首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
The theory of the Social Contract, first formulated by the English philosophers Thomas Hobbes and John Locke, assumes that men a
The theory of the Social Contract, first formulated by the English philosophers Thomas Hobbes and John Locke, assumes that men a
admin
2013-03-27
24
问题
The theory of the Social Contract, first formulated by the English philosophers Thomas Hobbes and John Locke, assumes that men at first lived in a state of anarchy in which there was no society, no government, and no organized coercion of the individual by the group. Hobbes maintained that by the social contract men had surrendered their natural liberties in order to enjoy the order and safety of the organized state. The French philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau, in LeContrat Social(1762), found the general will, a means of establishing reciprocal rights and duties, privileges, and responsibilities as a basis of the state. Similar ideas were used as a justification for both the American and the French revolutions in the 18th century. Thomas Jefferson held that the preservation of certain natural rights was an essential part of the social contract, and that "consent of the governed" was fundamental to any exercise of governmental power. The Social Contract theory has withstood the test of time; it served as a rationale for the enactment of felon disenfranchisement laws in the past, and remains a compelling argument today.
The early exclusion of felons from the franchise by many states could well have rested on Locke’s concept, so influential at the time, that by entering into society every man authorizes the society, or which is all one, the legislature thereof, to make laws for him, as the public good of the society shall require. A man who breaks the laws he has authorized his agent to make for his own governance could fairly have been thought to have abandoned the right to participate in further administering the compact. This is especially so when account is taken of the heavy incidence of recidivism and the prevalence of organized crime.
When someone commits a crime, he commits it not just against the victim, but against our entire society. Protests that time sewed is enough, and that society should prioritize the rehabilitation and reintegration of felons should fall on deaf ears. Opponents of disenfranchisement claim that the inability to vote stymies felons’ "remittance into a law-abiding society". Yet they neglect to explain why the tonic of voting did not curtail felons from committing crimes initially. They have breached the social contract and, like insane persons, have raised questions about their ability to vote responsibly.
Despite its initial attractiveness, the use of social contract theory to defend felon disenfranchisement is in fact specious. Disenfranchised felons are unequal parties to a contract that is fundamentally unfair in its formation on the grounds that they are unconscionable. The social contract between citizens and the state to which they delegate their authority gains its validity from the parties’ freedom to contract and share an active voice in negotiating. In fact, active citizenship in the United States is but a facade without this vital right.
The felon, disenfranchised upon breaching the original social contract, enters into a second contract upon his release. The validity of this second formation is questionable because the felon, in his disenfranchised state, is not an equal party truly free to contract. This suggests that the contract is unconscionable because of the unincarcerated felon’s unequal position as a silent party to the ongoing negotiation of the contract.
The social contract suffers from many of the ailments in the formation, liquidated damages provision, and unconscionable terms that would invalidate any traditional contract. The franchise should be returned to unincarcerated felons so that they may be whole and free parties to the social contract. The Social Contract theory and the objectives of punishment fail to provide a satisfactory explanation for the denial of one of the most fundamental rights to millions of citizens. Disenfranchisement’s defenders continue to claim that denying convicts the vote is necessary to protect something called the "purity of the ballot box" and that because offenders violate the "social contract", they forfeit political rights completely unrelated to the needs of incarceration.
According to the writer, does the "Social Contract" theory present a valid reason for felon disenfranchisement?
选项
A、Yes, because felons have raised questions about their ability to vote responsibly.
B、Yes, because a criminal commits a crime not just against the victim, but against the entire society.
C、No, because the preservation of certain natural rights was an essential part of the social contract.
D、No, because of the unincarcerated felon’s unequal position as a silent party to the ongoing negotiation of the contract.
答案
D
解析
根据第五段的“The felon,disenfranchised…ongoing negotiation of the contract.”可知,因违反最初的社会契约而被剥夺选举权的重罪犯,在获释后就开始了第二份契约。第二份契约的有效性令人质疑,因为重罪犯在被剥夺了选举权的状态下,不可能真正公平地应用这份契约。这表明契约是不合理的,因为未被监禁的重罪犯处于不平等的地位,在对契约不断进行的谈判中属于无发言权的一方。据此可知,“社会契约”理论不能为剥夺重罪犯的选举权提供有效的依据。D项正确。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/OVmO777K
0
考博英语
相关试题推荐
Atallageandatallstagesoflife,fearpresentsaproblemtoalmosteveryone."Wearelargelytheplaythingsofourfears,"
ThediscoveryoftheAntarcticnotonlyprovedoneofthemostinterestingofallgeographicaladventures,butcreatedwhatmigh
Althoughitisonlyasmallbusiness,its______issurprisinglyhigh.
Whenamemberofanethnicminoritygroupacquiresthebehaviorpatterns,lifestyles,values,andlanguageofthemainstreamcul
ProfessorWalterOechsleroftheUniversityofMannheim(Germany)believestheworkplaceandworkforceinthe21stcenturywill
Thesourcesofanti-Christianfeelingweremanyandcomplex.Onthemoreintangibleside,therewasageneralpiqueagainstthe
Thisleavesuswiththechallengeoffindingsomepoliticallypracticablewaytoreducegreenhousegasemissions.Butitisana
PublicationofthissurveyhadoriginallybeenintendedtocoincidewiththeannualmeetingsoftheWorldBankandtheInternati
______anyoneshouldthinkitstrange,letmeassureyouthatitisquitetrue.
Thecurrentpoliticaldebateoverfamilyvaluespersonalresponsibility,andwelfaretakesforgrantedtheentrenchedAmericanb
随机试题
“损其阴盛,治寒以热”适用于
有关上市许可人制度的说法,正确的有
心力衰竭患者低盐饮食,主要是了减轻()。
下列选项中属于非流动资产项目的是( )。
(2012年卷二第70题)美术学院教授王某受某公司委托,创作了一件象征该公司文化和精神的雕塑,并按照合同约定将该雕塑原件交付给该公司,但双方未约定该雕塑著作权的归属。根据著作权法及相关规定,下列哪些说法是正确的?
从各国情况来看,当基尼系数()时,表示社会劳动者收入差距非常小。
在很多情况下,一些非政府的组织机构(如行业协会),乃至私营企业都可以担当政策执行主体的角色。()
田某和陈某合伙经营一家打印社,由田某负责供应耗材。田某发现甲公司送的一批货质量存在问题,经协商无果,田某向法院提起诉讼,要求甲公司接受退货并承担违约责任。案件受理后,陈某得知此事,也向法院提起诉讼,要求甲公司赔偿损失。关于本案,下列哪一选项是正确的?(
据第六次全国人口普查主要数据公报,中国城镇常住人口超过6.7亿,比欧盟27国的总人口还多。众多农村人口在较短的时间内涌到城市里,一方面为国家创造了巨额的财富,大大推进了二、三产业的发展;另一方面,城市发展和管理中的问题也集中表现出来,给城市管理带来了考验。
请选择最适合的一项填入问号处,使之符合之前四个图形的变化规律。()
最新回复
(
0
)