘤D.多发性硬化E.帕金森病脑血管造影诊断价值最高的是
下列哪种行为属于信用卡诈骗罪?()
如图所示,一钢筋混凝土水槽底宽1m,水深0.5m,已知单位体积水的重量γ=9.8kN/m3,则在1m长度的水槽上由水引起的约束反力为( )。
通常用于替代铜及其他有色金属制作如齿轮、轴承、垫圈等的塑料有()。
根据公司法的规定,股份有限公司最低注册资本为()万元。
甲上市公司、乙普通合伙企业、丙全民所有制企业和丁公立大学拟共同设立一有限合伙企业。根据合伙企业法律制度的规定,甲、乙、丙、丁中可以成为普通合伙人的是()。
有“南食”、“南烹”之称的菜系是()菜。
Whodesignedthefirsthelicopter?Who【C1】______themostfamouspicturesintheworld?Whoknewmoreaboutthehumanbodythanm
“雕”牌洗衣粉是一种市场知名度非常高的产品。近期,消费者李先生在市场上误购了一种商标不同,但外包装与“雕”牌洗衣粉酷似的“周佳”牌洗衣粉,其价格只有“雕”牌洗衣粉的三分之一。李先生使用后发现为不合格产品,遂向“雕”牌洗衣粉的生产厂家投诉。如果“雕”牌生产厂
统计分组需要注意的问题有()
最新回复
(
0
)