首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
There is one last question I must deal with in this chapter. Why should human beings be moral? Another way of putting the proble
There is one last question I must deal with in this chapter. Why should human beings be moral? Another way of putting the proble
admin
2013-03-27
69
问题
There is one last question I must deal with in this chapter. Why should human beings be moral? Another way of putting the problem is as follows; Is there any clear foundation or basis for morality? Can any reasons be found for human beings to be good and do right acts rather than be bad and do wrong acts?
I have already pointed out the difficulties involved in founding morality on religion, and especially on religion as a safe factor.(1)
However, if a person has religious faith, then he or she does have a foundation for a personal morality, even though this foundation is basically psychological rather than logical in nature. What disturbs me about the use of religion as the foundation of morality is the frequently-made assumption that if there is no supernatural or religious basis for morality, then there can be no basis at all.
A related, and perhaps deeper, statement is that there can be no real meaning to human life: unless there is some sort of afterlife or some other extra-natural reason for living.(2)
It is obvious that for many individuals this is psychologically true; that is, they feel that their existence has meaning and purpose and that they have a reason for being moral if and only if there is a God, an afterlife, or some sort of religion in their lives.
I feel that we must respect this point of view and accept the conviction of the many people who hold it, because that is how they feel about life and morality.
It is also obvious, however, that many people do not feel this way.(3)
I think it is terribly presumptuous of religious believers to feel that if some people do not have a religious commitment, their lives are meaningless, or that such people have no reason for being moral in their actions.
But if religion does not necessarily provide a "why" for morality, then what does? Let us assume for a moment that there is no supernatural morality and see if we can find any other reasons why people should be moral.
Enlightened Self-interest
One can certainly argue on a basis of enlightened self-interest, that it is, at the very least, generally better to be good rather than bad and to create a world and society that is good rather than one that is bad. As a matter of fact, self-interest is the sole basis of one ethical theory, ethical egoism. I am not, however, suggesting at this point that one ought to pursue one’s own self-interest. I am merely presenting the argument that if everyone tried to do and be good and to avoid and prevent bad, it would be in everyone’s self-interest. For example, if within a group of people no one killed, stole, lied, or cheated, then each member of the group would benefit.(4)
An individual member of the group could say, "It’s in my self-interest to do good rather than bad because I stand to benefit if I do and also because I could be ostracized or punished if I don’t. " Therefore, even though it is not airtight, the argument from enlightened self-interest is a somewhat compelling one.
Argument from Tradition and Law
Related to the foregoing argument is the argument from tradition and law. This argument suggests that because traditions and laws, established over a long period of time, govern the behavior of human beings and because these traditions and laws urge human beings to be moral rather than immoral, there are good reasons for being so.(5)
Self-interest is one reason, but another is respect for the human thought and effort that has gone into establishing such laws and traditions and transferring them from one historic period and one culture to another. This can be an attractive argument, even though it tends to suppress questioning of traditions and laws—a kind of questioning that is, I feel, the very touchstone of creative moral reasoning.
It is interesting to note that most of us probably learned morality through being confronted with this argument, the religious argument, and the experiences surrounding them. Don’t we all remember being told we should or should not do something because it was or was not in our own self-interest, because God said it was right or wrong, or because it was the way we were supposed to act in our family, school, society, and world?
(5)
选项
答案
自利观是原因之一,但另一个原因是对人类的思想和努力的尊重。正是这些思想和努力使法律和传统得以形成,并从某个历史时期、某种文化传承到另一个历史时期和另一种文化。这个观点具有吸引力,尽管它倾向于压制人们对传统和法律提出质疑——这种质疑,我认为,是对创造性道德的理性思考的试金石。
解析
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/tjmO777K
0
考博英语
相关试题推荐
Ithasbeenarguedthatwhereschoolsbecomebureaucratized,theybecomeboundupwiththetechniquesandimplementationofthe
Atallageandatallstagesoflife,fearpresentsaproblemtoalmosteveryone."Wearelargelytheplaythingsofourfears,"
Althoughthegovernmentstillenjoysahighlevelofpublicsupport,thecrimeproblemhasstirredpolitical______andsuspicions
5.____intheirislandcommunity,thevarioustribesusedlanguageswhichbecamemoreandmoresimilartoeachother’s.
Criticismofresearchlaysasignificantfoundationforfutureinvestigativework,butwhenstudentsbegintheirownprojects,t
Criticismwithoutsuggestingareasofimprovementisnot______andshouldbeavoidedifpossible.
Culturalknowledgeconsistsoftherules,categories,assumptions,definitions,andjudgmentsthatpeopleusetoclassifyandin
Whatarethechancesthatwewillencountersomealienformoflife,asweexplorethegalaxy.Iftheargumentaboutthetimesc
Writeanessayonthegiventopic,OnUnrestrainedConsumption.Basedonthefollowingoutline,presentyourargumentwithsuppo
随着工业的快速发展,人类使用化石能源,创造了巨大的物质财富,但同时也产生了大量污染物和温室气体。全球能源、气候变化和环境问题越来越突出,成为我们面临的共同挑战。这次会议就这个重大战略性问题交换看法,反映出本地区国家加强合作,应对挑战的愿望和决心。
随机试题
甲级设备监理单位注册资金不得少于()万元。
患者男,27岁。因“右手示指掌指关节处掌面被锐器刺伤3小时”来诊。查体:示指呈伸直位,感觉障碍,手指苍白、发凉,Allen试验阳性。最适宜的处理方式是
患者,女,35岁,昨日因头痛、发热、鼻塞、流涕、服用感冒药物,今晨突然呕吐咖啡样液体及黑便,总量约为500ml,来急诊。体检:血压为90/60mmHg,脉搏为100次/min,肝脾无肿大。应首选下列哪项检查
以通幽汤治疗噎膈,取其功能为()以启膈散治疗噎膈,取其功能为()
国外工程咨询公司在( )方面发挥作用。
根据《建筑法》的规定,在建的建筑工程因故中止施工的,建设单位应当自中止施工之日起()内,向发证机关报告,并按照规定做好建设工程的维护管理工作。
今年年初,严重影响我国华北华东地区的灰霾天气再次引发人们对PM2.5的关注。以下关于PM2.5的说法错误的一项是()。
庄子,姓庄,名周,字子休(一说子沐),【R51】______中期宋国蒙人,先祖是宋国君主宋戴公,是东周著名的【R52】______、哲学家和文学家。他创立了重要的华夏哲学学派“庄学”,是继老子之后道家学派的主要代表人物之一。庄周因崇尚【R53】_
请在“答题”菜单下选择“演示文稿”命令,然后按照题目要求再打开相应的命令,完成下面的内容,具体要求如下:注意:下面出现的所有文件都必须保存在考生文件夹下。打开考生文件夹下的演示文稿yswg.ppt,按照下列要求完成对此文稿的修饰并保存。
Hemingwayoncewrotethatcourageisgraceunderpressure.ButIwouldratherthinkwiththe18th-centuryItaliandramatist,Vit
最新回复
(
0
)