2. 考研
  3. When is it permissible to tell a lie? Never, according to Augustine and Kant. Machiavelli approved lying for princes, Nietzsche

When is it permissible to tell a lie? Never, according to Augustine and Kant. Machiavelli approved lying for princes, Nietzsche

admin2023-03-22  63
问题     When is it permissible to tell a lie? Never, according to Augustine and Kant. Machiavelli approved lying for princes, Nietzsche for the exceptional hero—the Superman. Most other philosophers, and ordinary folk, are less certain, allowing some lies, but not others. After some 2,500 years of moral speculation, says Philosopher Sissela Bok, mankind is still trying to work out ground rules for acceptable lying.
    1.  Mental reservation as a type of lying.
    In her new book, Lying, Bok traces the history of convoluted arguments on the subject. For in-stance, casuists invented the "mental reservation."
    2.  Casual lying frequently used in America.
    Most norms on lying, Bok writes, grow out of elaborate moral systems of thought that "are often elegant in operation, noble in design. But when we have to make difficult concrete moral choices, they give us little help." In the absence of clear social guidelines, casual lying has become entrenched in America,
    3.  Lying accepted in academic circle.
    Bok also argues that lying is now an accepted part of many professions, including law and the behavioral sciences.
    4.  Lying in journalism.
    Bok sees problems in journalism too. Those lies reported on TV or newspapers, she maintains, were not clearly necessary and may encourage other reporters to use such tactics routinely. Reporters Bernstein and Woodward, however, seemed untroubled by "the whole fabric of deception".
    5.  Should political lies be approved?
    By this standard, she argues, political lies are rarely justifiable. "If government duplicity is to be al-lowed in exceptional cases," Bok concludes, "the criteria for these exceptions should themselves be openly debated and publicly chosen. Otherwise government leaders will have free rein to manipulate and distort the facts." Then what kinds of lies should be permitted? Bok’s answer only those approved in advance by the general public.
    Bok feels that doctors should stop virtually all lying to patients, universities should root out fraudulent and deceptive research, and government officials should be expected to stick to the truth. Her point: the public is now so cynical about being lied to that only extraordinary efforts to avoid lying will restore a feeling of trust. Or, as Mark Twain once observed, "Always do right. This will gratify some people, and astonish the rest."
    [A]   For instance, they used to uncover the Watergate scandal.
    [B]   Social Psychologist Jerald Jellison estimates that the average American outstrips Pinocchio by telling 200 lies a day, including white lies and false excuses ("Sorry I’m late. I was tied up at the office").
    [C]  The use of unmarked police cars is one example of socially approved deception.
    [D]   For instance, Grotius said that speaking falsely to an intruder is not a lie. This, Bok suggests, would be something like knocking a man to the ground, then explaining that you did not hit him because he had no right to be there.
    [E]   In a typical experiment in social psychology, for example, a subject is misled about the aims of the study to see how he reacts under pressure.
    [F]  The phrase can be best interpreted by this example: "Mr. Smith is not in today"—a lie that is magically transformed into a truth by adding the unspoken thought "to you."
    【D1】→【D2】→【D3】→【D4】→【D5】
【D6】
选项
答案F
解析 本段小标题为“保留意见(Mental reservation)也是说谎的一种方式”。F所举例子说的是一句谎话在补上某些一般不说出口的限定条件之后就未必是谎言，言下之意，这种有所保留的表达方式也是说谎行为，论证的正是本段标题的观点。其中，F的unspoken thought表达出reservation“有所保留”的意思，而The phrase实际上指的正是诡辩家提的“mental reservation”这个说法。因此确定F为正确答案。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/v7MD777K
0

考研英语一

相关试题推荐
随机试题
最新回复(0)