首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Many current discussions of immigration issues talk about immigrants in general, as if they were abstract people in an abstract
Many current discussions of immigration issues talk about immigrants in general, as if they were abstract people in an abstract
admin
2019-03-26
87
问题
Many current discussions of immigration issues talk about immigrants in general, as if they were abstract people in an abstract world. But the concrete differences between immigrants from different countries affect whether their coming here is good or bad for the American people.
The very thought of formulating immigration laws from the standpoint of what is best for the American people seems to have been forgotten by many who focus on how to solve the problems of illegal immigration.
It is hard to look for "the ideal outcome" on immigration in the abstract. Economics professor Milton Friedman once said, "The best is the enemy of the good," which to me meant that attempts to achieve an unattainable ideal can prevent us from reaching good outcomes that are possible in practice.
Too much of our current immigration controversy is conducted in terms of abstract ideals, such as "We are a nation of immigrants." Of course we are a nation of immigrants. But we are also a nation of people who wear shoes. Does it follow that we should admit anybody who wears shoes?
The immigrants of today are very different in many ways from those who arrived here a hundred years ago. Moreover, the society in which they arrive is different. To me, it is better to build a wall around the welfare state than the country.
But the welfare state is already here — and, far from having a wall built around it, the welfare state is expanding in all directions. We do not have a choice between the welfare state and open borders. Anything we try to do as regards immigration laws has to be done in the context of a huge welfare state that is already a major, inescapable fact of life.
Among other facts of life utterly ignored by many advocates of de facto amnesty(事实上的大赦)is that the free international movement of people is different from free international trade in goods.
Buying cars or cameras from other countries is not the same as admitting people from those countries or any other countries. Unlike inanimate objects, people have cultures and not all cultures are compatible with the culture in this country that has produced such benefits for the American people for so long.
Not only the United States, but the Western world in general, has been discovering the hard way that admitting people with incompatible cultures is an irreversible decision with incalculable consequences. If we do not see that after recent terrorist attacks on the streets of Boston and London, when will we see it?
"Comprehensive immigration reform" means doing everything all together in a rush, without time to look before we leap, and basing ourselves on abstract notions about abstract people.
What is the author’s attitude towards "comprehensive immigration reform"?
选项
A、Supportive.
B、Negative.
C、Wait-and-see.
D、Indifferent.
答案
B
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/dsX7777K
0
大学英语六级
相关试题推荐
Whatifwecouldreadthemindofaterrorist?ResearchersatNorthwesternUniversityinChicagosaytheyhavetakenastepclos
A、Itismoreimportantthanmoney.B、Peoplewerebornwithit.C、Peopleuseittogetthroughdifficulties.D、Itcanhealtheso
自从1949年新中国成立以来,中国政府一直十分重视教育,通过颁布(promulgate)一系列法律法规来保护不同群体的公民受教育的权利,尤其是保护少数民族、妇女、儿童和残疾人受教育的权利。五十多年来,通过持续不断的努力,中国的教育事业取得了长足的进步。中国
StatesExperimentwithOut-of-ClassroomLearning[A]AttheendofAugust,mostofOhio’steenagerswillshakeofftheirsummert
A、Fruit.B、Water.C、Lunch.D、Repairservices.B访谈最后,男士给可能参与活动的自行车手的提示是:要带上水。中继站处有供应,但是自己备一份还是有用处的。故选B。
A、Theywererated8.3%higherthantheaverageones.B、Theyweresoldatanaveragepriceof$61perpair.C、Theywererated8.1
A、Itcanbecontrolledremotely.B、Ittakesmuchroomofacar.C、Ithassomemeritsanddrawbacks.D、Itisratherexpensive.A在
A、Allofthemarebigbutcheap.B、TheyareavailableontheInternet.C、Wecanbuythemfromastore.D、Ittakeshourstodownl
Englishistheleadinginternationallanguage.Indifferentcountriesaroundtheglobe,Englishisacquiredasthemothertongue
A、BecausemanyarchitectsstudiedwithWright.B、BecauseWrightstartedthepracticeof"land-scraping".C、BecauseWrightusede
随机试题
Somepeopleworryaboutmycollectingofthosefascinatingbirdsandanimalsthattheypaytoseeinthezoo.Oneofthequestio
A.痰滞于胃B.饮停于胃C.痰凝肌肤D.痰阻经络纳呆恶心,呕吐痰涎。为
某医院年终对全院职工的基本情况作调查了解,其中有以下情况:死亡一人,医生甲因病在家闲了接近2年,医生丙参与经营未从事医疗两年多,医生丁承包医院的第二门诊三年,其余大多数仍在医院坚持工作,依据执业医师法,下列人员中,属于应当注销注册,收回医师执业证书的是
有机整体的"主宰"是()
(2006年简答题)甲、乙、丙、丁四人共同投资设立A普通合伙企业。合伙协议的部分内容如下:由甲、乙执行合伙企业事务,丙、丁不得过问企业事务;利润和损失由甲、乙、丙、丁平均分配和分担。在执行合伙企业事务过程中,为提高管理水平,甲自行决定聘请王某担任合伙企业经
(2011年)2010年4月6日,甲公司为履行与乙公司的买卖合同,签发一张已经由本公司承兑的商业汇票交付乙公司,汇票收款人为乙公司,到期日为10月6日。4月14日,乙公司将该汇票背书转让给丙公司。9月8日,丙公司持该汇票向其开户银行Q银行办理贴现。该汇票到
周师傅在某单位工作,该单位周一到周五为工作日,周六周日双休。已知某年的8月1日是星期五,那么周师傅在该年8月一共需要出勤()天。
甲、乙、丙、丁四人的车分别是白、黑、红、蓝。在问到他们各自车的颜色时,甲:“乙的不是白色”,乙:“丙的是蓝色”,丙:“丁的不是红色”。丁:“甲、乙、丙三人的车有一个是蓝色,而且只有车的颜色是蓝色的这个人说了实话。”如果丁说的是实话,那么以下说法正确的是哪一
关于十九世纪七八十年代的“边疆危机”下列正确的表述有()
AnewstudypublishedinthejournalProceedingsoftheRoyalSocietyBbytheteamsofDr.GregoryWestandDr.VeroniqueBohbo
最新回复
(
0
)