首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
From The Tipping Point to Nudge, the rise of pop-social science has been a noticeable feature of the past decade in publishing.
From The Tipping Point to Nudge, the rise of pop-social science has been a noticeable feature of the past decade in publishing.
admin
2012-07-06
75
问题
From The Tipping Point to Nudge, the rise of pop-social science has been a noticeable feature of the past decade in publishing. Not everyone is impressed. I recently interviewed a professor of education who is an expert in policy evaluation. She lamented the fact that politicians tend to get their facts from popular social science books containing inaccuracies.
I think the professor was right to worry about ministerial exposure to authors such as Malcolm Gladwell, Dan Ariely and even Tim Harford— but not for quite the right reasons. The problem is not that such authors are inaccurate. I’m not sure that they are. Gladwell has plenty of critics, but I find him a careful reporter. And I am told Tim Harford is all but infallible.
Yet infallibility is not enough. It’s perfectly possible for an author to do nothing but weave together credible, peer-reviewed research and yet produce a highly partial view of reality. Different pieces of research invariably point in different directions. Dan Ariely’s Predictably Irrational is full of examples of irrational behaviour. My own Logic of Life is full of examples of rational behaviour. Occasionally I am asked to explain the contradiction, but if there is a contradiction, it is a subtle one.
If Ariely describes a rainy day and I describe a sunny one, we are not really contradicting each other. We each offer our spin, but it’s really about whether most people expect sunshine or rain: Dan says that it’s rainier than we tend to think, while I say the sun shines more often than anyone would credit. A serious review of this metaphorical evidence would count up the rainy days and the sunny ones.
For real policy questions, such reviews exist. They are called systemic reviews. They should be the first port of call for anyone wanting to understand what works. But they are not exactly bestsellers in airport bookshops.
Quite apart from the fact that nobody wants to read all the evidence, there is a deep problem with the way evidence is selected throughout academia. Even a studiously impartial literature review will be biased towards published results. Many findings are never published because they just aren’t very intriguing. Alas, boring or disappointing evidence is still evidence. It is dangerous to discard it, but let’s not blame Malcolm Gladwell just because he doesn’t stick it on page one.
There’s a hierarchy of evidence here. The systemic review tries to track down unpublished research as well as what makes it into the journals. A less careful review will often be biased towards results that are interesting. A peer-reviewed article presents a single result, while a popular social-science book will highlight a series of results that tell a tale. The final selection mechanism is the reader, who will half-remember some findings and forget the rest.
Those of us who tell ourselves we are curious about the world are actually swimming in "evidence" that has been filtered again and again in favour of interestingness. It’s a heady and perhaps toxic drink, but we shouldn’t blame popularisers alone for our choice to dive in. [515 words]
It can be inferred that the lack, of systemic reviews should be mainly blamed on______.
选项
A、the publishing system
B、the policy system
C、social science authors
D、scientific researchers
答案
A
解析
本题考查推理引申。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/Ucp4777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
Inourincreasinglycomplexworld,informationisbecomingthebasicbuildingblockofthesociety.(46)However,atatimewhen
Inthetwodecadesbetween1929and1949,sculptureintheUnitedStatessustainedwhatwasprobablythegreatestexpansionins
Sciencehaslonghadanuneasyrelationshipwithotheraspectsofculture.ThinkofGalileo’s17thcenturytrialforhisrebelli
EightmonthsafterSep.11,itisbecomingincreasinglyapparentthatvariousarmsoftheUSgovernmenthadpiecesofinformatio
ItcanbeinferredfromParagraph1thatoneimportantfactorintheincreasingimportanceofeducationintheUnitedStateswas
Inascience-fictionmoviecalled"Species",amysterioussignalfromouterspaceturnsouttodescribethegenomeofanunknown
InapaperjustpublishedinScience,PeterGordonofColumbiaUniversityuseshisstudyofthePirahaandtheircountingsystem
Increasingly,historiansareblamingdiseasesimportedfromtheOldWorldforthegreatdisparitybetweenthenativepopulation
Weallknowthatscienceplaysanimportantroleinthesocietiesinwhichwelive.Manypeoplebelieve,however,thatourprogr
TheCaliforniancoastlinenorthandsouthofSiliconValleyisatrend-settingsortofplace.Increasingly,thehomeinteriorso
随机试题
“客户”数据表结构为:客户编号、手机号、购物金额,合理的字段类型为()
司机丙某冬季清晨出车,因天气寒冷,汽油上冻,汽车无法启动,便点燃木材烧烤油箱,不料油箱起火爆炸,当场炸死3人。丙某的行为构成:()
填方路基在碾压时应先轻后重,最后碾压机械应为不小于()级的压路机。
个人商用房贷款的借款人应具备的条件有()。
下列业务中属于银行代理业务的有()。
对于鉴定意见,发现有以下哪些情形的,经县级以上公安机关负责人批准,应当重新鉴定?()
【B1】【B10】
ADSL技术可以充分利用现有铜线网络,只要在用户线路两端加装ADSL设备即可为用户提供服务。请从以下术语选择适当的编号,将图5-9所示的拓扑结构中(1)~(4)空缺处的名称填写完整。【供选择的答案】A.程控交换机B.二层交换机
USBlacksHard-hitbyCancerDeathratesforcancerarefallingforallAmericans,butblackAmericansarestillmorelikely
Onceuponatime,innovationatProcter&Gambleflowedoneway:fromtheUnitedStatesoutward.WhilethelargeCincinnati-base
最新回复
(
0
)