首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
The following article is about the "parent trigger" laws in the US. The basic concept of the policy is that parents have the abi
The following article is about the "parent trigger" laws in the US. The basic concept of the policy is that parents have the abi
admin
2020-09-01
39
问题
The following article is about the "parent trigger" laws in the US. The basic concept of the policy is that parents have the ability to intervene in their child’s school if it is performing poorly. With enough signatures from parents, any number of actions can be taken against the low performing school. These can include converting it to a charter school, replacing some of the school’s administration and faculty, and closing the school altogether. From the following article you may find there are both assent and disapproval.
Write an article of NO LESS THAN 300 words, in which you should:
1. summarize the development of the parent trigger law, and then
2. express your opinion towards the law, especially whether this kind of law can really benefit students and schools.
Parent-Trigger Efforts: At a Crossroads? A Standstill? A Dead End?
Seven U.S. states have passed "parent trigger" laws, which give parents the ability to petition for changes at their children’s low-performing public schools. If more than half of the parents at a school sign the petition, the school district must comply with the changes. These can include hiring a new staff, hiring a public charter school operator to take over reforms, or closing the school altogether and sending students to better performing neighboring schools.
Across the nation, the debate rages on among policymakers, teachers and education advocates: Do parent-trigger-type laws have the potential to turn around underperforming schools when bureaucrats fail to act? Or should they be dismissed as a flawed tool that can do more harm than good in already struggling school communities?
Parent Revolution claims that support is building for parent triggers at local levels in several states, including Tennessee and New York. Memphis Council PTA Vice President Helen Collins said she’s ramping up efforts to build support for a stronger parent-trigger law among 53 schools in Memphis and Shelby County. "We really hope that the teachers and the administrators know that our goal is not to put them out of a job; if anything our goal is to make sure that they understand we’re there to help," she said.
In New York, a loose coalition of Buffalo parents has been backing parent-trigger legislation sponsored by Assemblywoman Crystal Peoples-Stokes. Tom Casey, campaign manager for We The Parents Buffalo, a group of parents, community members and faith-based leaders, said he does have some doubts about the parent trigger, including the difficulty of getting parents to reach consensus on the changes they want to see at a particular school. But he said he supports any tools that give parents more choices of schools, including charters, and believes too often teacher contracts get in the way of overhauling low-achieving ones. "You cannot change a school when you have tenured teachers and tenured principals," Casey said. "The only way to fix it is to totally restructure it."
Critics argue the law is a corporate-backed privatization tool under the guise of parent empowerment; they are particularly concerned about using parent trigger to force charter school conversions, which could strip away from some schools the leadership of elected school boards. Opponents have further charged that parents have been bullied into signing petitions, though trigger advocates have also accused teachers unions and other opponents of similarly aggressive tactics. Opponents insisted that there are mechanisms already in place to intervene in low performing schools. They point to school accountability committees and local school boards as the existing means for parents to be involved in the operation of their child’s school. They also worry that parents may not be aware of the changes low performing schools have already made such as hiring new administration and teachers.
选项
答案
Parent Trigger Law Need Be Properly Implemented Parent trigger law, as a new legal means to enable parents to involve in school education, has been advocated by several U.S. states, which leads to a nationwide debate among people from all walks of life. Many people show increasing support for this law, hoping to provide better education for students by changing schools. By contrast, opponents maintain that the parties that sponsor the establishment of parent trigger law would take advantage of it to reach their goals, which may damage the school’s functional mechanism. Furthermore, they insist that the law is unnecessary because there are already existing solutions for dealing with underperforming schools. As far as I can see, I fully sanction the idea of parent trigger law, which can effectively drive the school to improve education quality and thus offer better education for students with the help of parents. Based on this law, parents are entitled to supervision on the school administration. When they find the school failing to meet the needs of students and no prompt actions are taken by the school, they can initiate any necessary action demanding the school make according adjustments on management or teaching practices. In doing so, education quality will be improved and students will be able to access better education opportunities. Yet, in order to bring the law into full play, it should be implemented in a transparent and justified way so that the suggestions for schools can be actually beneficial to schools and students. Therefore, it is also government’s responsibility to detail the parent trigger law and put it into real effect. To sum up, parent trigger law could be a good way to improve teaching quality with proper implementation. Only when it is conducted in a reasonable and justified way can it really benefit schools and students, eventually paving the way for the future of children.
解析
材料围绕“家长制动法”展开讨论,可分为三部分内容。
第一段介绍了“家长制动法”的内容,这项条例赋予家长权利,允许他们请愿整改(petition for changes)表现不佳的学校,如雇佣新教职工(hiring a new staff),甚至可以关闭整个学校(closing the school altogether)。
第二段提出人们对这项法律的质疑,包括它能否改善表现不佳的学校(turn around underperforming schools);它对正在面临困境的学校社区(struggling school communities)而言弊大于利,是否应当废除?
最后三段分析了“家长制动法”的利弊。支持者认为,这项法律通过改变学校给学生提供更好的教育,是为教师和学校行政人员提供帮助(to help),而不是遣散他们(put them out of a job)。反对者则认为这项法律是由企业赞助以牟取私利的工具(a corporate-backed privatization tool);而且,当前已有处理表现不佳的学校的措施(mechanisms already in place),这项法律没有必要存在。
开篇:总结材料,从两方面概括社会对家长制动法的支持与反对。
主体:提出个人见解——家长制动法有利于提高学校教育水平,但执行时需要透明化、公正化。并加以论述。
结尾:总结全文,家长制动法有其存在的合理性,但只有恰当落实才能真正让学生与学校受益。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/ZzIK777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
SomeTheoriesofHistoryI.TheproblemsofunderstandinghistoryHistorywithwrittenrecords:therecordsmaybe【T1】______
FiveCommonMistakesinConversationandTheirSolutionsI.NotlisteningA.Problem:mostpeopledon’tlisten—waiteagerlyf
Inrecentyears,railroadshavebeencombiningwitheachother,mergingintosupersystems,causingheightenedconcernsaboutmo
AreyouconsideringtravelingtoanativeEnglishspeakingcountrytoimproveyourEnglishlanguagesskillsatalanguagescho
AreyouconsideringtravelingtoanativeEnglishspeakingcountrytoimproveyourEnglishlanguagesskillsatalanguagescho
作家有三种死法。一曰自然的死,二曰痛苦的死,三曰快乐的死。自然的死属于心脏停止跳动,是一种普遍的死亡形式,没有特色,可以略而不议。快乐的死和痛苦的死不属于心脏停止跳动,是人还活着,作品已经或几乎是没有了!作家没有了作品,可以看作是个人艺
沙漠里真有魔鬼吗?在那时人们的知识水平看起来,确像是有魔鬼在作怪。但是人们掌握了自然规律以后,便可把这种光怪陆离的现象说清楚。这种现象在大戈壁夏天中午是常见的。当人们旅行得渴不可耐的时候,忽然看见一个很大的湖,里面蓄着碧蓝的清水,看来并不很远。当人们欢天喜
科技是人类文明进步的动力源泉。古老的中国,曾在世界科技史上占有重要地位。今天的中国人民,不仅与全世界共享科技文明的成果,也在各个领域推动世界科技的进步。科技奥运将反映科技最新进展,集成全国科技创新成果,推出一届高科技含量的体育盛会;提高北京科技创新能力,推
当我在小学毕了业的时候,亲友一致的愿意我去学手艺,好帮助母亲。我晓得我应当去找饭吃,以减轻母亲的勤劳困苦。可是,我也愿意升学。我偷偷地考入了师范学校——制服,饭食,书籍,宿处,都由学校供给。只有这样,我才敢对母亲提升学的话。入学,要交十元的保证会。这是一笔
还是热,心里可镇定多了。凉风,即使是一点点,给了人们很多希望。
随机试题
A.犯罪主体B.犯罪客体C.刑事责任D.刑事处罚E.犯罪行为、违法行为
A、绝对卧床休息B、绝对卧床2周C、卧床休息D、可以正常活动E、室内轻度活动急性肾炎水肿消退、血压正常、肉眼血尿消退者()
体外纯菌药物敏感性试验常用的方法是
某护士在给一位乙型肝炎病毒携带者注射时.不慎被患者用过的针头刺伤手指。为预防乙型肝炎病毒感染.应首先采取的措施是
[2012年第022题]住宅设计中延长住宅建筑寿命的关键措施是解决:
当界桩点对边界走向影响较大且容易破坏时,为便于寻找确定界桩点可设方位物,方位物的设立和测定的主要要求有()。
下列给定程序中函数fun的功能是:逐个比较p、q所指两个字符串对应位置上的字符,并把ASCII值大或相等的字符依次存放到C所指的数组中,形成一个新的字符串。例如,若主函数中a字符串为“aBCDeFgH”,b字符串为“ABcd”,则c中的字符串应为“a
______isthestudyofspeechsoundsinlanguageoralanguagewithreferencetotheirdistributionandpatterningandtotacit
CaloriesForyearsnow,calorieshavebeenalltherage-peoplearecountingthemandcuttingthem,andyou’dbehard-pressed
Withmoreandmoreyoungpeoplegettingintotroublewiththelaw,racialworkersareverybusy.Theyaretryingtokeep【B1】____
最新回复
(
0
)