首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
The Roslin Institute announced last week that it had applied to patent the method by which its scientists had cloned Dolly the s
The Roslin Institute announced last week that it had applied to patent the method by which its scientists had cloned Dolly the s
admin
2010-07-19
47
问题
The Roslin Institute announced last week that it had applied to patent the method by which its scientists had cloned Dolly the sheep. The patent, if granted, would apply to "nuclear transfer technology" in both human and animal cells. One point of the patent is to help fund research into cures for diseases such as Parkinson’s, Alzheimer’s, cancer and heart failure.
Its other aim is to make some money. Last May, the Roslin Institute was taken over by Geron, an American biotech company. Geron has committed $32.5 million to research at the Roslin. It wants to get its money back. Two scientists from Stanford who developed the use of restriction enzymes, one of the fundamental techniques in biotechnology, made about pounds 80 million out of it in the 17 years before the patent expired. So you can see why Geron-Roslin is so keen to get its patent. There’s nothing wrong with that. Without the prospect of a return at the end of investment, no one would ever lend money to anyone involved in bio-medical research—and given the huge sums now required to develop a new drug, or a new diagnostic test for some medical condition, that would mean there wouldn’t be any research. It is wonderful when people give money to worthwhile causes with no hope of personal gain. But appealing to altruism simply won’t raise the billions required to develop and market drugs and therapies that rely on biotechnology. For that, you have to appeal to investors’ self-interest—which is why the bulk of medical research is funded not by charities or even tax-payers but by private companies and individuals.
The fact that biotech research depends on patents generates profound hostility. The opposition to the patenting of genetic sequences, cells, tissues and clones—critics call it "the privatization of nature"—takes many forms, from a Luddite desire to stop scientific research to a genuine, if mistaken, conviction that common ownership is always morally preferable to private property. But all of the objections have a single root. the sense that it must be wrong to make money out of the constituents of the human body. They cannot be "owned" by any individual, because they belong to everyone. There cannot be "property in people".
That is a profound mistake. The truth is rather the opposite: there is only property in things because there is property in people. People own their own bodies, and that ownership is the basis of their property rights (and most other individual rights, come to that). The problem with the law as it stands is that it doesn’t sufficiently recognize an individual’s property rights over his or her own body, and his or her entitlement to make money out of it.
The outcome of a lawsuit in the US nearly 10 years ago defined the de facto rules governing the ownership of human tissues, and the financial exploitation of the discoveries that derive from them. In Moorev the Regents of UCLA the issue was whether an individual was entitled to a share of the profits that a biotech company made from developing drugs or treatments derived from cells that came from his body. Dr David Golde had discovered that John Moore, one of his patients, had a pancreas whose cells had some unusual properties that might be helpful in treating a form of cancer. In his laboratory, Golde developed what his called a "cell line" from Moore’s cells and patented it. When Moore found out, he sued Dr Golde for a share of whatever profits the cell line generated.
Mr. Moore lost. The court said he had no right to any of those profits, because he did not own the cells removed from his body. Moreover, the court held that since "research on human cells plays a critical role in medical research", granting property rights to the patient from whom the cells came threatened to "hinder research by restricting access to the raw materials".
In essence, that decision said that biotech companies could own and make money out of human cells and tissue—but the person from whom that tissue or cells came could not. The logic behind that decision is bizarre. No one except the most unreconstructed communist disputes that I own my own body. Indeed, it is only because I own my body that I can come to own anything else independent of it, mixing my labor with something being the most fundamental means by which I can come to own it. If cells from Mr. Moore’s body are his property, how can anyone else come to own them—unless he sells or gives those cells to them? (778 words)
Which of the following statements is true?
选项
A、Without a prospect of a of at the end of investment, no one would ever lend money to anyone involved in bio-medical research.
B、Private fund is the most important financial source for scientific research.
C、It is commonly agreed that people can dispose their own body organs because of their ownership.
D、Commercial use of body organs is unconstitutional in the US.
答案
D
解析
三个备选答案,根据文章内容均可判断是正确的。第一项如果投资没有回报的话,恐怕没有人愿意借钱给任何人去做生物医学研究。B不对,私人企业和个人投资是进行医学研究重要的资金来源,但不能就此理解为“最重要的”。C不正确,从第四段可见,有反对观点认为“身体并非人们的私有财产”。 D所述内容文中未提到。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/wAlO777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
GettingtotheheartofKuwaitidemocracyseemshilariouslyeasy.Armedonlywithadog-earedNEWSWEEKID,Iambledthroughthe
WhichofthefollowingisNOTaromanticpoet?
ItcanbeinferredfromthefirstparagraphthatThereisaboomingmarketforfor-profituniversitiesbecause
目前美国的所谓“人文教育”(liberalartseducation)的理念,在中国颇有些鼓吹者。但“人文教育”后面还有体育这一层。体育是学习人生的最好手段。体育和人生的关系,如同数学和科学的关系一样。因为体育能够把人生中千变万化的现象,抽象为几个最简
Accordingtothedoctor,KapsakandEkaUdo’schildrenAllofthefollowingcanbeinferredfromthepassageEXCEPTthat
Theholidaybeganasawaytohonorsoldierskilledduring______.
Itcanbeinferredfromthetextthatoneofthemajorobjectivesofaffirmativeactionisto______.Connerlyinsiststhatthe
Sub-SaharanAfricancountries______.ThepopulationgrowthrateintheUSis______.
TheheirtotheBritainCrownisalsocalled______?
Sydneyislocatedin______.
随机试题
以下不属于学前儿童基础动作模式的是()
辨证应当明确的内容有
设备信息管理系统中的进度控制子系统应实现的基本功能包括()。
《首次公开发行股票并上市管理办法》规定“最近3年内实际控制人没有发生变更”的立法意图有( )。
正保公司委托乙企业加工用于连续生产的应税消费品,正保公司和乙企业均为增值税一般纳税人,适用的增值税税率均为17%,适用的消费税税率为10%,正保公司对原材料按实际成本进行核算,收回加工后的A材料用于继续生产应税消费品一B产品。有关资料如下。 (1)20
案例: 2006年7月10日,甲与乙订立买卖合同,以500万元的价格向乙购买一套精装修住房。当日,甲支付了40万元定金,乙将房屋交付给甲。双方约定:甲应于8月1日之前付清余款;乙应在收到余款后3日内办理房屋过户手续。7月15日,当地突降特大暴雨,该房屋被
建立一支核心队伍是培养班集体的一项重要工作。
心血管循环系统疾病是目前除癌症以外最危险的致死疾病。心脏病发作、中风、血栓形成——没有其他死因像心血管循环系统损伤那样在德国夺走了如此多的生命。德国今年约有近40万人死于心血管循环系统疾病,几乎占全部死亡病例的一半。心性死亡是从天而降的吗?它是让人无可奈何
TheproportionofworkscutforthecinemainBritaindroppedfrom40percentwhenIjoinedtheBBFCin1975tolessthan4per
Morethanonce______usbynowtoadheretotherulesanddisciplinesofouruniversity.
最新回复
(
0
)