首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Plato’s Republic has been the source of great consternation, especially in literary circles, for its attack on the poets. Socrat
Plato’s Republic has been the source of great consternation, especially in literary circles, for its attack on the poets. Socrat
admin
2019-08-27
45
问题
Plato’s Republic has been the source of great consternation, especially in literary circles, for its attack on the poets. Socrates in fact asserts that they should have no place in the ideal state. Eric Havelock suggests that there are several misunderstandings in this regard, and in his Preface to Plato he identifies the issues, explains the historical context.
Havelock opens his discussion by suggesting that the very title of the Republic is the source of much confusion. The book is commonly understood to be a treatise on the ideal political entity, but even a casual analysis will show that only one-third of the text is concerned with statecraft. The other two-thirds cover a variety of subjects, but the thrust of Plato’s argument amounts to an attack on the traditional Greek approach to education.
The educational methods still in use in the 4th century BC had their origins in what has been-called the Greek Dark Age beginning around 1200 BC when the Mycenaean era collapsed. Very little is known about the whys and wherefores of this collapse, but it wasn’t until around 700 BC that the Phoenician alphabet began to be adapted and used in the Greek-speaking world. During the intervening centuries, all knowledge concerning Greek history, culture, mores and laws were orally transmitted down through the generations. The most effective device in aid of memorizing vast amounts of information was rhyme. The epic form we see in Homer’s Iliad grew out of the need to preserve the Greek cultural memory. Havelock takes the reader through Book 1 of The Iliad and dissects it in detail to show how this cultural, historical and ethical heritage was conveyed. The Iliad takes on new and significant meaning to the reader of this minute examination.
The Iliad and presumably other poetic vehicles were taught to children from an early age. The whole of the Greek-speaking world was immersed in the project of memorizing, and out of the masses arose those individuals with superior memories and theatrical skills who became the next generation of minstrels and teachers. Education was thus comprised of memorization and rote learning, and the people enjoyed constant reminders through public readings and festivals.
Plato’s focus in the Republic and elsewhere is on Homer and Hesiod and to some extent the dramatists which at the time were the centerpieces of the educational regime. Their works presented gods and heroes as fundamentally immoral and thus bad examples for youth. The overall result is that the Greek adolescent is continually conditioned to an attitude which at bottom is cynical. It is more important to keep up appearances than to practice the reality. Decorum and decent behavior are not obviously violated, but the inner principle of morality is. Once the Republic is viewed as a critique of the educational regime, Havelock says that the logic of its total organization becomes clear.
What Plato was railing against was an "oral state of mind" which seems to have persisted even though the alphabet and written documentation had been in use for three centuries. Illiteracy was thus still a widespread problem in Plato’s time, and the poetic state of mind was the main obstacle to scientific rationalism and analysis. This is why Plato regarded the poetic or oral state of mind as the arch-enemy. In his teachings he did the opposite. He asked his students to "think about what they were saying instead of just saying it". The epic had become, in Plato’s view, not "an act of creation but an act of reminder and recall" and contributed to what Havelock terms "the Homeric state of mind". It was Socrates’ project (and by extension Plato’s) to reform Greek education to encourage thinking and analysis. Thus all the ranting and railing about the "poets" in Plato’s Republic was limited basically to Homer and Hesiod because of what he viewed as a wholly inadequate approach to education of which these particular poets were an integral part.
Unfortunately, Western culture has misconstrued what Plato and Socrates meant by "the poets". And because we view poetry as a highly creative and elevated form of expression, our critics have failed to recognize that Plato’s diatribe had a very specific and limited target which had nothing to do with high-minded creativity, of which there is plenty, by the way, in the proscribed poets. It wasn’t really the poets who were the problem; it was the use of them that was deemed unacceptable.
Post-Havelock, we can now read the Republic with the scales lifted from our eyes and see it for what it really was: an indictment of an antiquated educational regime which had no place in a democratic society.
A common critique of the present-day Chinese educational system resembles the educational system that Plato fulminated against in that it often______.
选项
A、asks students to think about what they were saying instead of just saying it
B、comprises memorization and rote learning
C、has a very specific and limited target
D、encourages thinking and analysis
答案
B
解析
根据第六段中的“The epic had become,in Plato’s view, not‘an act of creation but an act of reminder and recall”可知,柏拉图认为,史诗已经不再是一种创造行为,而只是一种回忆和记忆方式。据此可知,B项“包括记忆和死记硬背”正确。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/yZUO777K
0
考博英语
相关试题推荐
Farmersinthedevelopingworldhatepricefluctuations.Itmakesithardtoplanahead.Butmostofthemhavelittlechoice:th
Sleepisanimportantpartofourlives.Wespendaboutone-thirdofourlivessleeping.Formillionsofpeople,【C1】______,gett
Americanstodaydon’tplaceaveryhighvalueonintellect.Ourheroesareathletes,entertainers,andentrepreneurs,notschola
Ingeneral,oursocietyisbecomingoneofgiantenterprisesdirectedbyabureaucraticmanagementinwhichmanbecomesasmall,
Agreatdealofattentionisbeingpaidtodaytotheso-calleddigitaldivide—thedivisionoftheworldintotheinfo(informatio
Agreatdealofattentionisbeingpaidtodaytotheso-calleddigitaldivide—thedivisionoftheworldintotheinfo(informatio
Allanimalsmustrest,butdotheyreallysleepasweknowit?Theanswertothisquestionseemsobvious.Ifananimalregularly
Allanimalsmustrest,butdotheyreallysleepasweknowit?Theanswertothisquestionseemsobvious.Ifananimalregularly
Americansocietyisnotnap(午睡)friendly.Infact,saysDavidDinges,asleepspecialistattheUniversityofPennsylvaniaSchool
Researchershavestudiedthepoorasindividuals,asfamiliesandhouseholds,asmembersofpoorcommunities,neighborhoodsand
随机试题
工程招标代理机构资格分为甲、乙两级。()
A.尿道球腺B.精囊腺C.前列腺D.尿道球腺E.输精管壶腹鸡气管分叉处形成的特殊结构是()
小儿1岁,可见胸骨串珠,膈肋沟,手镯及脚镯,前囟为1.5cm×1.5cm,血钙为2.25mmol/L,血磷1.0mmol/L,X线可见于骺端呈杯口状改变,临时钙化带消失,诊断为
急性肾小球肾炎最常见的临床表现为()
根据《标准施工招标文件》中“通用合同条款”的规定,下列情况中承包人无权要求发包人延长工期和(或)增加费用的是()。
我国金融衍生品市场按资产类别划分主要包括利率类衍生品、()、货币类衍生品、信用类衍生品。
嘉业股份有限公司于2008年6月在上海证券交易所上市,截至2014年12月31日,股本总额8亿股,净资产6亿元。2015年2月5日,公司董事会对以下几种融资方案进行讨论:(1)发行优先股方案:公开发行优先股3亿股,筹资4亿元。(2)向原股东配股方案:
张老师认为一年级的学生都还小,当面数落学生几句难听话也没有任何问题。你认为张老师的观点()。
教养这东西,人家以为要出身名门才能拥有。其实这是一种常识,只要稍加注意都可学到,和你的出身没有关系。没有教养的人是懒惰的人,不求上进的人。教养这东西是自发的,自己肯学一定能学会。这段文字告诉我们:
行政违法的构成要件包括()。
最新回复
(
0
)