首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
Who’s poor in America? That’s a question hard to answer. Hard because there’s no conclusive definition of poverty. Low income ma
Who’s poor in America? That’s a question hard to answer. Hard because there’s no conclusive definition of poverty. Low income ma
admin
2017-07-09
58
问题
Who’s poor in America? That’s a question hard to answer. Hard because there’s no conclusive definition of poverty. Low income matters, though how low is unclear. Poverty is also a state of mind that fosters self-defeating behavior—bad work habits, family breakdowns, and addictions. Finally, poverty results from bad luck: accidents, job losses, disability.
Despite poverty’s messiness, we’ve measured progress against it by a single statistic; the federal poverty line. By this measure, we haven’t made much progress. But the apparent lack of progress is misleading for two reasons.
First, it ignores immigration. Many immigrants are poor and low-skilled. They add to the poor. From 1989 to 2007, about three quarters of the increase in the poverty population occurred among Hispanics(西班牙裔美国人) —mostly immigrants and their children.
Second, the poor’s material well-being has improved. The official poverty measure obscures this by counting only pre-tax cash income and ignoring other sources of support, including food stamps and housing subsidies. Although many poor live from hand to mouth, they’ve participated in rising living standards. In 2005, 91% had microwaves, 79% air-conditioning, and 48% cell phones.
The existing poverty line could be improved by adding some income sources and subtracting some expenses. Unfortunately, the administration’s proposal for a "supplemental poverty measure" in 2011 goes beyond that. The new poverty number would compound public confusion. It also raises questions about whether the statistic is tailored to favor a political agenda.
The "supplemental measure" ties the poverty threshold to what the poorest third of Americans spend on food, housing, clothing, and utilities. The actual threshold will probably be higher than today’s poverty line. Many Americans would find this curious; people get richer, but "poverty" stays stuck.
What produces this outcome is a different view of poverty. The present concept is an absolute one; the poverty threshold reflects the amount estimated to meet basic needs. By contrast, the new measure embraces a relative notion of poverty; people are automatically poor if they’re a given distance from the top, even if their incomes are increasing.
The new indicator is a "propaganda device" to promote income redistribution by showing that poverty is stubborn or increasing. The Census Bureau has estimated statistics similar to the administration’s proposal. In 2008, the traditional poverty rate was 13.2% ; estimates of the new statistic range up to 17%. The new poverty statistic exceeds the old, and the gap grows larger over time.
As senator Daniel Moynihan said, the administration is defining poverty up. It’s reasonable to debate how much we should aid the poor or reduce economic inequality. But the debate should not be swayed by misleading statistics that few Americans could possibly understand. Government statistics should strive for political neutrality. This one fails.
What does the author want to say by quoting Daniel Moynihan?
选项
A、Economic equality is but an empty dream.
B、Political neutrality can never be achieved.
C、The administration’s statistics are biased.
D、The debate over poverty will get nowhere.
答案
C
解析
引证题。根据题干关键词Daniel Moynihan定位到文章末段。作者在文章末段借Daniel Moynihan的观点指出,政府数据应该具有政治中立性,而新标准中的数据不具有中立性,也就是说,新标准中的政府数据存在偏见。所以,C项为正确答案。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/98bZ777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
【F1】Americansnolongerexpectpublicfigures,whetherinspeechorinwriting,tocommandtheEnglishlanguagewithskillandg
YouwereunabletoattendtheexaminationonEnglishWritingbyMr.Whitebecauseyougotsickinthemorning.Writealetterto
Peoplewhoaredepressedareliterallysiekatheart:theyhaveasignificantlyincreasedriskforcardiovasculardisease,andn
Whatshapesmoralemotionsinthefirstplace?Theanswerhaslongbeenevolution,hutinrecentyearsthere’sanincreasingapp
Humanbeingshavetheuniqueabilitytoformulatepersonalgoalsforthemselves.Withoutthisformofpersonaldevelopment,the
It’sbadbiologytoargueagainsttheexistenceofanimalemotions.Scientificresearchinevolutionarybiology,cognitiveethol
Researchhasuncoveredthatcultureisadeterminingfactorwheninterpretingfacialemotions.Thestudyrevealsthatinculture
FortheaverageAmericanlivingintheUnitedStatesislikehavingmorethanhalfamilliondollarsinwealth.Sosaysanewst
随机试题
下列属于扶正治则指导下确立的治法
阴阳的相互转化是
路面施工场界噪声限值为昼间70dB,夜间65dB。当敏感区域噪声不能达标时,应采用控制作业时间等措施,保证居民的夜间休息不受打扰。( )
商业银行流动性风险预警信号有()
严格指示词是指一个语言表达式所具有的如下性质:它所指示的对象不会随着该表达式被使用的具体情境而发生改变。这些情境通常包括表达式的使用主体,表达式被使用的时间、地点、世界状态等等。根据上述定义,下列属于严格指示词的是()。
你单位委托培训机构对20名新同事进行为期4天的培训。但是培训机构说只能对10人进行2天的培训。你作为负责人。怎么处理?
【壬申之乱】2016年历史学统考真题
下列关于数据库设计的叙述中,错误的是
(1)将考生文件夹下FIN文件夹中的文件KIKK.HTML复制到考生文件夹下文件夹DOIN中。(2)将考生文件夹下IBM文件夹中的文件CARE.TXT删除。(3)将考生文件夹下WATER文件夹删除。(4)为考生文件夹下FAR文件夹中的文件START.
A、Itisanonlinecourseforteachinginvestment.B、Itraisesquestionsaboutcareerandleadership.C、Itinvitesprofessionals
最新回复
(
0
)