首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
From The Tipping Point to Nudge, the rise of pop-social science has been a noticeable feature of the past decade in publishing.
From The Tipping Point to Nudge, the rise of pop-social science has been a noticeable feature of the past decade in publishing.
admin
2012-07-06
47
问题
From The Tipping Point to Nudge, the rise of pop-social science has been a noticeable feature of the past decade in publishing. Not everyone is impressed. I recently interviewed a professor of education who is an expert in policy evaluation. She lamented the fact that politicians tend to get their facts from popular social science books containing inaccuracies.
I think the professor was right to worry about ministerial exposure to authors such as Malcolm Gladwell, Dan Ariely and even Tim Harford— but not for quite the right reasons. The problem is not that such authors are inaccurate. I’m not sure that they are. Gladwell has plenty of critics, but I find him a careful reporter. And I am told Tim Harford is all but infallible.
Yet infallibility is not enough. It’s perfectly possible for an author to do nothing but weave together credible, peer-reviewed research and yet produce a highly partial view of reality. Different pieces of research invariably point in different directions. Dan Ariely’s Predictably Irrational is full of examples of irrational behaviour. My own Logic of Life is full of examples of rational behaviour. Occasionally I am asked to explain the contradiction, but if there is a contradiction, it is a subtle one.
If Ariely describes a rainy day and I describe a sunny one, we are not really contradicting each other. We each offer our spin, but it’s really about whether most people expect sunshine or rain: Dan says that it’s rainier than we tend to think, while I say the sun shines more often than anyone would credit. A serious review of this metaphorical evidence would count up the rainy days and the sunny ones.
For real policy questions, such reviews exist. They are called systemic reviews. They should be the first port of call for anyone wanting to understand what works. But they are not exactly bestsellers in airport bookshops.
Quite apart from the fact that nobody wants to read all the evidence, there is a deep problem with the way evidence is selected throughout academia. Even a studiously impartial literature review will be biased towards published results. Many findings are never published because they just aren’t very intriguing. Alas, boring or disappointing evidence is still evidence. It is dangerous to discard it, but let’s not blame Malcolm Gladwell just because he doesn’t stick it on page one.
There’s a hierarchy of evidence here. The systemic review tries to track down unpublished research as well as what makes it into the journals. A less careful review will often be biased towards results that are interesting. A peer-reviewed article presents a single result, while a popular social-science book will highlight a series of results that tell a tale. The final selection mechanism is the reader, who will half-remember some findings and forget the rest.
Those of us who tell ourselves we are curious about the world are actually swimming in "evidence" that has been filtered again and again in favour of interestingness. It’s a heady and perhaps toxic drink, but we shouldn’t blame popularisers alone for our choice to dive in. [515 words]
It can be inferred that the lack, of systemic reviews should be mainly blamed on______.
选项
A、the publishing system
B、the policy system
C、social science authors
D、scientific researchers
答案
A
解析
本题考查推理引申。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/Ucp4777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
YouaresupposedtoinviteDr.Kingtomakeaspeechaboutthefuturedevelopmentofcomputerscienceattheannualconferenceo
Inourincreasinglycomplexworld,informationisbecomingthebasicbuildingblockofthesociety.(46)However,atatimewhen
Inourincreasinglycomplexworld,informationisbecomingthebasicbuildingblockofthesociety.(46)However,atatimewhen
Inthetwodecadesbetween1929and1949,sculptureintheUnitedStatessustainedwhatwasprobablythegreatestexpansionins
ItcanbeinferredfromParagraph1thatoneimportantfactorintheincreasingimportanceofeducationintheUnitedStateswas
YouaresupposedtoinviteDr.Kingtomakeaspeechaboutthefuturedevelopmentofcomputerscienceattheannualconferenceo
Increasingly,historiansareblamingdiseasesimportedfromtheOldWorldforthegreatdisparitybetweenthenativepopulation
Underpressurefromanimalwelfaregroups,twonationalscienceteachersassociationshaveadoptedguidelinesthatbanclassroom
TheCaliforniancoastlinenorthandsouthofSiliconValleyisatrend-settingsortofplace.Increasingly,thehomeinteriorso
随机试题
男孩,9岁,于2005年1月20日来院急诊,病史其父代诉,高热,头痛伴呕吐6小时伴呼之不应,体检,体温40℃,面色青灰,四肢凉,全身皮肤见广泛淤点、淤斑,心率快,心音较弱,血压未能测出,双肺呼吸音稍粗,脑膜刺激征不明显。下列哪项是诊断本病的主要依据
关于输卵管各部,正确的是
支气管扩张最常见的原因是
甲成立一犯罪组织.常年从事走私活动。乙是甲的好友,乙知道甲的走私行为,每当甲资金紧张时,乙会放贷款给甲,资金来往共计500万元。丙是甲的收购方,经常直接到内海与甲接头.直接收购走私货物。收购金额高达600万元。某日,公安机关收到线报,甲将走私一批珍贵名表经
下面对于员工福利的中期发展的特点描述错误的是()。
甲公司2008年1月5B支付价款2000万元购入乙公司30%的股份,准备长期持有,另支付相关税费20万元,购入时乙公司可辨认净资产公允价值为12000万元。甲公司取得投资后对乙公司具有重大影响。假定不考虑其他因素,甲公司因确认投资而影响利润的金额为(
应用计量调整型抽样方案对连续生产的产品批进行验收,当产品检验费用较高,检验耗费时间较长时,更适宜的检验水平是()。
下列哪些选项属于我国在政府体制内的家庭社会工作?()
某公司出纳员的直接上级是财务经理,所属部门是财务中心,工资等级是C系列四等,定员人数1人,工作性质是服务人员。主要负责公司日常的现金收支管理、现金日记帐管理,公司工资及福利核算,费州统计及分析等事项。任职资格为大学专科会计专业,同等学力
“龙生龙,凤生凤,老鼠生来会打洞”是环境决定论的观点。()
最新回复
(
0
)