首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
It’s a common misconception that poverty alleviation is all about financial aid. People regard this as the most effective way to
It’s a common misconception that poverty alleviation is all about financial aid. People regard this as the most effective way to
admin
2021-02-24
107
问题
It’s a common misconception that poverty alleviation is all about financial aid. People regard this as the most effective way to help the poor. However, some hold that helping the poor with education is more important than donating money. The following excerpts are opinions toward the means of poverty alleviation.
Write an article of NO LESS THAN 300 words, in which you should:
1. summarize briefly the arguments on both sides;
2. give your suggestions on the means of poverty alleviation.
Excerpt 1
Giving money isn’t even a way to help the poor if it was then the various charities should have solved the poverty problem ages ago.
Here on TV every day we see terrible pictures and hear the mournful voiceover asking us to save a child from lack of clean water, starvation, or illness usually somewhere in Africa.
I have heard the same pleas all my adult life and still the problem persists or has got worse, surely in nearly 60 years the people of the West have given enough money to the charities to drill a few thousand wells and buy enough food to feed the entire population... yet it goes on and on.
So therefore I say whatever they have been doing and are still doing is not the answer.
Educating people how to earn money for themselves is more of a help. As an old Chinese proverb goes: Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish and you feed him for a lifetime. I am in favour of teaching people to fish and farm so that they learn to provide for their own. However, you cannot fish in a dry river nor farm where there is no rain...
For charities to continue to sustain life where life cannot sustain itself is madness there just has to be a better way.
Excerpt 2
Poverty is more than just a lack of income. Poverty encompasses a lack of money, education, resources, housing stability, safety, opportunities, etc. It is a complex issue. I worked for over a year helping to house the homeless and I now work as a self sufficiency specialist to help enable those in poverty rise above their circumstances. Where I work we have six categories which have shown reliability and validity when it comes to self sufficiency. Income, either fixed (disability, SSI, retirement, earned, etc), Housing (stable is required, other options are unstable and literally homeless), Food, Education, Transportation, and Health Care. If a client is lacking in any of these areas they are at risk for falling back into poverty and/or remaining in poverty.
Therefore, money can make a huge impact when applied correctly. However, if all we do is pay for the current shut off and provide them with no other resources or opportunities to change the situation overall, they will need another shut-off assist the very next month.
Other ways to help the poor include volunteering at a food bank, volunteering to teach a skill you excel at such as budgeting, how to do your own oil change, writing a resume, etc. Time and knowledge are just as valuable, if not more so, than money.
选项
答案
Want to Help the Poor? Just Give Them Money Many people are disconcerted by the idea of giving money directly to the poor, afraid that without regulations the money would be misused and wasted. The first excerpt echoes this notion, suggesting that education is a more effective alternative to financial aid, as teaching a man to fish works better than giving him a fish. Although the second excerpt underlines the importance of money, it points out that money alone cannot eliminate poverty, and there should be other types of help, such as provision of resources, opportunities, and knowledge. I agree that other kinds of assistance could be considered, but financial support, or more precisely cash transfer, is the best way to help the poor. For decades, it was thought that the poor needed everything done for them. Few people would trust anyone to spend a large sum of money responsibly. Thus governments and charities rationed everything, from food to medical supplies, school to public transportation, with people living in poverty denied the right to make decisions about their needs and priorities. However, we should realize that poverty is as much a deficit in power as a material lack. Why do we think poor people cannot manage money well? In reality, the growing practice and success of cash transfer show that giving money away indeed pulls people out of poverty. According to an experiment conducted by GiveDirectly, a charity trying to help poor people by sending them money with no strings attached, cash recipients did not lavish money upon their pleasures; instead they invested it in their kid’s education, health care, better food or even business. This further proves that giving people wealth is enabling them to feel more in control of their life. In conclusion, cash transfer ensures those who we aim to help can make their decisions about how best to use our assistance. In doing so, they recognize the need for self-reliance and autonomy, therefore unshackling the material and immaterial fetters that poverty places on them.
解析
材料围绕“扶贫的方式”展开讨论,两个选段分别给出了不同的看法。
选段一驳斥了捐款在扶贫中的作用,并以过去六十年里西方对非洲的捐款为例,说明捐款无济于事(is not the answer)。并以中国古语为证:授人以鱼不如授人以渔,强调教育人们(Educating people)如何赚钱产生的帮助更大(more of a help)。
选段二则认为捐款还是有用的,但扶贫的方式不能局限于捐款。因为贫困是一个涉及方方面面的复杂问题(a complex issue)。虽然钱款应用得当能发挥重大作用(make a huge impact),但其他方式的援助也十分重要,而时间和知识(Time and knowledge)的重要性仅次于金钱。
开篇:总结材料中对扶贫方式的两种看法,并提出自己的观点——直接捐钱是最有效的扶贫方式。
主体:阐述捐钱最有效的原因,因为穷人也需要自主掌控人生的权利。
结尾:总结全文,直接给钱能让穷人自主地决定自己的人生。
转载请注明原文地址:https://kaotiyun.com/show/8BIK777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
Whatdoyouneedtodoinordertounderstandthelecture?NowtherearefourthingsthatI’mgoingtotalkabout.Thefirstthi
A、Notfast,notslowly.B、Withabitofchange.C、Slowlybutclearly.D、Witharoaringvoice.B在第一部分对话的最后,男士问女士,演讲速度是要快一些还是慢一些。女
PASSAGETHREEWhatdoes"moralimagination"meaninPara.11?
我喜爱湖。湖是大地的眼睛,湖是一种流动的深情,湖是生活中没有被剥夺的一点奇妙。早在幼年时候,一见到北海公园的太液池,我就眼睛一亮。在贫穷和危险的旧社会,太液池是一个意外的惊喜,是一种奇异的温柔,是一种孩提式的敞露与清流。我常常认为,大地与人之间有
克隆人、千年虫、互联网……我们触目所见的许多东西都在挑战我们的思维和传统。虽然我们应当有勇气来接受和不断地超越人类的局限,可是并非一切发展都无懈可击。无限制的发展和无限制的挥霍一样的可怕,所以西方科学家生活在隐忧中,对未来的科学又喜又惊,反思科学发展成了他
在古罗马,柱子是按照人的比例划分的;到了文艺复兴时期,人就是世界上最美好的尺度。今天的中国城市里,裁弯取直的河渠,向四面八方扩张的交通,膨胀硕大的以便于接纳更多商业行为的城市广场与建筑立面,都在告诉人们建设背后的权力与资本才是审美标准。直到有一天。回过头来
你是否觉得劳生草草,身心两乏?我劝你工余之暇,常到小巷里走走,那是最好的将息,会使你消除疲劳,紧张的心弦得到调整。你如果有时情绪烦燥,心情悒郁,我劝你到小巷里负手行吟一阵,你一定会豁然开朗,怡然自得,物我两忘。你有爱人吗?我建议不要带她去什么名园胜景,还是
A、Herdifferentstyle.B、Herdistinctivevoice.C、Heryoungage.D、Hercoolmusic.B主持人说他试着将Alex与其他歌手进行比较,却发现根本没有可比性。因为女士的声音太独特了
手机刷新了人与人的关系。
人是会病的,孩子也不能幸免,生病是生活的一部分,父母不能包办一切。我一直秉承这一思路,来处理自己和孩子的关系。父母爱孩子,是天性和本能。如何教育孩子,需要学习和实践,本能管不了那么多。孩子一天天长大,能做的事情、能思考的问题逐日增加,越来越多。一切都在潜
随机试题
关于CH50试验不正确的是()
男,40岁,因反复机会性感染入院。检查发现患者伴发卡波西肉瘤。诊断应首先考虑
某厂因污染事故被环境保护部门作出以下处理:(1)责令限期治理;(2)罚款8500元;(3)赔偿受污染单位损失16000元。上述决定中属于行政处罚的是:()
未成年人享有生存权、发展权、受保护权、参与权等权利,国家根据未成年人身心发展特点给予()保护,保障未成年人的合法权益不受侵犯。
A、 B、 C、 D、 B以左边第二格的白色方块为底,可以直接叠成B,并可根据各个面的关系排除A、C、D。
填入下面横线上的两句话,与上下文衔接最恰当的一项是:泰山的南天门又叫三天门,创建于元代,至今已有六百余年。______为“门辟九霄仰步三天胜迹,阶崇万级俯临千嶂奇观”。
2009年1月21日,希拉里.克林顿在美国首都华盛顿宣誓就任美国国务卿。美国参议员当天以94票对2票的绝对优势,批准奥巴马总统关于希拉里担任国务卿的提名。投反对票的两位议员分别是路易斯安那州共产党员大卫.威特和南卡州的共产党参议员吉姆.德敏特。在全院投票之
Itisbadmannerto______otherpeoplebehindtheirbacks.
Cepetitenfantnesaitéplucher(削)des_____.
Theivory-billedwoodpecker,ifyouhaven’theard,isnolongerextinct.Inlatespring,agroupof17researchersannouncedin
最新回复
(
0
)