首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
This week, some 27,000 freshly published research articles will pour into the Web of Science, a vast online database of scientif
This week, some 27,000 freshly published research articles will pour into the Web of Science, a vast online database of scientif
admin
2013-09-16
73
问题
This week, some 27,000 freshly published research articles will pour into the Web of Science, a vast online database of scientific publications. Almost all of these papers will stay there forever, a fixed contribution to the research literature. But maybe five or six will one day receive science’s ultimate post-publication punishment; retraction, the official declaration that a paper is so flawed that it must be withdrawn from the literature. It is reassuring that retractions are so rare, for behind at least half of them lies some shocking tale of scientific misconduct —plagiarism, altered images or faked data—and the other half are admissions of embarrassing mistakes. But retraction notices are increasing rapidly.
Perhaps surprisingly, scientists and editors broadly welcome the trend. "I don’t think there’s any doubt that we’re detecting more fraud, and that systems are more responsive to misconduct. It’s become more acceptable for journals to step in," says Nicholas Steneck, a research ethicist at the University of Michigan. But as retractions become more commonplace, stresses that have always existed in the system are starting to show more vividly.
When the Committee on Publication Ethics(COPE)surveyed editors’ attitudes to retraction two years ago, it found huge differences in policies and practices between journals. That survey led to retraction guidelines that COPE published in 2009. But it’s still the case that editors often have to be pushed to retract. Other frustrations include obscure retraction notices that don’t explain why a paper has been withdrawn, aj tendency for authors to keep citing retracted papers long after they’ve been red-flagged and the fact that many scientists hear ’ retraction’ and immediately think ’misconduct’ a stigma that may keep researchers from coming forward to admit honest errors.
Perfection may be too much to expect from any system that has to deal with human error in all its messiness. But as more retractions hit the headlines, some researchers are calling for ways to improve their handling. Suggested reforms include better systems for linking papers to their retraction notices, more responsibility on the part of journal editors and, most of all, greater clarity about mistakes in research.
The reasons behind the rise in retractions are still unclear. I don’t think that there is suddenly a boom in the production of fraudulent or erroneous work. Instead, the growth in retractions has come from an increased awareness of research misconduct. That’s thanks in part to the setting up of regulatory bodies. These ensure greater accountability for the research institutions, which, along with researchers, are responsible for detecting mistakes.
The growth also owes a lot to the emergence of software for easily detecting plagiarism and image manipulation, combined with the greater number of readers that the Internet brings to research papers. In the future, wider use of such software could cause the rate of retraction notices to dip as fast as it increased, simply because more of the problematic papers will be screened out before they reach publication. On the other hand, editors’ newfound comfort with talking about retraction may lead to notices coming at an even greater rate.
Which of the following is the most suitable title of the text?
选项
A、Online Science Literature; a Mix of Good and Bad
B、Science Publishing: the Trouble with Retractions
C、Article Retractions: Punishment for Scientific Misconduct
D、Removing Scientific Misconduct: a Challenging Task
答案
B
解析
文章第一段指出现象“撤回一一已发表的文章因涉及科学不端行为或存在严重错误而收到发表撤回声明”。第二、三段说明撤回体制中存在的问题。第四段就如何改善撤回方法提出建议。第五、六段解释撤回通告上升的可能原因并预测未来走向。可见,全篇主要围绕“对已发表文章的撤回中存在的问题”展开论述,[B]选项正确。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/I6O4777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
Inmostpartsoftheworld,climatechangeisaworryingsubject.NotsoinCalifornia.AtarecentgatheringofgreenLUMINARIE
Studythefollowinggraphcarefullyandwriteanessayin160-200words.Youressayshouldcoverthesetwopoints:1)proble
Illiteracymaybeconsideredmoreasanabstractconceptthanacondition.WhenafamousEnglishwriterusedthe(1)_____overt
Title:ShouldThereBeCompulsoryRetirementAge?TimeLimit:40minutesWordlimit:about200wordsYourcompositio
Whydidnomemberofthepublicrequestanyhearing?NRCiscriticizedbyCongressmemberschieflybecause
AccordingtotheresearchofNCAR,iftheconcentrationswereheldsteadyat2000levels,______.By"atbest,theresultspoin
Wedarenotplayjokesonher______sheshouldbecomeangry.
Forthispart,youareallowed30minutestowritealettertoyourcollegedean.Yourletter,about120words,shouldincludet
Customhasnotcommonlybeenregardedasasubjectofanygreatmoment.Itistheinnerworkingofownbrainsthatwefeelt
Stopworryingaboutrecession.ThatisthemessagefromAmerica’sR-wordindex.Foreachquarter,we(1)_____howmanystonesin
随机试题
规定企业基本结构和性质的根本性制度是()
电子邮件地址windy.gmail.com中主机域名是()。
鳞状上皮细胞癌细支气管-肺泡细胞癌
为了使病人舒适,利于观察病情应做到
甲公司2007年度长期股权投资情况如下:1.(1)深圳资产100%控股的全资子公司当年实现税后利润150万元,分回利润100万元。(2)湖北资产占50%的子公司亏损50万元(亏损已经当地税务机关认定)。(3)温州一资产75%控股的生产性中外合资企
下列不属于商业银行资本的是()。
事业单位存货的盘点以及银行存款与银行对账单的核对,均为至少每月核对或盘点一次。()
导游服务在各项旅游接待服务中的纽带作用具体表现在()。
某位家长认为孩子的将来取决于是否可以考上奥校,如果可以考上奥校,则将来会考上好大学,如果没有考上好大学,就不会有好前途,而是否可以考上奥校,最关键的是有否多做练习题,因此,他要求孩子不仅要完成老师布置的作业,还要额外做很多习题。则这位家长认为下列
Beinginaclassroomfullof"thebestandbrightest"studentsmaynothelpfringeones,accordingtonewresearchthat【C1】_____
最新回复
(
0
)