In an uncritical August 11, 1997, World News Tonight report on " diamagnetic therapy," a physical therapist explained that "magn

admin2013-01-10  40

问题     In an uncritical August 11, 1997, World News Tonight report on " diamagnetic therapy," a physical therapist explained that "magnets are another form of electric energy that we now think has a powerful effect on bodies. " A fellow selling $ 89 magnets proclaimed: "All humans are magnetic. Every cell has a positive and negative side of it. "
    On the positive side, these magnets are so weak that they cause no harm. On the negative side, these magnets do have the remarkable power of attracting the pocketbooks of gullible Americans to the tune of about $ 300 million a year. They range in scale from coin-sized patches to mattresses, and their curative powers are said to be nearly limitless, based on the premise that magnetic fields increase blood circulation and enrich oxygen supplies because of the iron pressure in the blood.
    This is fantastic flapdoodle and a financial flimflam. Iron atoms in a magnet are crammed together in a solid state about one atom apart from one another. In your blood only four iron atoms are allocated to each hemoglobin molecule, and they are separated by distances too great to form a magnet. This is easily rested by picking your finger and placing a drop of your blood next to a magnet.
    What about claims that magnets attenuate pain? In a 1997 Baylor College of Medicine double-blind study of 50 patients (in which 29 got real magnets and 21 got sham ones), 76 percent in the experimental group but just 19 percent in the control group reported a reduction in pain. Unfortunately, this study included only one 45-minute treatment, did not try other pain-reduction modalities, did not record the length of the pain reduction and has never been replicated.
    Scientists studying magnetic therapy would do well to read the 1784 " Report of the Commissioners Charged by the King to Examine Animal Magnetism" (reprinted in an English translation in Skeptic, Vol. 4, No. 3). The report was instituted by French King Louis XVI and conducted by Benjamin Franklin and Antoine Lavoisier to experimentally test the claims of German physician Franz Anton Mesmer, discoverer of "animal magnetism. " Mesmer reasoned that just as an invisible force of magnetism draws iron shavings to a lodestone, so does an invisible force of animal magnetism flow through living beings.
Which of the following is NOT the way the iron atoms in a magnet are distributed in our blood?

选项 A、They are squeezed in a solid state about one atom apart from one another.
B、They are dispersed far away from each other.
C、They are only four in our blood scattered to each hemoglobin molecule.
D、They are easily rested by placing a drop of our blood in our finger next to a magnet.

答案D

解析 是非题型A选项在第三段第二句中有提及;B选项和C选项在第三段第三句中有提及;第三段最后一句说:这一切(this is指前面所谈)可以从能轻易地将你的一滴指血滴在一块磁铁旁得到证实,而不是像选项D中说的;它们(they指铁原子)可以轻易地通过将你的一滴指血滴在一块磁铁旁得到证实;因此选项D是答案。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/IowO777K
0

最新回复(0)