首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
When my predecessors at Time reviewed ecologist Rachel Carson’s book Silent Spring 50 years ago this month, they were less than
When my predecessors at Time reviewed ecologist Rachel Carson’s book Silent Spring 50 years ago this month, they were less than
admin
2014-09-09
42
问题
When my predecessors at Time reviewed ecologist Rachel Carson’s book Silent Spring 50 years ago this month, they were less than impressed. While the piece praised her graceful writing style, it argued that Carson’s "emotional and inaccurate outburst" was "hysterically overemphatic," which I believe is a fancy way of saying that the lady writer let her feelings get the best of her.
Time’s take was gentle compared with the reactions of some of her other contemporary critics. As William Souder writes in his new biography of Carson, On a Farther Shore, chemical companies threatened her with lawsuits after she argued that pesticide overuse was ruining the environment and threatening human health. Others insinuated that she was in league with communists who wanted to cripple American agriculture. As a former chemical-industry spokesman put it bluntly, "If man were to follow the teachings of Miss Carson, we would return to the Dark Ages, and the insects and diseases and vermin would once again inherit the earth. "
Today Silent Spring is regarded as a masterpiece, one of the most influential books of the 20th century. The criticism of Carson—and the sexism implicit in much of it—is a relic from an age devoted to better living through chemistry. Yet 50 years after its publication and 48 years after Carson’s untimely death from breast cancer, there’s still a small but vibrant industry in attacking Silent Spring and its author.
The claim now is that her polemic against pesticides led the world to phase out the insecticide dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane, or DDT. That might seem like a good thing. In Silent Spring Carson describes the toxic effects of DDT use on animals, particularly birds, and in 1972 the Environmental Protection Agency banned it partly on the grounds that it was a probable human carcinogen. So long-lived and potent is DDT that even now, 40 years after the ban, most Americans still carry traces of the chemical in their bodies.
But DDT was also effective in killing the mosquitoes that carry malaria. Conservative critics have argued that by turning the world against DDT, Carson crippled efforts to fight the deadly disease in Africa, where it kills hundreds of thousands of people a year. The right-wing Conservative Enterprise Institute maintains a website called RachelWasWrong. org, arguing that Carson’s "extreme rhetoric generated a culture of fear, resulting in policies that have deprived many people access to life-saving chemicals," namely DDT. In 2005, British politician Dick Taverne wrote that "the anti-DDT campaign that she inspired was responsible for almost as many deaths as some of the worst dictators of the last century. "
The Godwinning of Carson ignores a few facts. Carson took pains to make it clear that she wasn’t calling for the banning of all pesticides, especially those that might be able to protect human beings against insect-transmitted diseases. Carson simply wanted to bring some balance to the use of powerful chemicals at a time when ecology was barely considered a science and industry had license to do whatever it wanted in the name of progress. As for DDT, many experts believe the pesticide would have been less effective against malaria-carrying mosquitoes in the scattered and remote villages of sub-Saharan Africa than it was in more densely populated North America. Africa’ s staggering malaria death toll has more to do with decades of Western indifference than it does with a single book.
If Silent Spring gave birth to the modern green movement, the critical reaction to it created the blueprint for how industry defends itself against environmentalism. Whether it’ s pesticides, asbestos or air pollution, the battle plan is the same: question the science, attack the scientists’ credibility and warn of unbearable costs. The plan hasn’t worked: the U. S. has become cleaner and healthier since Silent Spring, and the Dark Ages that serious men warned us about have yet to descend. But the fight is far from over, as the polarized debate over climate change demonstrates. Rachel Carson may have prophesied a silent spring, but the battle between her acolytes and her enemies will be long and loud.
In the sentence " Time’ s take was gentle compared with the reactions of some of her other contemporary critics, "(para. 2), the word "take" can best be replaced by______.
选项
A、comment
B、analysis
C、approach
D、criticism
答案
C
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/FHSO777K
本试题收录于:
NAETI高级口译笔试题库外语翻译证书(NAETI)分类
0
NAETI高级口译笔试
外语翻译证书(NAETI)
相关试题推荐
Bush’sMBATwenty-sixof42presidents,includingBillClinton,werelawyers.Sevenweregenerals.GeorgeW.Bushbecomesth
Thingswentwellforherduringherearlylifebutinhermiddleageher________seemedtochange.
OurGlobalVillageScienceandtechnologyhasturnedourworldintoaglobalvillage.Theterm—globalvillage—wascoinedby
Throughreceivingfinancialsupportfromfamily,communityorthegovernment,isallowed,itisneveradmired.
Thecentralgovernmenthopestocurtailmilitaryspendinginthenextyear.
Fornearlyacentury,twoUnitedStatesgovernmentalagencies,theUnitedStatesArmyCorpsofEngineersandtheBureauofRecla
Fornearlyacentury,twoUnitedStatesgovernmentalagencies,theUnitedStatesArmyCorpsofEngineersandtheBureauofRecla
Whenthisagreementissigned,acircularwillbepreparedforgiventoourcustomers.
OtherEuropeansseizeforsuchexamplestojumptotheoppositeconclusion.
Wehavenotstressedsofrequentlytheimportanceofliaisonwithourowncolleagues,arguing(withsometimesdubiousvalidity)
随机试题
一家外商投资企业立项审批历时10个月,修改立项报批的文件资料合计280多万字,耗费纸张505公斤,经办人员行程2万多公里,在途27个通宵,费用达4万元。1999年6月,某微型电机厂、金清购销服务部与香港峻诚企业有限公司合资筹办“金港塑料薄膜制品有
Iamfeelingsick.I______somuchchocolate.
针对变更地籍测量,宗地变更不包括()。
()比企业完成的开发工作量(产值)更能反映房地产开发投资项目的真实经济效果。
消防水泵应保证在自动火灾报警后多长时间内启动?
塑料窗应进行复验的性能指标是:[2009年第51题]
下列有权任免期货交易所负责人的机构是()。
1月22日晚,李某喝了两瓶啤酒、一杯白酒,之后到A市平房居民区实施入室盗窃,盗得首饰、手机等物,而后来到工商银行A市支行院外。因为醉酒,李某误以为是个小商店,于是翻进了院子,用钳子夹断铁防护网进入室内,在一楼翻找财物竟然一无所获,看到室内的门上写着“工商银
传统观念认为鸡蛋黄胆固醇含量高,是直接造成高血压、动脉粥样硬化、冠心病及脑中风的罪魁祸首,所以,很多中老年人不敢吃鸡蛋黄。最近,营养学家组织了一个专门实验小组研究鸡蛋黄和胆固醇之间的关系,专家对100名45岁至60岁的男性进行了为期半年的实验。下列哪项实验
【2009年青海省第45题】在比例尺为1:1000000的地图上量得甲、乙两地的距离为15厘米,甲、丙两地的距离为12厘米,乙、丙两地的距离为9厘米,并量得丁地与甲、乙两地的距离都为7.5厘米,问丙、丁两地的实际距离为多少公里?
最新回复
(
0
)