首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Handle With Care When Thomas Butler stepped off a plane in April 2002 on his return to the United States from a trip to Tanz
Handle With Care When Thomas Butler stepped off a plane in April 2002 on his return to the United States from a trip to Tanz
admin
2013-07-11
81
问题
Handle With Care
When Thomas Butler stepped off a plane in April 2002 on his return to the United States from a trip to Tanzania, he set in motion a chain of events that now threatens to destroy his life. A microbiologist at Texas Tech University in Lubbock, Butler was bringing back samples of the plague bacterium Yersinia pestis for his research. Yet on reentering the country, he is alleged to have passed right by US customs inspectors without notifying them that he was carrying this potentially deadly cargo. That move and its consequences have led the federal government to prosecute Butler for a range of offences. If convicted on all counts, he could be fined millions of dollars and spend the rest of his life in jail.
The US scientific community has leapt to butler’s defence, arguing that his prosecution is overzealous, alarming and unnecessary. The presidents of the National Academy of Sciences and the Institute of Medicine have written to Attorney General John Ashcroft, claiming that the case could endanger research into countering the threat of bioterrorism. And the academy’s human-rights committee has asked its members to write letters on Butler’s behalf and to donate funds for his defense.
Those who defend Butler argue that the rules governing the import of pathogens are so restrictive that bending them is the only option for researchers who are working to provide protection from deadly diseases that affect the developing world. Why, they ask, prosecute Butler for breaking the rules that made his work more difficult without serving a useful purpose?
The supporters consider that the charge laid against Butler merely reflects the determination of federal prosecutors to throw the book at Butler to make an example of him to others. Many researchers now fear falling victim to an overzealous prosecution if they fail to dot all the i’s and cross all the i’s on their paperwork. Some US microbiologists are so frightened of being hauled off in handcuffs for a minor administrative error that they have decided to avoid biodefense research entirely—despite the current funding boom in the field.
Whether Butler is a villain or a scapegoat is now for a jury to decide. But whatever verdict is eventually reached, scientists who are lobbying on Butler’s behalf would do well to consider public perceptions. If the rules governing the import of pathogenic bacteria make no sense, then microbiologists must make that case clearly, and lobby for the regulations to be changed. Researchers are also justified in making statements to help ensure that any punishment that Butler might receive is proportionate.
But researchers risk a damaging public protest if the main message that emerges is that his peers think he was justified in carrying samples of the plague bacterium onto a commercial flight. Appearing to deny the importance of rules designed to protect the public from deadly pathogens—however unwieldy those rules may be in practice— will not generate trust. It will not foster a culture of responsibility. And it would show disregard for the public’s faith that scientific research will be conducted as safely and as competently as possible.
The author believes that scientists should______.
选项
A、advocate for the abolition of import rules
B、speak in defense of Butler’s behavior
C、give careful attention to public health
D、learn a lesson from Butler’s case
答案
C
解析
本题考查作者观点。文章末段首句指出“如果认为携带鼠疫细菌样本乘坐商业飞机是正当的,那么会遭到公众的强烈反对”;第二句指出,“会失去公众的信任”;第三句指出,“不会培养出一种富有责任感的文化氛围”;末句指出,“同时会表现出对公众想法的漠视”。综合全段可以总结出,作者并没有为巴特勒辩护,相反,他不赞成为了做科学研究而置民众的身体健康于不顾这种行为,所以[B]错误。从上述分析也可推出,作者借公众的话明确表明自己的观点,即科学研究应该尽可能安全、有效。换句话说,科学研究应尽可能不危害人民的健康。第五段第三句提到,如果科学家认为与携带病原体细菌有关的规定都是毫无意义的废话,那么他们应该建议议员修改这些规定(to be changed)。[A]项的“废除”(abolition)与原文相悖,所以排除。[D]项原文未提及。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/pl4O777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
Researchersinmanycountrieshaveobservedthatmiddleclasschildrenasagrouparemoresuccessfulintheeducationalsystem
Researchersinmanycountrieshaveobservedthatmiddleclasschildrenasagrouparemoresuccessfulintheeducationalsystem
AimlessnesshashardlybeentypicalofthepostwarJapanwhoseproductivityandsocialharmonyaretheenvyoftheUnitedStates
AimlessnesshashardlybeentypicalofthepostwarJapanwhoseproductivityandsocialharmonyaretheenvyoftheUnitedStates
OncefoundalmostentirelyinthewesternUnitedStatesandinAsia,dinosaurfossilsarenowbeingdiscoveredonallsevencont
TheUnitedStatesDeclarationofIndependencewasdraftedandsignedin
WilliamFaulknerwasborninOxford,Miss.Hehad【1】education,thenhejoinedtheBritishRoyalAirForceinCanadabecausehew
WilliamFaulknerwasborninOxford,Miss.Hehad【1】education,thenhejoinedtheBritishRoyalAirForceinCanadabecausehew
Oncefound"almostentirelyinthewesternUnitedStatesandinAsia,dinosaurfossilsarenowbeingdiscoveredonallsevencon
随机试题
在PowerPoint2010中,使用幻灯片浏览视图,可以完成的操作是________。
在国际贸易支付中,属于汇付支付方式的是()
A、去枕平卧位B、半卧位C、头低足高位D、头肩抬高15度~30度E、勤翻身,变换体位护理急性颅内压增高患儿应选择()
理中丸具有的功效是()。
在一个建设项目中,具有独立的设计文件,且建成后可以独立发挥生产能力或效益的工程是:(2019年第66题)
甲公司为境内上市公司,2×17年发生的有关交易或事项包括以下内容:①收到增值税出口退税200万元;②收到控股股东现金捐赠500万元;③收到税务部门先征后返的增值税税款1200万元;④收到财政部门发放的补偿以前期间研究阶段项目财政补助资金1600
以普及家庭教育知识、提高家长教育水平,促进家校有机结合的家校联系形式是()。
海洋是潜力巨大的资源宝库,也是支撑未来发展的战略空间。我国海域辽阔,海洋资源丰富,开发潜力巨大。经过多年发展,我国海洋经济取得显著成就.对国民经济和社会发展发挥了积极带动作用。大力发展海洋经济,进一步提高海洋经济的质量和效益,对于提高国民经济综合竞争力,加
旅途是一幅展开的山水长卷,大漠孤烟直,长河落日圆,松间明月,石上清泉……一路走来,尽收眼底;细细品味,意趣盎然。那岸边的垂柳,柔条如发,随风摇曳;路边的小花,纤蕊若斯,带露绽开。置身于旭日清风的抚慰,流连于茂林修竹的环抱,静听鸟语,轻嗅花香,有何胸中块垒不
Whatistheauthor’sopinionaboutwork?Accordingtothepassage,tobetoldtodosomethingisgenerally______.
最新回复
(
0
)